Upvote if you think more people should see this post!

27

22

News
Posted by KayRosa AKP STAFF 24 days ago

Netizens compare Joy and Tzuyu's stage presence from their cover of Miss A's 'Hush'

Netizens shared their opinions on Joy and Tzuyu's performance on '2018 KBS Gayo Daechukje'.

On December 28th, a handful of girl group members got together for a special performance of Miss A's "Hush". After watching the video (above), netizens took GIFs of Red Velvet's Joy and TWICE's Tzuyu, comparing the performance styles of the two iconic female idols from SM and JYP.

According to the netizens, most thought that Tzuyu was the better performer judging by the dance techniques, but Joy had the upper hand in terms of overall visuals and 'aura'.

Some comments were, "Joy has great facial expressions, but Tzuyu is so good at her JYP-style dancing!" "Both look good -- please get together again next year!" "TZUYU IS SO GORGEOUS" "Look at the details of Tzuyu dancing, even from her finger tips" "Joy has this beautiful gaze that grabs the audience's attention" "TWICE probably had to do the dance really well thanks to J.Y. Park".

Which female idol do you think owned the cover of Miss A's "Hush"?

 

  1. Red Velvet
  2. Joy
  3. TWICE
  4. Tzuyu
  5. NETIZENS
70 91,425 Share 55% Upvoted

43

borahae 24 days ago 3
24 days ago

Joy naturally has a sultrier more feminine performance style as she is a young woman while Tzuyu is still a teen and relies on her professionalism for now, she will grow :)

Share

6

Winston 24 days ago 2
24 days ago

Tzuyu still have the bit of "embarrassing or shy" feeling when asked to do cute or sexy dance, like the recent Idol Room, when asked to do so. while Joy is more bold and daring, like how she did her SNL skits and when her eyes "seduced" Min Kyung Hoon in Knowing Brothers and "melted" Seo Jang Hoon.

But i think both are the best among the 6 performers.

Share

3

Zenning 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Someone called it a 'deer in the headlights' expression, I think that's a fitting description for it.

Her expression wasn't entirely right for the vibe of the song, but Tzuyu has great looks so people are willing to not be bothered by it.


Joy has a sexy vibe from herself in performing, so songs like these are a natural fit for her. And her sultry, sensual expression was a great fit for the vibe of the song. Joy does really well in sexy and sensual concept performances.


I think that Sowon stuck out too, her hair color and style completely transformed her from her usual looks.

Share

-2

keyleejeans20 (Banned) 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

Comment has been deleted

Share

20

cobblestone 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

So proud of Tzuyu's performance, she is starting to get her sixteen era self the (bubbly confident kid). Keep it up and you're doing great Tzuyu👏👏👏

Share

16

Celebration 24 days ago 13
24 days ago

This generation of idols seriously lacks charisma on stage. While it can be argued that they all have more skills, the charisma is terrible. Neither is at all that good. I miss gen 2 and 3. FYI I consider all idols starting from 2015 are gen 4. RV is a transition group, so they are gen 4 too

Share

12

SoshiTwices 24 days ago 5
24 days ago

I thought I was the only one who felt this way seeing everyone praising them. Joy looked as if she only got an hour of sleep the night before. Tzuyu is adorable and that unfortunately didn't play in her favor considering the concept. Miss A really gave off the vibe this song calls for so I was so diasppointed watching.

Share

-2

Celebration 24 days ago 4
24 days ago

Seriously. And you can't say it's because it's not the original performers because Sistar killed it when they covered it. Gen 3 had a healthy mix of above average talent and above average charisma. Gen 2 was light on the skillful but the Charisma of Gen 2 is no joke. Even Suju who frankly sucks to me, had charisma up the woozoo to the point that I know every member's name, whether I like them or not. The complete opposite of groups like NCT, who if you aren't a fan, you can't name even one. (no I can't name one) Same with GG, I can name all of them, I am not a fan of them though. RV? I know names, but if you ask me who is who in RV, I am sorry. I am really not a fan of this generation of idols as a whole. Too boring, not unique, and no to little charisma. I can go on and on about this topic, but I'll stop. Mind you I don't hate RV or NCT, I am just extremely indifferent and underwhelmed.

Share

4 more replies

-1

crowboy 24 days ago 6
24 days ago

hmm, i'm not sure about girl groups but a lot of the boy groups have some very, very charismatic idols (i.e. NCT Taeyong, iKON Bobby, etc.).

Share

6 more replies

12

salongimmine 24 days ago 2
24 days ago

tbh both were on equal level.

But now go back and watch Miss A performing it. You will see the aura, the expression and everything...

everything will just slay you!


Share

-6

Winston 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

unfortunately they are no more, miss A, so lets move on.

