18

47

Discussions
Posted by abnormalk2,515 pts Thursday, January 9, 2020

OPINION | SM entertainment should start working on giving more fan content

NOTE: The following is only displaying MY opinion, not allkpop's.


SM Entertainment is without any doubt one of the biggest entertainment companies in Asia.

Being the home of legendary K-POP artists like H.O.T, BoA, SNSD, TVXQ and EXO. 


Yet, in the past few years, many fans have not been content on the way SM provides fan content. Specifically, how most of the content is either not available for international fans or non existent as a whole.


And they are right to do so.


The K-POP industry have changed ever since SM have created the fondation by debuting H.O.T in 1996. What was before a more unknown genre have become a worldwide known multi million market that is still in expansion. The ways to connect with fans also changed. With social medias, there's thousands of methods to connect and interact with fans.
Which is why fan content became important in the building of a strong and passionate fandom.

And this is what SM higher-ups failed to understand, which made them fall behind other companies in the recent years.

The company that was known to be the trendsetter (and still is to this day), the example to follow is now the company who's trying to catch up and they are doing so horribly.


As I have previously said, fan content is a must. In today's industry, to grow and build a strong fandom, you must put out original fan content. Red Velvet and EXO, two of their most known groups, barely releases said content for older fans to enjoy and for new fans to watch in order to be more familiarized with them. And when they do so, it is either released on Vlive +, which has to be paid in order to be watched or oksusu, a streaming site that only Korean fans can access easily while international fans must go through VPN and hope to be able to pass the welcome page. By doing so, SM is drastically cutting any chance for both groups to gain new loyal fans. Which is quite surprising to see when they do know how to create a good fan-artist complicity. Look at NCT, whose content mostly on YouTube, a streaming site where most can go to easily and do not have to pay for it and also on Vlive but for free compared to their older compatriots.

The point here is that SM actually knows how to connect the fans and the artist but isn't willing to let most of their act have access to it.

And this is quite disheartening because fans deserve content and you cannot expect fans to stay with your groups if you are willingly blocking the connection between the two.

You simply cannot expect a growth in a fandom if you are only working hard to give free and fun content to one instead of all.

EXO fans have been complaining for the last 3 years on how SM should let the members use the official EXO Twitter account so they can interact with each other. To this day, SM has not listen and EXO's Twitter, though having near 7 millions of followers, barely get the social interactions a 7 million followers account should get. The account looks more like an advertisement account, a page full of links to articles, achievements, etc... only in Korean. The few times EXO's twitter releases tweets in English is when they (SM interns) have to boast about EXO's achievements or interact with influential persons and global companies. When member Baekhyun made his personal Twitter account, his first tweet had more interactions and retweets than the last 7 tweets on EXO's page which were mostly links to EXO's variety show on oksusu that most international fans cannot even access.

There is a clear issue on the way SM gives content to their fans, in a modern K-POP industry who is now exposed to the world, content must be easy to access for all. If SM wants to compete with other companies in the western world as they have shown many times in the past 4 years, they must think of a new way of approach so that ALL their groups can easily interact with their fans.


And if they don't do so, their own ship might sink due to their carelessness.

-Ab

    17 8,816 Share 28% Upvoted
     
    Nina14red
    Nina14red4,417 pts Friday, January 10, 2020 1
    Friday, January 10, 2020

    I have been saying this for years and this problem is not only limited to SM. Some agencies still don't understand that by creating more intimate and personal fan content, they are essentially ignoring the potential for earning and maintaining newer fans. I usually don't like to mention other groups that are not specifically referenced in an article but I think it's definitely worth mentioning that this is a big part of why BTS is successful. BigHit creates BTS focused content such as variety shows instead of relying on preexisting shows to showcase the group. We as fans love and adore all of their content. Something so small and insignificant as a 30 second Bangtan Bomb of the members goofing off garners MILLIONS of views. Same thing goes for highly produced series such as Run BTS or Bon Voyage. It is this visibility that helps attract and sustain new and seasoned fans. Groups are not going to be able to have comeback after comeback so it is wise to have other content in between. I love seeing smaller labels or newer groups apply this tactic. You get to see your favorite idols in raw and candid moments instead of these company controlled/edited fashion. Sidenote: I am currently LOVING all the Kard and ATEEZ content I can get my hands on, in addition to my usual steady stream of BTS and TXT content!!!

    2 (+3 / -1)
    Share

    1 more reply

     
    dizzcity
    dizzcity2,547 pts Thursday, January 9, 2020 1
    Thursday, January 9, 2020

    This is fine as an article for discussion here instead of in the forums, since the writer made a decent attempt at making an argument for his/her case, and clearly labelled it as their own opinion. Essentially, this is an OP-ED piece.


    I agree in general with the writer's opinion about what SM should do, if their goal was to build their fandoms and please fans more. I'm not sure if that is SM Entertainment's only goal though. It feels to me like SM Ent's corporate culture relies very heavily on their management controlling their artists' public image. Giving up control of the communication channels between artist and fans may be too risky for the SM management, especially if their artists may accidentally reveal things which lead to backlash against the company or the artists themselves. (Like Irene's posting that she read that book supporting feminism, for example). Basically, in my opinion, SM's management are control freaks. NCT's only able to act the way they do right now on social media because they're currently Lee Soo Man's pet project.


    Honestly, I think we here on allkpop are kinda spoiled by JYP Entertainment's fandom-building and communications strategy, which puts out a ton of fan content. But keep in mind that this strategy only works because of the company's culture and branding. Specifically, JYP's philosophy for a long time now is that they build stars centered around relatability and personalities, rather than making music as an artform. Therefore, for them, in order to market their idols' strengths better, it's important to build relationships with fans, which necessitates constant communication (via social media and fan content) between artist and fans. That kind of strategy, of marketing idols who are like guys-or-girls-next-door, and huge dorks, is not always transferable to other companies, with different company cultures. SM Ent tries to market some of their idols as being mysterious and perfect from a distance, rather than relatable dorks next door. That may be why they are restricting access to fans. But you're probably right in that this is backfiring on them in the age of social media personalities.

    2 (+2 / -0)
    Share

    1 more reply

    SHOW ALL COMMENTS

    allkpop in your Inbox

    THE TOP 10 STORIES DELIVERED DAILY
    New Message

    SEND