Want to join in on the discussion? It's easy to sign up!

Welcome to our community

What Do You Care About In An Idol?

Discussion in 'K-POP' started by emanresu, Apr 3, 2018.

  1. emanresu

    emanresu Icon

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Messages:
    22,859
    Likes Received:
    49,279
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Location:
    USA
    What Do You Care About In An Idol?

    [​IMG]


    For idols you stan or like what do you most care about? What don't you care about?

    Make a list and rate each category!

    Have Fun!


    TEMPLATE:

    (X Out Of 10)

    Vocals X
    Rapping X
    Dancing X
    Songwriting X
    Choreographing X
    Instrument Skill X
    Visuals X
    Personality/Charm X
    Acting X
    Variety/Hosting X
    Modeling/CF X
    (Other: Write In) X





    Me:
    What I Care About:

    Vocals 3
    Rapping 0
    Dancing 8
    Songwriting 0
    Choreographing 0
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 10
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 5
    Variety/Hosting 5
    Modeling/CF 8
    Other 0


    [​IMG]



    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    An Official Emanresu™ Thread
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Do You Like Popcorn?
    She's So Beautiful
    How Do You Make Thread Titles?
    I'm Gonna Adopt These F-ing Kids
    Idol You Think You'd Have A Chance With If They Weren't An Idol
    Do You Use Pinterest?
    Seolhyun Eating Noodles & Selling Phones
    Binnie An Astronaut? Arin In Pigtails? A Monkey Dance?

    Gifs Of Tzuyu-Ah
    Is Olivia Hye The Devil, The Black Wolf, Or A Gosh Darn Angel?
    LOONA Threatens BLACK PINK & RED VELVET, Not TWICE
    Who Is Olivia Hye & Why Do I Love Her So Much?
    G-Dragon Whines Like A Middle Schooler
    The Evolution Of Nayoung
    It's All Coelacanth's Fault (About BIG BANG)
    D.O. What's His Name
    The Most Underrated Groups
    Idols You Prefer With Short Hair
    Better Than Kim Jong Un's Rockets
    Eman's K-Drama Actress Rule #47
    What Kpop MV Is Most Nostalgic For You?
    I Love This Solo By Her. Do You?
    Pretty Sica
    Is Tzuyu The Most Adorable Idol Ever?
    When Was Your "Stan" Moment?
    Eunha Is One Of The Sexiest Girls In Kpop And No One Knows It
    Favorite Titles Of 2017-2018
    Great B-Sides
    Seolhyun Is The Most Gorgeous Thing I've Ever Seen
    Yoona - SuperELLE - Spring 2018 - [Photos + Interview]
    Tzuyu Is Daebak
    The Other Nayoung Thread
    The Angel From Taiwan In Black
    When's SM Trainee Yiyang Debuting?
    Joy Is Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Hot
    Are People Really That Naive?
    What Fresh Hell Is This?
    My New Crush Isn't Even Human
    I Stan Her Because It's Written In The Stars
    It's Against The Rules To Be This Pretty
    What's Your Phone/PC Background?
    Few Things In This World Compare To Her
    Tzuyu Is A Magician
    Who's Your Favorite MOMOLAND Member?
    The Thread We Need Right Now
    "Almost" Hits
    How Can I Purchase My Very Own Nayeon?
    GFRIEND Is The Perfect Blend Of Technical Proficiency, Youthful Purity, And Nostalgic Appeal
    Who Is Your Favorite RED VELVET Member?
    Who Is Your Favorite GFRIEND Member?
    Who Is Your Favorite TWICE Member?
    Tzuyu Loves Gucci More Than Jennie
    HELP! I Was Bitten By Dracula!
    Who Has The Best Body In Kpop? (3rd Generation)
    Tzuyu Says She's Not A Yoda. But She Is.
    I Just Love RED VELVET