Share

0

anna_sueweeties 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

they will always exists in #sayA's heart... back then, now and forever in the future.. no need to highlight their "disbanding" still they all active individually, also just wanna add for those who doesn't know.. even Min not really on news, she's actually still active singing with feat here and there, if u follow her ig... she actively share insta story about her works and enjoyed her current life ^^

Share

7

deputy57 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

Tzuyu had these bizarre wide eyes the entire time, it was particularly bad in that shot right before the bridge. Joys advantage is that her expressions matched the feel of the song. Tzuyu seems to only have one setting perhaps because that's all Twice's concepts call for, but Red Velvet have a fair amount of variety in their concepts. I felt that Mijoo & Joy did the best and Sowon's hair was a nice touch.

Share

0

Joohee11 21 days ago 0
21 days ago

Common she's born with beautiful big eyes, not her fault

Share

6

jalkerw 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Hmmm does anyone else feel like they both actually lacked energy?

also I think Tzuyu had sharper motions but Joy has an expression that matches the mood of the song better.


Share

5

Hopkinz 24 days ago 3
24 days ago

The REAL best performer was Sowon and I don't even stan Gfriend

Share

1

ase 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

cant really watch her perf as i'm distracted by her nose.

Share

0

kpopglasses 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

at least one person on here is giving her recognition, and I'm also not a fan of gfriend

Share

0

Jonis 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

her height really catch on me. she is so tall.

Share

3

Taktak 24 days ago 2
24 days ago

Can y'all not see that Joy was freaking singing live throughout. For me that matters more. Tzuyu did great too but she and some other girls were lip syncing while others were singing live and slaying it. Most people don't even notice it so I'm guessing they sang THAT good lol.

Share

2

Zenning 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

True, I noticed that too.


I like Joy's voice, she has a great vocal tone, I hope she'll get more opportunities to show off her singing in different settings.

Share

0

hexrealm 22 days ago 0
22 days ago

They may be all lip syncing, it depends on the version they use. Just because she sounds live doesn't mean it is.

Share

3

Queen_Sana 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

I like both of them in this cover they both have there own charms loved other four idols as well they just slayed that stage with there amazing coreo and dance

Share

3

strawberrimeii 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

I really liked Tzuyu.

Share

3

Indri_hapsari 24 days ago 2
24 days ago

eventho i am once but have to admit, miss a did it 10 times better than them...there 6 of them n no 1 cant be compare with miss a member's aura n stage presence...suddenly i want miss a to exist again..

Share

3

xxamr 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

Of course Miss A is unbeatable when it comes to their own songs. They had a much longer time to prepare and practice before they promoted Hush. These girls had like what, weeks? Seriously people need to stop comparing covers and original. Covers will never do justice to the original version.

Share

0

Indri_hapsari 14 days ago 0
14 days ago

There r sometimes covers doin better than the original

Share

2

ase 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

i tought they are good, until i went back watching suzy and realized non of them can hold a candle to her.

Share

2

adnirvs 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

The entire performance was very average tbh. So nothing matters.

Share

2

yaya202 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Love Tzuyu ... more innocent.

Share

1

qeemqeem 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

erm. of course tzuyu will dance better. this is like a mandatory dance song to all jyp trainees. lol

Share

1

T_ara_Sone_Blink 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Nice tribute, Miss A was spectacular! But all the girls did a great job! The song is iconic!!

Share

1

girl_group_lover 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

I agree with the netizens. Joy captures the vibe and mood of the song very well. It's dark and eerie, yet sexy (similar to Red Velvet's darker concepts) so I think she's totally in her element. However, when you look at their dance moves, Tzuyu is clearly the one with better dance skills. But the issue with Tzuyu is she's still performing this song as if it's a Twice song (cute and bubbly), which doesn't fit the concept very well. Her expressions look too bright. Like if you hadn't known about this performance and judged soley off of these gifs, you would have no idea Tzuyu was covering a song like Hush.

Share

1

Myjisjash 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

joy got my attention. also tzuyu and yeonwoo last night look like a twin hhaha

Share

1

aldebaran 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

why?... just enoy the performance

Share

1

Winston 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

its sad that while, GFriend Sowon, Oh My Girl Jiho, Momoland Yeonwoo, Lovelyz Mijoo everyone is only talking about Joy and Tzuyu...looking at the Top 10 upvoted comments on Korean portal sites..below


1. [+457, -115] Joy really is super sexy... Tzuyu's pretty but she's young so I don't really feel anything but everything about Joy down to her gaze is whoa

2. [+327, -74] Joy is really Red Velvet's ace

3. [+234, -112] Tzuyu's pretty but has a great body too. Her singing career is already a success but I think she'll be even more successful in the acting scene.

