30

0

Music Shows

'Music Bank' addresses the point system controversy about BTS beating IOI

Posted by alice10146 pts Monday, October 31, 2016
BTS, IOI

KBS officially addressed the recent controversy regarding BTS and IOI's rankings on October 28 installment of 'Music Bank'


On October 28, BTS's "Blood, Sweat, & Tears" beat IOI's "Very Very Very" and won first place. After the show, some viewers raised their concern about a potential error in the point calculation. Here are some of the comments from the IOI fans: 




"Please recalculate the points."

"Fix the #1 win that IOI was robbed of."




"We want official feedback."

"KBS ignores viewers."




"Music Bank #1 win is weird."

"Music Bank #1 win is incorrect."


These concerns prompted 'Music Bank' to release the exact numbers and calculation. The following is the full statement from 'Music Bank': 


"Hello, we are the production team of 'Music Bank.'


The October 28 live broadcast of 'Music Bank' and its 'K-Chart's 1st and 2nd place along with the points brought in a lot of questions and concerns, so we are here to reveal the details of the calculation method and points. 


*Each category's percentage is not a reflective percentage but the percentage from the final, total points. 

[Calculation for K-Chart points] 


Digital airplay (online streaming) 65%, 130,000 points (online 117,000 points + mobile 13,000 points) + album sales 5%, 10,000 points + broadcasting appearance 20%, 40,000 points (TV 34,000 points + radio 6,000 points) + viewers' preference survey 10%, 20,000 points = total points 200,000 points


*numbers less than decimals are rounded up 



[BTS - "Blood, Sweat & Tears] 

Digital streaming: online 2535.4 points + mobile 138.1 points = 2673.5 points


Album sales: percentage in the market 41.52% (sales 89,308 albums) = 4152 points 

Broadcast appearance: TV 685.88 points + radio 59.52 points = 745.40 points 

Viewers' preference survey: out of a total survey of 6987, they earned 284. 4.1% of the answers, 813 points


Total points = 8384 points 




[IOI - "Very Very Very"] 

Digital streaming: online 4338 points + mobile 506 points = 4844 points 

Album sales: percentage in the market 23.45% (sales 50,433 albums) = 2345 points 

Broadcasting appearance: TV 588 points + radio 83 points = 671 points 

Viewers' preference survey: excluded because it was conducted 1 week prior to the music release 


Total points = 7860 points 


We used the method above to determine that BTS ranks #1 and IOI ranks #2 on the K-Chart for the fourth week of October. 



Thank you to all the viewers, and we will always try our best to give you prompt and accurate feedback to your concerns."


  1. BTS
  2. IOI
  3. MUSIC BANK
0 150,258 Share 100% Upvoted

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Moon Geun Young, Song Hye Kyo
Min Hee Jin, NewJeans
Yang Hyun Suk, Park Bom
ATEEZ, G-Dragon, Rosé, Byeon Woo Seok, Choo Young Woo, i-dle, Go Yoon Jung, Ju Ji Hoon, Kim Ji Won, Kim Tae Ri, LE SSERAFIM, Lee Byung Hun, Lee Min Ho, Park Bo Young, RIIZE, Seventeen, TVXQ, TWICE, ZEROBASEONE
Song Ji Hyo
Song Hye Kyo
Cha Eun Woo, Kang Ha Neul, Kim Young Kwang, Sunhwa
misc.
Big Bang, DAY6, ENHYPEN, EXO, GOT7, ILLIT, Red Velvet, Irene, Seulgi, Seventeen, STAYC, Super Junior, Henry, SuperM
Min Hee Jin, NewJeans
Min Hee Jin, NewJeans
ATEEZ, G-Dragon, Rosé, Byeon Woo Seok, Choo Young Woo, i-dle, Go Yoon Jung, Ju Ji Hoon, Kim Ji Won, Kim Tae Ri, LE SSERAFIM, Lee Byung Hun, Lee Min Ho, Park Bo Young, RIIZE, Seventeen, TVXQ, TWICE, ZEROBASEONE
Kwon Hyun Bin
LE SSERAFIM
Brown Eyed Girls, Ga In, Seo In Young
New Message

SEND