IOI fans accuse MelOn of unfairly awarding Black Pink the 'Rookie Award'

This year, Black Pink won the 'Rookies Award' at the '2016 MMA,' but IOI fans are arguing that the award should have been given to IOI instead. 

SEE ALSO: When Greedy fans show up - Should K-Pop merch have Buying Limits?

Here are the evidence IOI fans are presenting to make their case. 

First, IOI won the popular votes for the award on the MelOn website. Following is the screen shot of the vote results: 

IOI won the votes with 49% of the votes, whereas Black Pink only earned 14% of the votes. 

Next, IOI fans point the streaming scores and downloads. 

In Gaon Music chart streaming, IOI has a total of 89,741,863 points; Black Pink has 79,171,770 points. 

In another fans' analysis of downloads and streams, IOI again beats Black Pink by a lot.  

What do you think about the arguments above? Do you think IOI should have won the 'Rookies Awards' for 2016 instead of Black Pink?

Tip: Rue