Would Nana have reigned the K-pop idol scene had she debuted now?

On an online forum, netizens discussed whether former After School member Nana would have become a popular 4th-gen icon. Based on her striking looks, a netizen asserted that her face would have become instantly popular had she shared the stage with female idols today like IVE's Wonyoung or NewJeans. 

The post, titled "If Nana had debuted now, she would have been hella popular," shared a few photos of Nana and explained: "Her face is the definition of today's trend. So pretty."

In the comments section, however, netizens split over the debate by referencing other non-visual sides of Nana, such as her carefree attitude outside of taboo.

Reactions include:

"I feel like she was able to get away with a lot of things for being born at the right time of her days though"

"She was chosen as one of the most beautiful faces in the world and yet I think her beauty didn't receive as much spotlight in comparison"
"Nana is already popular lol how much more does one need to be popular"
"Who cares if she received plastic surgery though, if that's the case then please let me know where that hospital is lol"
"I think she would have amassed the same amount of popularity as now"
"She is my wannabe face....so elegantly gorgeous"
"I think had she debuted as an actress now she would have been like Han So Hee"
"I think it's her acting skills and the agency that got her the spotlight, not really as an idol to begin with"
"She reminds me of SISTAR's Bora though, the kind of face I like"
"Nine Muses' Minha? would have been really popular had she been in the current generation.. I think she might have been as popular as Wonyoung"

"Innocent look concepts suit her well, too"
"I think she would have amassed as many female fans as Han So Hee does"

What are your thoughts?