83

27

Discussions
Posted by Sophie-Ha 16 days ago

K-netizens debate if it's appropriate that a girl group consisting of all Japanese members is performing at a "Korean-Culture" Festival

AKP STAFF

XG is a new global girl group under the label XGALX. The group has been preparing for their debut since 2017 and finally made their entrance into the K-pop industry in March of this year.

However, many have been wondering whether the group should be classified as a K-pop idol group since all of the members are of Japanese nationality.

Additionally, the group has released a single with two tracks that are not in Korean but are sung entirely in English. Therefore, the girls have been considered a global group rather than recognized as a K-pop group.

Recently, a debate began online when it was revealed that XG will be performing at the '2022 Into The-K, K-Culture Festival,' which will be hosted by the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism and overseen by the Korea Foundation for International Cultural Exchange.

    The news that XG will be performing at a Korean Culture festival was shared in a popular online community where K-netizens shared their opinions on this matter.

    Many K-netizens felt that the group should not be considered a K-pop group, especially because all the members are Japanese and they do not sing in Korean. K-Netizens commented, "I heard their music on Spotify because it was recommended to me but they do really sound like BLACKPINK or something...no wonder people mistake them to be a YG group," "I'm not against the group or anything but this event is a K-culture event hosted by the  Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism; they should do a better job selecting artists to perform at a K-culture event," "This is such a random group that was invited," "What's going on Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism?" "Never heard of them," "Why is everyone now saying they're are K-pop?" "We should boycott this event," "The event is called 'The-K' but why is there an all-Japanese group performing?" and, "Even XG themselves say they're not K-pop though."

    1. XG
    131 23,325 Share 75% Upvoted
     
    StayWow-Bebe-Cat
    StayWow-Bebe-Cat114 pts 16 days ago 4
    16 days ago

    I'm just as confused as the Knetz are not gonna lie. I been confused honestly since XG's debut. I don't understand why they are called a kpop group either.

    33 (+35 / -2)
    Share

    4 more replies

     
    eldershawol
    eldershawol279 pts 16 days ago 8
    16 days ago

    I don't think the issue is that they're an all-Japanese group. There are solo Kpop artists who are Japanese, like Yukika, or Thai, like Natty. I think the issue is that, well, they're not a Korean Pop Music group. They sing entirely in English. What about it is Kpop at that point?

    32 (+36 / -4)
    Share

    8 more replies

    SHOW ALL COMMENTS

    allkpop in your Inbox

    THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
    BLACKPINK, Lisa, BTS, V, Jungkook, Jimin, j-hope, ENHYPEN, GOT7, BamBam, NCT 127, NCT Dream, Seventeen, Stray Kids, TREASURE
    15 minutes ago   0   749
    Goo Hye Sun
    3 hours ago   12   14,681
    New Message

    SEND