Find Friend(s)
Chat
Group Chat
General Chat

Dramas, Special Features, Original Features

[Drama Review] 'Scarlet Heart: Ryeo' - Episode 16

By eric_r_wirsing   Thursday, October 20, 2016   25,398   3,633   19
Baekhyun,Seohyun,IU,lee-jun-ki

4

0

SHARES
  1. Google+

SCARLET HEART: RYEO -- EPISODE 16




At that moment, Choi considers including Beano® with So's meals...

The purge concludes, and no one will be the same again.

It almost seems like the producers of this episode said "Okay, let's listen to Eric" and wrote things the way I wanted and hoped for. It's a little coincidental that not one but two things were changed in this way, but maybe I'm just overthinking it.

The first was that they finally did time shifts correctly. So takes off, and Hae Soo waits for him. Artfully, they show the time changing from summer to fall to winter and back again. The CGI here is sweet and wonderful. Not only that, they tell you what year it is, helping us to orient ourselves immensely. I can't imagine what made them all of a sudden include this. It's almost like they listened to viewers and reviewers alike and re-edited things. That would explain why scenes that were supposed to be in the last episode ended up here.


"Lighten up, son. In everyone's life, a little reign must fall..."

The second thing is that they altered the events in Hae Soo's vision presaging Eun's death. We all know that So was the cause of it, and he appeared to laugh cruelly after he cut Eun and Soon Deok down. But the actual events shook this up a bit and gave intent to the action. Soon Deok was already dead, and Eun begged So to kill him so he could be with his recently killed wife. The laugh was more a rictus born from pain. It was a powerful scene, made all the more powerful by the different interpretation of his actions. The only question is this: what was the point of the vision?

Which brings me to my next point: how many have to die? It seems a needless thing. Once you get used to everyone dropping like flies, it seems less novel and more tiresome. It seems like they're trying too hard to be edgy, and it's descending into self-parody. I liked Eun and Soon Deok, and their deaths felt particularly pointless because they had just started to get along as a couple in love, and the show robbed us of more cute moments by killing them.


The backhug: a unisex maneuver

Speaking of self-parody, the musical thrones game is wearing thin. I realize they've got a story to tell, but the whole ascension thing is a bit boring, and the kings are all insane. It's a little hard to care since the kings don't spend more than a couple episodes on the throne and then BAM! New ruler! The most common theme in this drama is "three years pass, and there's a new monarch." And when they go nuts, they become even less sympathetic characters.

They did step up the romance between Hae Soo and Prince So, though I still wasn't completely happy with it. It seems like they always punctuate their love affair with something, whether it's fear or broken trust, and they are forever trying to put them at arm's length before they get the two together. And we got some genuinely adorable scenes. I just get tired of the on again-off again nature of their relationship. If they're supposed to be together, then get them there!


"Did you know my hand is about as big as your whole head?"

It's becoming more of a mess, particularly with this episode. It's like they're falling all over themselves to get to the end, and that leads to all sorts of the plot issues I mentioned. The edits lingered a bit long too, so I was not impressed with the pacing either. They need to introduce some new elements into the show and really shake things up. This episode needed a serious wedgie.

Note: If you're looking for episode 17, that's next week at the same time, assuming it's not preempted by the ball game.

Score

Plot........................5
Performance.........6
Pacing...................5


OVERALL............5.3

SEE ALSO: EXO's Baekhyun sweetly chats on the phone with Cao Lu and Giant Pink on 'Muck!et Street'

    YOU MAY LIKE

    GET AKP IN YOUR INBOX!

    Tags:

    1. Baekhyun
    2. Seohyun
    3. IU
    4. Lee Jun Ki
    5. scarlet heart ryeo


    phabbiola Monday, October 24, 2016

    Are you getting paid to write so much trash? I guess you are because it makes no sense whatsoever. I actually pity you.

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    si Friday, October 21, 2016

    This reviewer clearly has no idea what is really happening! This is pure ignorance!! The reviewer is very superficial!

     1
     0Reply Report Share

    Delylah Friday, October 21, 2016

    I'm going to take a stab in the dark and guess that 1) you haven't bothered looking up any of the history the show is based on. Neither Mu nor Yo lasted more than 2 years on the throne. Hence the quick turnaround. Do we really want to be subjected to the every day humdrum of their rule? No? Didn't think so. Taejo and So, however, both reigned around 25 years. Also, the 10th prince represents a figure whose grandfather really did try to put him on the throne. That rebellion actually happened. 2) I'll also guess it has not occurred to you that maybe one of the themes the show is built around is that :It's not easy being king...it seems you're doomed to do so many rotten, underhanded thingslike leave your lovers, kill your brothers, and then you goand lose your marbles because the Head Honcho Helmet is justtoo heavy to wear....Not a Kermit fan? Then how's this: The show is all about how the fight for the throne nearly destroys a dynasty before it can ever really get started. Brother against brother. Mother against son. Son against father. One king lost his health. Two lost their minds, and a third wannabe is well on his way to losing his. The question is whether or not Wang So can be the one to really have it all - or will he have to give something up? Hae Soo? more brothers? his own sanity? or should he just give up the throne itself? 3)  Hae Soo has been through a lot - she's been dumped, drowned, disembodied, re-embodied, flirted with a married man, threatened with grievous bodily harm on multiple occasions (by the man she's now in love with) lost her cousin who was not actually her cousin whose husband she had fallen in love with, been engaged to a king, sliced, indentured, entrapped, betrayed, ignored, manipulated, sold out (by the man who used to love her but he had to kill her? try to kill her? she bitched so much she drove him nuts - oh wait, he was nuts to begin with never mind). On top of that, the man she's drawn to is, according to history, a cruel tyrant who murdered his brothers, and let's not forget that horse he rode in on.... can we blame the girl for being a little reluctant to have that man sign his name across her heart?  If you aren't going to make a serious effort to review the show based on its merits and instead turn in a sarcastic piece of drek just to try and get laughs, perhaps you should pass the assignment on to someone else. Just because you don't seem to be capable of sussing out the reasons for why things are happening the way they are, doesn't mean those reasons aren't there for you to discover.

