77

42

News

Stray Kids winning #1 on M Countdown becomes controversial

Posted by yckim124766 pts Friday, April 5, 2019

Stray Kids meaningful win has turned controversial. 

On April 4, the JYP Entertainment boy group had their first-ever music show win on Mnet's 'M Countdown.' The members immediately broke down in tears after being announced the winner for the first time.

Unfortunately, their win has become a topic of controversy. The reason is due to their scores. The weekly winner is determined by 'Digital Single Sales' (45%), 'Album Sales' (15%), 'Social Media Points (20%), 'Global Fan Votes' (10%), and 'Broadcast Score' (10%).

Haeun, Yosep, the other nominee for the 1st place, had a score of zero in the 'Album Sales' and 'Global Fan Votes' categories, which take up 25% of the total score. Meanwhile, Stray Kids scored zero in 'Digital Single Sales' - the largest portion of the entire score (45%). 

Stray Kids' score for 'Digital Single Sales' showed as zero because their track "Miroh" wasn't ranked in the top 1000 on music charts. With this in mind, netizens criticized their win


Comments stated, "What? How did they win when their score is zero lolol Classic Mnet," "This is why there's no trust in music show scores," "This is nonsense. How can you have none in 'Digital Single Sales,'" "Rank out of 1000 on music charts but win #1 music shows... lol" "This is why music show wins have no meaning."

Shop the story
STRAYKIDS FELIX : ELLE Magazine November 2024
$25
STRAY KIDS HYUNJIN : ESQUIRE October 2024
$25
STRAY KIDS - 9th Mini Album [ATE] (ATE Ver.) (Limited Edition)
$24
  1. Stray Kids
93 170,749 Share 65% Upvoted
 
ratmonster
ratmonster5,062 pts Friday, April 5, 2019 0
Friday, April 5, 2019

They won fair and square. I sense a bunch of bitter antis trying to start shit. They won and they deserved it so get over it.

59 (+65 / -6)
Share
 
Sa1459
Sa145956 pts Friday, April 5, 2019 8
Friday, April 5, 2019

Others music shows have different criteria. According to Mcountdown criteria, Stray Kids definitely deserve to win. The points collected is the prove , Stray Kids also leads the live voting and that makes them the final winner. Stray Kids didn't win at Music Bank because they didn't reached the criteria required

56 (+61 / -5)
Share

8 more replies

SHOW ALL COMMENTS

allkpop in your Inbox

THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
Junsu (XIA)
aespa, Cha Eun Woo, RIIZE, TVXQ, TWICE, Nayeon, Wonder Girls, 2PM
2 hours ago      3,467
IU, Park Bo Gum
Red Velvet, Irene, Seulgi
Gong Hyo Jin, Kevin Oh
Han Ji Min, Kim Woo Bin
Choi Hyun Wook, Hong Kyung, Kim Sung Kyun, Jun (Lee Jun Young),  Shin Seung Ho
Taemin, TXT
49 minutes ago      1,263
NMIXX
Byeon Woo Seok, Kim Hye Yoon
Red Velvet, Irene, Seulgi
RIIZE
Taemin, TXT
49 minutes ago      1,263
NMIXX
BABYMONSTER
New Message

SEND