4. [+36, -10] 'Hush' seemed like a stage made for Joy~ she really matched the concept and the song well

5. [+25, -11] Ahhhhhhhh Joy was jjang

6. [+20, -4] I can kind of see some sex appeal in Joy

7. [+19, -7] Joy looks exactly like this in real life... she has that 'Hush' feel to her

8. [+15, -1] Momoland's Yeonwoo is a bit average for me whereas Joy and Tzuyu completely dominate

9. [+14, -0] Tzuyu, Joy are so pretty

10. [+14, -7] Tzuyu's too young whereas Joy really pulled this off, she should get a solo

Share

-4

Soulbrother 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

It wouldn't surprise me if half are manufactured comments from the companies themselves haha, hell the screentime Tzuyu got is clearly more than others. Big three no doubt had their wallets out for this. When imo Sown and Mijoo stood out the most. With hair alone really and legs for Mijoo :D

Share

1

Winston 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

its a JYP song by a JYP trainee, Tzuyu, so it should be NO Surprise that Tzuyu has a better Dance Technique due to her years of practising it as a trainee back then,

i also think that HUSH being a Sexy concept song, Joy did well in the facial expression and aura.


Share

1

Off_the_Recor 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

let’s not kid ourselves. Sowon definitely slays the most

Share

1

Myjisjash 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

probably your opinion. Mine is mijoo and joy. But sowon is stood out as well but for me, still 2 of them

Share

0

Joohee11 21 days ago 0
21 days ago

Tzuyu was just being herself, not trying to act super sexy with crazy facial expressions, that's her style. You see a hint of innocence in her, that's hot.

Share

0

WonderSara 22 days ago 0
22 days ago

Sorry but my eyes were stuck on Sowon, I was surprised on how she rocked this concept and how beautiful she was!

Share

0

Indhys 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

joy try why to hard to look sexy and her stage presence is.... does she have one??



Share

0

razorbladeromanc 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

the sad part is that the other idols who danced with them is not worth comparing at all...

Share

0

lizrosee 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

oh god I'm glad it was a positive comparison and not fans ripping each other down.

Share

0

Toms_K_Trash 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Anyway, it's six of them. It's really annoying when people only talk about Joy and Tzuyu, as if Sowon and Mijoo didn't shine at all, while Jiho and Yeonwoo were able to show a side for which they weren't so well known yet.

Share

0

almondtree 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

both were good imo but none as good as the original which is 99% of the time for any covers. this performance was probably put together in a v short period of time esp when you have so many members of the popular girl groups of this gen.

Share

0

FragleDagle 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

My Boy Joy out here looking on point as ever.

Share

0

vpriyajr 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

i find both quite boring but joy kind of has a sex appeal even though she looks sleepy..

it looks like they both were performing different songs...

if we mute the song, tzuyu looked like she is performing a cute and bubbly song and joy looked like she was performing a hot song..

Share

0

jeyjin 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

I watched the whole performance just to see what they were talking about. I agree with what this article says about Tzuyu and Joy but what stood out to me was the synchronization. It was like they barely rehearsed it. If you watch Miss A's performance, you'll see what i mean.

Share

0

NORM 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Lol, but how will you say Tzuyu is the better performer if you only praised her dance skills... :/

Honestly since she's JYP, i'd be more surprised if her dance for this song was bad.

Share

0

Soulbrother 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Haha this usual popularity contest bullshit. Mijoo stood out to me, and she owned the leg game also. Being biased is fine in the "popularity" contest but you're kidding yourself to think Mijoo doesn't stand out even with the tiny amount of screen time she got haha, Even Sowon on height alone and hair stood out. Over this stupid popularity shit haha Big3 clearly had their wallet open for this

Share

0

eager_beaver 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

"...most thought that Tzuyu was the better performer judging by the dance techniques, but Joy had the upper hand in terms of overall visuals and 'aura'."


I would actually say it was the other way around. But everyone's got an opinion...

Share

0

Winston 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

Personally it i felt JOY > Tzuyu but i get the reason why Tzuyu might have the edge, due to it being JYP song and she has probably danced to it so many times in her trainee days, it like how i would except Yeri to be better at Kissing You than the others.
However Tzuyu seems to be less expressive in Sexy concepts than JOY, JOY is more "daring" when it comes to being Bold and sexy, as shown in her SNL skits and other variety shows.

Share

0

estheram 24 days ago 0
24 days ago

joy always looks like she's ready to sleep onstage lol

Share

-1

I_stan_Ong 22 days ago 0
22 days ago

I'm not hating on Tzuyu but the two idols who caught my eyes the most are Joy and Sowon.

Share

-1

Rita2020 22 days ago 0
22 days ago

Joy catched my attention right from the start she was natural, while the other girls were just mehh

Share

-1

pink_oracle 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

Chewy's outfit definitely makes her stand out more. Joy's giving it more of a sexy vibe though.

Share

-10

Stopudelulu 24 days ago 1
24 days ago

both are boring like hell. They need a good fuck in bed first then only they can improved in this kinda perf

Share

0

Datboiyoongz 23 days ago 0
23 days ago

It’s funny how your name is “Stopudelulu” yet that is what people have to tell you. Just stop your not doing anything but make EVEN MORE people dislike you on this site so let me ask you this, what are you trying to accomplish here dumbass

Share

allkpop in your Inbox