    Favorite Songs From Harry Potter
    The Greatest Song In The World
    Song You're Currently Into
    Things You're Into
    That Moment When You Stan Another Man's Wife
    Could She Be The Next Seolhyun?
    What's With This Girl Crush Invading My Senses?
    Old Songs You Like
    Eman's K-Drama Favs - (Vol. 2)
    MOMOLAND's Yeonwoo To Make Acting Debut
    Is She The Hottest Thing In Kpop?
    Bring Sexy Back
    [PHOTO] TWICE - MLB Photoshoot - 180223
    Take My Money D-mnit
    Thank God For This Thread
    Beauty & Kpop
    2 Pickle. Pecan 1.
    The Actress Effect
    How To Look Miraculous Even When You're Airporting
    I'm Now A Legend Like Tzuyu
    I Don't Think They Make Them Better Than This
    What Do You Like Best About Your Favorite Group
    Who's Your First Great Love Of 2018?
    "I Feel Lacking When It Comes To Talent"
    She Is Literal Perfection
    I Just Got GUGUDAN-ed
    Getting That Exposure
    My Advice To CL. Stop Being Pretentious.
    It's Been At Least 48 Hours...
    Moonlight Angels?
    I Think TrueChoi Is A Chinese Spy
    Get Yeonwoo'd
    When's Pledis Gonna Have This Girl Kill Us?
    What's Your New Jam?
    Favorite Selcas
    Stan PRISTIN Because They Save Puppies
    I Want CRAYON POP Back
    Favorite GIFS
    2016 Luna Just Screwed Up My 2018
    OMG It's A Pink Tzuyu!
    Suzy Is An Underrated Artist
    SHOW US YOUR FUZZY PETS!
    Wayo F---ing Wayo
    How Many Children Do You Want To Have?
    Groups You Follow Mostly Because You Like A Certain Member
    What Kind Of Idols Do You Gravitate Toward?
    Eman's K-Drama Favs - (Vol. 1)
    "The Cuteness Melts The Hearts Of All Men"
    The Prettiest Actress In K-Drama
    Boy Groups Suck
    Anyone Like Taiwanese Dramas?
    Do You All Like Yeri?
    Does Everyone Hate Korean Beauty Standards?
    YES! YES! YES!
    Favorite "Nostalgia" Hits
    MOMOLAND - Boom Boom - Show Champion
    Seolhyun - Mind Bridge - Spring & Summer 2018
    What Are Your Groups?
    From Zero To Hero!
    Eman Reacts To TWICE Candy Pop
    Even When She Has No Idea...
    She's So Awkward...
    Oscar Nominees 2018
    Did You Notice Suzy Miracle Of Korea Came To Town?
    Who's Your MOMOLAND Bias?
    Cute Candids!
    Yoona - Grazia - "Miss Zero Negative Criticism"
    Good Lord She's Perfect
    [Allkpop] 2018: The Year Of Seolhyun
    She's The Best. Love Her World.
    How Many Idols?
    Suzy Is A God. Eman Says So.
    Yoona Breaks Record For Most Magazine Covers In A Single Year
    Who Are You Currently Crushing On? (Vol. 2)
    Idol Pics That Make You Smile
    Prettiest Or Most Handsome Idol Names
    Is Tzuyu The Prettiest Woman In The World?
    [16+] Do You Care About Virginity Or Level Or Sexual Experience In A Romantic Partner?
    Who's Your Pet Idol?
    Can Cute Groups/Idols Have "Stage Presence"?
    When Yoona Pouts I Pay Attention
    Men Are Easy
    Favorite Christmas Movies
    Holy Batman TWICE Has Done It
    BYE! I'm Moving To Seoul
    My Heart Is Shaken
    "Dahyun Told Me She Watches You Sleep"
    Yoona x Max Mara - Vogue Taiwan
    Do People Perceive You Differently?
    "You Can Feel Warmth Just By Looking At Her"
    Prettiest Idols/Actresses In Wedding Dresses
    [16+] What Would You Do If Your Favorite Idol Died?
    She Slayed The Dragon
    She's Great. Just Great. Don't Argue.
    Do You Think I'll Join The Army In 3 Months?
    Yoona - Elle Magazine - November 2017 - [Full Interview + Photos + Video]
    [Allkpop] Yoona Shares What She's Been Up To. Gives Advice To Young Women.
    Why Isn't YG Pushing BLACKPINK?
    This Is Why TWICE Works
    Yep. He's Crazy.
    [16+] Thank God Kpop Idols Are "Fake"
    Come. Listen.
    Which Idol Do You Want To Have A Movie Night With?
    Ya'll Got It Wrong. Signal Was Robbed By Signal.
    Sana In That Dress
    Sana Is A Bulbasaur
    Omo It's Momo
    She Slays Even When She's Not (Slaying)
    Is This Heaven?
    Does This Make You Cringe?
    Let Me Stare At Her Forever
    Is She Perfect?
    I Saw This Picture And Almost...
    [18+] Turn Ons During Sex
    Group Live Performance Closest To Your Heart
    Song You Recently Fell In Love With
    What's This RED VELVET Is Cute Business?
    Your Favorite '99 Liners
    "I Got So Distracted By Joy's Ass"
    How Do You Stan?
    I Just Watched BTS Perform At The AMAs
    [Appreciation No. 2] Nayoung & Her Chubby Cheeks Complete Me As A Fanboy
    BTS: A Hipster's Lament
    I'm In Love With Shin Se-Kyung
    Someone Tell Me About Kim Lip So I Can Fanboy Properly
    Favorite MVs That Aren't Because You Think They're All So Gosh Darn Pretty/Handsome
    Confess To Eman (Anonymously)
    TWICE - Likey [MV] | A Review By Emanresu
    The Most Important Group In Your Life
    How Important Is Physical Attractiveness To You (For Groups/Idols You Stan/Follow)?

