Find Friend(s)
Chat
CHAT ROOMS
KPOP Lounge

General

IOI fans accuse MelOn of unfairly awarding Black Pink the 'Rookie Award'

By alice101   Tuesday, November 22, 2016   146,602   17,906   1
ioi,black-pink

26

0

SHARES
  1. Google+
IOI fans are outraged by the result of '2016 MelOn Music Awards'


This year, Black Pink won the 'Rookies Award' at the '2016 MMA,' but IOI fans are arguing that the award should have been given to IOI instead. 


SEE ALSO: AKP Talks Eric Nam collaboration and more with AOBeats


Here are the evidence IOI fans are presenting to make their case. 


First, IOI won the popular votes for the award on the MelOn website. Following is the screen shot of the vote results: 





IOI won the votes with 49% of the votes, whereas Black Pink only earned 14% of the votes. 


Next, IOI fans point the streaming scores and downloads. 


In Gaon Music chart streaming, IOI has a total of 89,741,863 points; Black Pink has 79,171,770 points




In another fans' analysis of downloads and streams, IOI again beats Black Pink by a lot.  




What do you think about the arguments above? Do you think IOI should have won the 'Rookies Awards' for 2016 instead of Black Pink?


Tip: Rue

  1. IOI
  2. Black Pink


KpopRox94 Sunday, December 4, 2016

Lol..

KpopRox94 Sunday, December 4, 2016

Everyone knows IOI will get best new artist in MAMA,so just let BP take this,ok? -.-

jerok Sunday, November 27, 2016

They are rules, but still doesn't make sense. Ynot have a rookie group win both awards if they are badass enough to achieve them. We all know twice is rookie of the year.

groot980 Thursday, November 24, 2016

IOI is not an actual band..Its only a project..while BP is a band from YG

FreshQueen groot980 Tuesday, November 29, 2016

They worked extremely hard to debut, have albums, promoted throughout the year, constantly on tv shows, and rarely sleep because they're too busy, just for people like you to say they aren't "a real group"? what exactly constitutes a group genius? please enlighten me..

groot980 FreshQueen Friday, December 2, 2016

There are a lot of other groups who work hard too..But its true that they're no a real group..You must realize that they're just a project which will disband soon.

groot980 Friday, December 2, 2016

You're annoyed at my comment bcoz you stan them...but think rationally they're just a project group whose members actually belong to a variety of groups.

karat groot980 Sunday, December 4, 2016

They work just as hard and put the same amount of effort as every other band. They worked so hard to debut and even if ioi is just a "project", they sure put a lot of hard work into it. Some of the members even put twice the effort since they're in another band so they sure as hell deserve the rookie award. And if the only reason why they couldn't win was because they aren't technically a band, they wouldn't even be nominated to win the awards in the first place.

groot980 karat Monday, December 5, 2016

So just accept the fact

FreshQueen groot980 Friday, December 9, 2016

It's not a fact, just your opinion. All groups eventually disband so your argument isn't valid. Just because IOI have a set date, doesn't mean they're not a real group.

kkkat groot980 Tuesday, December 20, 2016

My girls have worked their asses off the whole year attending tons of schedules in need of sleep. Your comment just activates my inner fury!

groot980 kkkat Wednesday, December 21, 2016

RELEASE YOUR INNER FURYYYYYYYYYYY!!!

hanalalabitchy Thursday, November 24, 2016

BECAUSE BLACK PINK IS FROM YG :) AND I DONT MIND IF BP WON A AWARD BECAUSE THEIR RIVAL IS IOI THAT ALMOST DISBAND.BUT IKON??? HOW CAN???? HAHAHA NO TALENTED NO COMEBACK NO PERFORMANCE BUT WIN? IT IS REALLY YG'S POWER NOT FANS POWER :) AND WHY EXO WON BEST CHOREO?? HAHAHAA WAAA... I DONT THINK THEY DESERVE :)  SORRY :)YG AND SM ARE NO KIDDING!! BIG COMPANIES ALWAYS MAKE ME FEEL ANNOYED W/ THEIR MONEY  XD AND THANK TO JYP BECAUSE THEY DIDNT DO LIKE THAT XD

mynameis21 hanalalabitchy Friday, November 25, 2016

ikon won QQ Music Asia Star Award which is for chinese charts and they were very active in japan and china(many fans call them iCon and iJon xd ) so their award have a meaning !

drygra hanalalabitchy Saturday, April 8, 2017

ikon not talented? they producing their own album, make their own choreo and they're have a great voice. bobby won the smtm. i doubt that they doesnt comeback recently, but it doesnt mean that they not talented.when YG artist comeback they're always slay. YG artist have much better talent.

