Find Friend(s)
Chat
CHAT ROOMS
KPOP Lounge
KARD Chat
BTS Chat
JYP Chat
SM Chat
G-Friend Chat
YG Chat

Music Releases, Special Features, Original Features

[Album & MV Review] SHINee - '1 and 1'

By eric_r_wirsing   Sunday, November 20, 2016   22,088   2,743   15
SHINee

2

0

SHARES
  1. Google+


SHINEE -- 1 AND 1 -- 5th ALBUM REPACKAGE

Track List:

1. Tell Me What To Do
2. Wish Upon a Star
3. Rescue
4. Beautiful Life
5. If You Love Her
6. Beautiful Life (Inst.)
7. Wish Upon a Star (Inst.)
8. Tell Me What To Do (Inst.)
9. Rescue (Inst.)
10. If You Love Her (Inst.)
11. Prism
12. 1 of 1
13. Feel Good
14. Don`t Let Me Go
15. Lipstick
16. Don`t Stop
17. SHIFT
18. U Need Me
19. So Amazing (Special Track)



Not content with just the chart-topping '1 of 1,' SHINee is back again with '1 and 1.' A special treat for fans, it has a whopping 19 tracks here, including five new ones and their instrumentals. That's practically another LP here. Just like the first one, this one's trending high on the charts. The 5th album review can be found here.

The album kicks off with "Tell Me What To Do." It's their title track, and it starts out soft, but it acquires a marching beat in the bridge. Jonghyun and Taemin belt that bridge fiercely. It's a sharp contrast to the rest of the tune, which has a whispery quality to the vocals. I love that. I thought it was headed one way and it took the expressway and shot off in a different direction. If there's a stronger way to start this off I can't think of one.



"Wish Upon a Star" is a quiet ballad and, while it brings in strings and soon after a full-blown orchestra, it doesn't try to ruin the production with overwrought vocals. The boys have powerful enough vocals where they can tackle the emotional parts without losing control. It proves to be a good thing here.

They pick up the pace again with "Rescue." It's a little like the first track, only they have a harmony for the chorus and it's not quite so fierce. This is to its benefit, giving it a quiet strength. It's a rock solid tune. It reminds me a lot of R&B, only done in SHINee's inimitable style.



Harmony-heavy "Beautiful Life" is a soft pop number, mid-tempo, and that's kind of where they lost me. There are so many songs like this it felt like they were throwing their hats in the ring saying "me too." It was okay for what it was, but it just seemed like filler.

"If You Love Her" is a tenderly sung ballad, stripped down and relying on the vocals to carry it. It's well put together, and it again avoids being lumped together with other ballads simply because of the superb voice work. This is what I'm talking about when I talk about a ballad done right.



Sometimes the artists skimp on the repackage, and there's a couple new tracks and remixes. This, I'm happy to report, is not one of them. As always, SHINee's amazing vocals are what come through to save the day. The instrumentals by themselves are soothing, and serve as good ambient music, bereft of vocals as they are. This is a pretty good album, except for one dud, but as always YMMV. An extra few SHINee songs are always a good thing, right?  

MV REVIEW


I keep feeling there's a narrative here, but I think it got lost.

We have fire, a car, a pyro apparently responsible for the fire, a burning gun, and guns galore floating in mid-air. If someone can explain this, I'd love to hear it. Make it funny, though. Funny interpretations are always better than straight ones. Near as I can tell, they're partying when someone sets things ablaze and picks up a gun.

I'm not quite sure where to begin and end on it. It seemed like a series of vines, almost, scenes lasting no more than six seconds before we hit a new one. It's exceedingly well filmed, and if there's no story here, then there needs to be one. I'd like to think it's not just a random series of lightning fast vignettes.



But, as I said, it's wonderfully filmed. There's also no synchronized dancing, and indeed, no dancing at all, which makes me think there's a ghost of a plot in there somewhere. Regardless, there's some fantastic stylistic touches that make this thing entirely watchable.  

True, I'm not sure what's going on, but that's okay. I still liked it.

Score:
MV Relevance..........7
MV Production.........8
MV Concept.............6


Album Production...7
Album Concept........7
Tracklisting..............7


OVERALL...............7.0


SEE ALSO: SHINee trend #1 worldwide for their 9th-anniversary!


Get K-POP Merch @ allkpop The Shop


YOU MAY LIKE

GET AKP IN YOUR INBOX!

Tags:

  1. SHINee
  2. 1-and-1


MyuuMyuu Tuesday, November 22, 2016

"jonghyun and taemin belt that bridge", but, dont onew, tae and jjong sing the same parts here? first jjong then tae then onew...then why isnt onew mentioned? im sorry if i sound stupid, maybe im just no aware what the bridge actually is in this song, but i listened to it a lot and cant figure out what is they sing that onew doesnt besides the "dont cry no more" parts in between "tell me what to do" is that the bridge here?.

 0
 0Reply Report Share

shineefeels Monday, November 21, 2016

"This review reflects the opinions of the author and not necessarily those of Allkpop." ... I think AKP doesn't get how this works. You see... when someone writes an article, it has to get approved by an editor. That editor chooses what should and shouldn't be on AKP. If they didn't approve it, it wouldn't be here. So yes, it does reflect AKP's opinion. If you don't like what your writers are writing, proofread the articles instead of pretending like what they write isn't supported by AKP.I feel like I'm wasting my breath. Calling songs "duds" isn't professional btw. I don't know what music reviews y'all are referencing but you've got to work harder than this. If you don't know what the MV is about, go read some comments on the MV - the rest of us figured it out just fine.

 0
 0Reply Report Share

kacichan Monday, November 21, 2016

Tell Me What To Do is the best song out of all the 1of1 and 1and1. I'm so happy we got this, really really than you Shinee.

 1
 0Reply Report Share

Du2 Monday, November 21, 2016

Hope allkpop would allow only professional music critic to make an article about an artist not a wannabe. 7? This is TRASH! BIAS!

 1
 0Reply Report Share

herliaaa Sunday, November 20, 2016

seriously? please tell me you're kidding

 2
 0Reply Report Share

ThsDee Sunday, November 20, 2016

a 7?! and you said you like it.....

 2
 0Reply Report Share

Maggie Sunday, November 20, 2016

Allktrash.

 3
 0Reply Report Share

Flowercrew Sunday, November 20, 2016

Shinee always delivers.

 1
 0Reply Report Share

kwanglove Sunday, November 20, 2016

let akp give shinee half assed scores while shinee gets the best scores from actual professional music critics :)

 9
 0Reply Report Share

ahgase88 Sunday, November 20, 2016

If you loovee herrrrr

 1
 0Reply Report Share
Load More Comments

CONNECT WITH ALLKPOP

  1. Follow us on Instagram
  2. Subscribe on Youtube
  3. Follow us on Google+

BRAND PARTNERS

totes
totes
$20
singal
singal
$18
tote
tote
$20
kpop
kpop
$18

MORE STORIES