185

117

News
Posted by Yaki-Jones Saturday, November 27, 2021

Discharged soldier shares his perspective on BTS's military exemption

AKP STAFF

A netizen claiming to be a discharged soldier shared his perspective on BTS's military exemption.

On November 26th, a netizen claiming to be a discharged soldier shared his perspective on BTS's military exemption. He stated the following 6 reasons for wanting the national assembly to expand the military exemption act to include popular cultural artists like BTS.

He wrote in his post: 1. The current military exemption act was established back in 1973. Back then, enhancing the national status and dignity had bigger importance in our society and had different social standards than what we have now. This naturally leads to the necessity of addressing the standards that are apt for 2021. For example, the current law allows people who win first or second place at 'The Seoul International Dance Competition', including other many 'international' competitions. There are people who get exempted from the obligative military duty yet the general public really doesn't know who they are or what they did.  

2. Some might argue that for fairness, those exemptions should be discarded altogether. However, I'm against this stance as the law's ulterior motive is to protect the leakage of talent to other countries due to mandatory duty. Anyone would question what the winners did to enhance the national status by winning some 'international' competition but no one would question Olympic medalists for that. What I'm saying is that the standard should be reestablished to reflect new societal consensus. 

3. The law is not absolute. We collectively enacted that law in the first place, so why can't we amend the current law?

4. BTS has done so much raising awareness of Korean culture and popular culture is the number one component affecting the national image according to a survey among foreigners in 2019. While 38.2% answered popular culture affected Korea's image, only 3.1% answered sports and 1.5% answered pure art. I see it's a prejudice against idols not how much the person influences the national status that hinders the discussion at the National assembly. 

5. Fans might feel other labels are using the BTS's clout for exemptions. But this is only half true. Do you think other labels are lobbying for BTS's exemption independently? Big Hit can't publicly announce that they are supporting this amendment as it may discredit BTS's answer that they would carry out the duties when they are called. 

6. Of course, there are some barriers to actually passing the amendment. Older generations may have a prejudice against idols, and most men are indifferent to exemptions. I also saw the ministry of national defense quoting a decline in soldiers as one of the restrictions, but I think this is ridiculous. Expanding exempted personnel to a handful of famous artists isn't the core cause of diminishing soldiers. This is due to a low birthrate which has to be addressed with another government policy. 


What do you think?

  1. BTS
232 141,446 Share 61% Upvoted

83

mike2427
mike2427433 pts Saturday, November 27, 2021 48
Saturday, November 27, 2021

Why are people debating if they should go to the military or not? It doesn't matter how much you contribute to the success of Kpop. If every male citizen has to then they should also. Everyone should be treated equally.

Share

48 more replies

59

seafiant
seafiant5,131 pts Saturday, November 27, 2021 8
Saturday, November 27, 2021

The moment I read "and most men are indifferent to exemptions." I knew this was fan fiction.

There no is way on earth would a man say that, especially one who just served. They either think "well I did my time so should you" in SK as a right of passage or hold it against people who skipped like that guy who went to the US and keeps wanting to return or the chaebols who sneak out on fake medical reports. No way "most men are indifferent to exemptions."

Then to read discussing needing policy on a low birthrate vs recruiting idols is just icing on the cake. When was the last time any man would be thinking birth issues a priority subject unless a politican looking for the female vote? Come on.

Share

8 more replies

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
MIRAE
13 minutes ago   0   41
New Message

SEND