83

8

News

A first generation K-pop idol says the idols these days all sound the same

AKP STAFF
Posted by K-Soul Friday, February 28, 2025 29,455

In a past episode of 'Jae Friends' featuring g.o.d's Son Ho Young and Park Joon Hyung, the first-generation K-pop idols touched upon the current issue of the current generation of idols.

During the episode, Son Ho Young, Park Joon Hyung, and Kim Jae Joong sat down and reminisced about their promotion during the earlier times in the entertainment industry. They also talked about the differences in the idol industry compared to the first generation.

Son Ho Young started on the topic by sharing, "The hardest part for me is figuring out who is singing which part." He continued, "When you hear a track [it's hard to distinguish who's who]. I can't match the member to the voice."

Kim Jae Joong agreed, saying, "It's tricky." Son Ho Young elaborated, "Yeah, [In the past] you'd hear a song and [Right away] know which member is singing. But the voices these days are so similar." Park Joon Hyung added, "But we know which groups are from SM, because SM has a distinct style."


Korean netizens are revisiting this episode and reflecting on the current situation of the idol industry. They commented:

"What he said is true."
"True."
"Oh, so it's a mixing difference that makes it easier to distinguish. Among boy groups, SM has a distinct sound."
"You hear as much as you know. If you've listened to a group a few times, you can tell them apart, but if not, you just don’t know."
"It’s not that newer idols have similar voices or are tuned the same; it’s just that, compared to idols back then, individual recognition is much lower. People can’t match faces to voices, so they just assume they all sound the same."
"Before saying you can’t distinguish them, maybe check if you even know the members’ names, faces, and voices first. 1st-gen idols were on another level when it came to recognition."
"Totally agree, especially with HYBE groups."
"I don’t really get it either. A lot of them mumble and slur their words. But I guess that’s just the trend these days if I don’t like it, I don’t listen."
"It’s all auto-tuned."
"Some groups are distinguishable, and some aren’t, lol."
"Hasn’t it always been like this? You hear as much as you know."
"You hear as much as you know... I couldn’t even tell 1st-gen idols apart, lol."

SEE ALSO: Director Shin Sung Hoon was found dead in May at age 40

  1. g.o.d
  2. Son Ho Young
  3. Park Joon Hyung
  4. Jaejoong
29,455 Share 91% Upvoted

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
H.O.T, Moon Hee Jun, Kangta
Hanni
misc.
Sunmi
Ahn Eun Jin, Doh Kyung Soo (D.O.), Han Hye Jin , Jang Ki Yong, Jeon So Nee, Ji Chang Wook, Jin Seo Yeon, Jin Seon Kyu, Kim Do Hoon, Kim Eui Sung, Kim Hee Sun, Kim Mu Jun, Kim Yoo Jung, Kim Young Dae, Lee Jae Hoon, Lee Jae Wook, Lee Jung Jae, Lee Yoo Mi, Lim Ji Yeon, Seo Ji Hye, Yoon Kye Sang
Krystal, Jessica
Wonstein
Kim Min Ha, Junho (Lee Jun Ho)
BTS, Jungkook
G-Dragon
BTS, V
Hanni
BTS, RM
Kim Eui Sung, Lee Jae Hoon, Pyo Ye Jin
NCT Dream
New Message

SEND