Master_Wayne Thursday, November 24, 2016

I get people wanted them to win, but honestly IOI was made to debut this year and disband. I personally, don't see it fair.

AprilJune Wednesday, November 23, 2016

wow! of course ioi would beat black pink for streaming and download scores..ioi has a lot of songs compared to black pink.. ioi debuted first so downloads and streamings gave them a boost.. why bp got the award? it is because on all of their songs are hit.. just compare the percentage of bp's debut album and ioi's debut album..since ioi has more songs, it already explains why they beat bp..got it???😒😒

AprilJune Wednesday, November 23, 2016

and look, for four songs, they have 79 million streams compared to ioi's eight songs. if they really deserve the award, their streamings should double bp's streamings..

BuddyPanda AprilJune Thursday, November 24, 2016

the issue here is that the criteria of winning are the voting and stream/download. and IOI tops those both. it doesnt matter if its bp has less song or debut later the award is for 2016 so everything counts from jan 1 to the day before MMA. IOI fans accusing Melon for not following the criteria

Tyson_anm AprilJune Thursday, November 24, 2016

If that were the criteria then what is the point of giving rookie of the year 2016 those who debuted earlier will always win, obviously average sales were taken into consideration here Blackpink has 1.8M+ sales for 4 songs and 170M views so they won

FreshQueen Tyson_anm Tuesday, November 29, 2016

What's the point of having a group that debuted late in the year and only have a few songs that they barely promoted as opposed to a group that promoted aggressively the whole year, worked their asses off with no rest and made a big impact on the country becoming the most popular girl group of the year (along with twice). Which one deserves it more?

Tyson_anm FreshQueen Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Its because the award is for rookie of the year not rookie of summer 2016, also the award is for music not entertainment award just because the appear on variety shows every week doesn't mean that their music are good we are talking about sales and digital streaming here and if we take an average you will know how popular they are without variety shows and promotional ventures!! Mnet should give ioi a beat entertainer award as theirshow was popular!! Why try to win the rookie award when you are just a tv show experiment -_-

_infirestae Wednesday, November 23, 2016

aish these pabos

Knigin Wednesday, November 23, 2016

YG paid for BP win... end off.

bibi87 Wednesday, November 23, 2016

Do you kidding me? It will be a trend to try to take away awards from artists who clearly deserve those awards? EXO and IOI fans need to go to hell with their datas and complains! These two fandom are a good match for each other, you can console each other and be crycry together forever!

Cali_22 bibi87 Wednesday, November 23, 2016

Lol, ikr?

micahxo_lu bibi87 Wednesday, November 23, 2016

Stooooooop generalizing omg it's not even half the fandom lmao

NanandGomu bibi87 Friday, December 2, 2016

Lol, your fandom is worse.

kizaru_hijin Wednesday, November 23, 2016

seems ioi fans are just as stupid as exo fans...no thinking at all and think being jealous and hating at others would make their bias happy, when they will only feel ashamed...

yousuckk kizaru_hijin Wednesday, November 23, 2016

They're so whiny

pablo27 kizaru_hijin Thursday, November 24, 2016

Please be a little nicer... after 01/17/17 these fans are kaput...

kizaru_hijin pablo27 Thursday, November 24, 2016

its not these kind of "fans" that deserve to be treated nicely, these idiots are only making it worse for their bias...they didnt win and also have to see how their fans are embarassing them and attack others because they were better...a fact these idiots cant accept, one group/artist cant always win and instead of making it worse for everyone, they should focus on supporting their bias more and not crying around like that...

Load More Comments

GET AKP IN YOUR INBOX!

CONNECT WITH ALLKPOP

  1. Follow us on Instagram
  2. Subscribe on Youtube
  3. Follow us on Google+

BRAND PARTNERS

20
20
$20
20
20
$18
35
35
$18
18
18
$18