82

45

News
Posted by Janie-Reign Sunday, May 8, 2022

Four members create the best combination for girl groups? Netizens discuss several examples

AKP STAFF

Netizens are wondering if four members for a girl group raises the probability for success.

On an online community forum, a netizen made a post expressing that four members is the best combination for girl groups, "seeing how successful BLACKPINK and aespa are."

Under the post, comments agreed that "having fewer members is definitely better than having too many," and that other examples of successful 4-member girl groups also include SISTAR, 2NE1, and Brave Girls

Even some fans whose bias group had many members acknowledged that having fewer members would be beneficial. On the other hand, others commented that number "does not matter" as long as the group is good at what they do.

Meanwhile, a netizen wrote that "four members is a small, even number," which creates a good "balance." Other comments include: "[Four members] definitely creates an aura," and that having fewer members is better for line distributions and structuring the choreography. 

However, a netizen pointed out that having four members could be an issue if one of them potentially leaves the group. Furthermore, netizens also expressed that having a maximum of six or seven members, considering some successful rookie groups from this year, would be an ideal number.

Do you think 4 is an ideal number of members for a girl group?

Shop the story
BLACKPINK JENNIE Cover: VOGUE KOREA May 2024
$22
BLACKPINK ROSÉ : Dazed & Confused Korea 2024 Spring Edition
$25
BLACKPINK JISOO Cover - W Magazine April 2024
$20
BLACKPINK Official Lightstick ver.2
$63
JISOO First Single Album [ME]
$22
  1. aespa
  2. BLACKPINK
30 29,311 Share 65% Upvoted
 
tagnol8
tagnol82,771 pts Sunday, May 8, 2022 7
Sunday, May 8, 2022

BP and Aespa success is because they are from the big 3, not because they have 4 members.

34 (+37 / -3)
Share

7 more replies

 
kpopfan7
kpopfan7978 pts Sunday, May 8, 2022 0
Sunday, May 8, 2022

I don't think the number of members affects the probability of success. It really boils down to the quality of the stuff they release as well as timing and a little bit of luck.

25 (+25 / -0)
Share

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
New Message

SEND