Melon partners up with 35 music critics to name the 'Top 100 Best K-Pop Songs' of all time
AKP STAFF
One of the top music streaming platforms in South Korea, Melon has published its list for the 'Top 100 Best K-Pop Songs' of all time.
Melon partnered up with 35 music critics and experts from the music industry over a period of 5 months, undergoing two rounds of selections. During the first round, the critics and experts narrowed down 1,120 candidates. In the second round, each song was scored in 10 unique categories.
Finally, here are Melon's 'Top 100 Best K-Pop Songs' of all time, below!
I'm kind of disappointed that this ended up being more of a popularity contest than real criticism of the music. For example, I wanted less emphasis on sales & impact (although those two are important) and more emphasis on originality & creativity. Almost everyone on this list has much better songs than the ones that were named. For example, Infinite has better songs than Be Mine, BTS has better songs than Dynamite, EXO has better songs than Growl, SNSD has better songs than Gee, 2NE1 has better songs than I AM THE BEST, BIGBANG has better songs than Fantastic Baby, BEG has better songs than Abracadabra, BoA has better songs than No. 1, BlackPink has better songs than DDU-DU DDU-DU, etc. I could go on & on.
.
Yet again, the impact of these songs are obviously important, but for a list deemed "Top 100 Best K-Pop Songs", I expected more authenticity on 'Best'. This is more of a list, in my opinion, on songs that have solidified themselves in K-Pop history.
53(+62 / -9)
Share
14 more replies
BlissZ (Banned)529 ptsFriday, August 27, 2021 2
Friday, August 27, 2021
What EXACTLY were those ”10 unique categories”??? I’m kind of dumbfounded by the order of these songs....
SHARE
I'm kind of disappointed that this ended up being more of a popularity contest than real criticism of the music. For example, I wanted less emphasis on sales & impact (although those two are important) and more emphasis on originality & creativity. Almost everyone on this list has much better songs than the ones that were named. For example, Infinite has better songs than Be Mine, BTS has better songs than Dynamite, EXO has better songs than Growl, SNSD has better songs than Gee, 2NE1 has better songs than I AM THE BEST, BIGBANG has better songs than Fantastic Baby, BEG has better songs than Abracadabra, BoA has better songs than No. 1, BlackPink has better songs than DDU-DU DDU-DU, etc. I could go on & on.
.
Yet again, the impact of these songs are obviously important, but for a list deemed "Top 100 Best K-Pop Songs", I expected more authenticity on 'Best'. This is more of a list, in my opinion, on songs that have solidified themselves in K-Pop history.
14 more replies