MuGirlGroupTrash kiko_san • Sunday, June 11, 2017

Ummmm more MamaPink moments pls????

gilmore1111111 hiroonakamura • Sunday, June 11, 2017

Not Really they are still selling more than 100k albums a year and are still in the top for monthly brand rankings even when not promoting.

hiroonakamura gilmore1111111 • Sunday, June 11, 2017

they have never sold 100k albums (unless you add two or more albums together).if u look at their singles, their sales numbers have gone down as well. Their previous single Only One sold less than 500k whereas the oneb efore that (Remember) sold more than 1 million. Their release earlier this year, Always, sold only 50k)

gilmore1111111 hiroonakamura • Monday, June 12, 2017

I dunno what stats you are looking at, I'm looking at only Korea and I'm talking about yearly combined. Last year Apink sold 40k+ for eunji 50k+ for only one and 30k+ for Dear. That's around 120k+.To put that in perspective they are around GFriend and Mamamoo mark in terms of total album sales in 2016.Always is a digital single for fans which I am sure you are not.Remember was the only album released in 2015 and that sold 90k by itself so you could argue last years album didn't do as great but they still sold more collectively than 2015.

hiroonakamura gilmore1111111 • Monday, June 12, 2017

i am reading the official sales numbers. You however are adding sales of many albums together to make the number seem higher. What i was saying in my initial post was how sales have been going downwards per album and single. That is for a-pink, not for eunji. Same goes for their singles sales. They have been selling less and less per every new single. You need to stop talking about collective sales because that is a different topic

gilmore1111111 hiroonakamura • Monday, June 12, 2017

Urmm sorry I am not adding numbers these are official sales from last year 2016 - look up (sales-2016-gaon-album-sales) If anything the should be higher than what I have stated by now. You should do your research before making lies, also why would you not look at them collectively they are a group.

gilmore1111111 hiroonakamura • Monday, June 12, 2017

also if you look at Gaon Sales 2016 album sales Pink revolution surpassed mamamoo plus red velvet. Album sales is all that matters in terms of fandom strength.

hiroonakamura gilmore1111111 • Monday, June 12, 2017

like i said, i am not adding up numbers because adding up doesnt reveal is the albums are doing better for each release or not. A group could release 6 albums a year and get a good total - that doesnt say anything though regarding how popular each album is. Look at my initial post that you replied to. It is about how the sales PER album is going.

hiroonakamura gilmore1111111 • Monday, June 12, 2017

I dont know where you are getting album sales numbers from but you can see it here: onehallyu (.) com/topic/321716-official-apink-sales-thread-digital-physical-21m-dl-478m-streaming-458k-gaon-721k-total-physical-sales/ ------ Keep in mind though that the album sales there have added the japanese numbers too. As you can see, even with japanese numbers, the sales numbers are closer to what I said (which you can find on wikipedia) than yours