     5
     0Reply Report Share

    calculator Friday, October 21, 2016

    i'm reading your review just to see how terrible it is..... like do you even watch this drama???

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    mahyo711 Friday, October 21, 2016

    Clearly you are either biased or blind or both. Or maybe you have zero sense in analyzing things. Watch the show from the beginning to understand the point of the visions. ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME ?! Eun's death was a trigger for So to man up to his responsibility and take charge. It was very much needed. Yes, their love was short-lived but sometimes you need to tick something off to make a point. The Kings didn't just go nut. One died of natural causes, the other was poisoned and the third one is filled with remorse. I don't even want to get started on the So/Soo part of your article. You seriously need to chill and stop your baseless venting on a good episode. You give a six for the performance. You deserve a zero for your writing and analyzing skills.

     3
     0Reply Report Share

    si mahyo711 Friday, October 21, 2016

    I agree I can't believe I wasted my time reading his review!

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    chichuu Thursday, October 20, 2016

    I don't know why I bother to read these reviews. They are simply terrible, almost like the person doesn't even try. I'm more shocked about the 6 on the performance! Or the pacing with 5, are you kidding me? It has been giving me an heart attack in the last episodes! Plus Lee Jun Ki is being amazing as Wang So. Plus, I have to admit that Baekhyun also shone in this episode. Ha Neul is being brilliant too. In this episode, Jong Hyun was particulary amazing. I think even IU has been growing in her character. And their deaths seem pointless? Do you even read a bit of history before actually watch anything? If they twisted the story too much, what would be the point of being inserted in a historical concept? Eun was supposed to die and he died in the year he was supposed to die too. I wouldn't have wanted to see Soon Deok living a life without Eun, so I think this end was fair for both of them. I just wished that we could have seen more about their story. They cut so many scenes. I really wanted to see more of their story together during the time skips. To whoever is reading this and is thinking twice about watching the drama, don't because you will miss an amazing drama. Believe me!

     7
     0Reply Report Share

    si chichuu Friday, October 21, 2016

    The writer is biased and pure stupid!!

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    kpopfandom2 Thursday, October 20, 2016

    This guy's just writing reviews because he doesn't like the drama in the first place lol. The actors worked hard. Fighting!

     3
     0Reply Report Share

    si kpopfandom2 Friday, October 21, 2016

    Precisely!!

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    kpopfandom2 si Friday, October 21, 2016

    thank you

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    nami_chan Thursday, October 20, 2016

    Lol Yo is crazy, I hope So doesn't get crazy as the other kings, I can't wait for ep 17, I'm so happy for So and Soo ^^

     0
     0Reply Report Share

    nami_chan Thursday, October 20, 2016

    STOP WRITING REVIEWS YOU SUCK!

     8
     0Reply Report Share

    nami_chan Thursday, October 20, 2016

    ok no but you are so biased, when are you going to give it good score , when So or Soo die? , next!

     2
     0Reply Report Share

    JungkookxYonghwa Thursday, October 20, 2016

    ARE YOU EVEN WATCHING THE SHOW? ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME? A 6 FOR PERFORMANCE? LEE JOON GI AND BAEKHYUN KILLED IT. THEY WERE AMAZING. HONG JONGHYUN IS DOING A TERRIFIC JOB. HA NEUL IS GREAT. LIKE WHAAAAAAT? And also, "What was the point of the vision?" oh I don't know, maybe tO PROVE HAE SOO'S BEEN WRONG IN JUDGING SO'S ACTIONS IN THE FIRST PLACE. Her visions being wrong is definitely important here, duh. ALSO, the kings don't just "go nuts". Taejo was ill, CP was poisoned and Yo was haunted by the remorse of killing Eun. I swear to God, people - give the show a try. Don't avoid it based on these stupid reviews that are SO FUCKING WRONG.

     15
     0Reply Report Share

    nami_chan JungkookxYonghwa Thursday, October 20, 2016

    I agree, this review sucks

     3
     0Reply Report Share
    Load More Comments

    CONNECT WITH ALLKPOP

    1. Follow us on Instagram
    2. Subscribe on Youtube
    3. Follow us on Google+

    BRAND PARTNERS

    dont recall
    dont recall
    $18
    walk alone
    walk alone
    $18
    knock knock
    knock knock
    $18
    soju
    soju
    $18

    MORE STORIES