    Idols You Miss
    Idols And Their Pets
    I Think I Like Yeri Now

    The Cutest Idol Ever Thread
    Prettiest/Most Handsome Person You've Known Personally
    I Never Thought I'd Get Into...
    I'm 28 And I Love Tzuyu
    One Photo That Best Sums Up Your Favorite Idol
    What's Your Favorite Fancam?
    Yoona's Short Hair Domination Continues (Eman Live On Location)
    Play It On Repeat. Your New Obsession.
    Who Are You Currently Crushing On?
    The Prettiest Idols In Kpop
    Who's Your Favorite Dancer In Kpop?
    That's So Bad For You!
    If Only You Weren't A One Hit Wonder
    How Do You React To Users/Threads You Feel Cross The Line?
    Yoona Cut Her Hair. Slayed Millions.
    Why Do You Love TWICE?
    It's Angel From Heaven Time With Your Friend Emanresu
    It Just Hit Me And I Am Sad. Tear.
    Share Your Beautiful Songs
    It's All IU's Fault In The End
    One Of These Nights I'm Gonna Velvet Your A**
    How Did You Get Into Kpop?
    Is BTS Gonna Save Me?
    What Are Your Favorite Ballads?
    Is Sleep-Walking The Best Song Of The Year?
    I Need More Like This Song - (Vol. 2)
    I Love And Hate V-Lives. What Should I Do?
    What A Derp! (AKA The Derpy Idol Thread)
    Will You Be My Buddy?
    Hey You Talk Funny!
    Most Attractive Korean Male Idol Or Actor?
    I Like Average Vanilla People. What About You?
    Is This Girl From HELLO VENUS Single?
    Dia Can't Stop Is A Bop!
    [Rant] When Sh-t Doesn't Go According To Plan
    What Do You Think Of Cute Aegyo Singing Voices?
    TWICE Songs Are Amazing! You Should Stan.
    My Heart Was Stolen By A Chipmunk
    Your Pet Group
    Favorite Idol From K-Pop Reality TV Show?
    God Called. Says Hi From Iceland.
    Idol That Fits Your Ideal Type
    I Need More Like This Song
    [Poll] How Many Groups?
    Age You First Had Sex
    Help! I've Been Caught Up In Some Kind Of Dream!
    Holy Guacamole!
    I'm An Old Wise Man. Are You?
    [Quiz] Which Yoona Character Should You Date?
    3 Turn-Ons / 3 Turn-Offs
    What's Your Favorite Disney Movie?
    What Do You Do When No One's Looking?
    3-Night Stand (Or) Marry In 5?
    Your Favorite Female Voice
    F-ck Yeah! Nostalgia! (Non-Kpop Band Or Song)
    How Many GBs Obsessed Are You?
    Yoona VS. Yoona VS. Yoona
    Jisoo VS. Yoona VS. Irene
    Jennie VS. Tzuyu VS. Seulgi
    Yoona Still Humble
    I Like Cute Girls. What About You?
    Uh Oh. Your Bias Is Drunk!
    Who Has The Best Figure In K-Pop?
    5 Things You Like About K-Pop
    Appreciate Your Second UB
    Are Any Idols "Sacred" To You?

    Dara Is A F-ing Witch
    Who's Your Favorite 3rd Generation Idol?
    I'm Addicted To Crayons, Power Rangers & Soda Pop
    Happy Birthday Yoona!
    [Rant] She Sure As Hell Ain't Useless

    What Are Your Favorite TWICE Songs?
    What's Your Theme Song?
    Which Idol Do You Love Now That You Didn't Before?
    Who Would You Save In A Fire?
    Rookie Is A Gosh Darn Masterpiece & RED VELVET Is Slaying My A**
    Can Psy Be A Funny Korean Fat Man Forever?
    I Don't Want K-Pop To Go Mainstream
    Why Does Everyone Hate BTS?

    Who/What Is BTS?
    Who Are The Prettiest K-Drama Actresses?
    Oh My Girl?
    Kill Me With That Aegyo Magic
    I Want To Get Hit In The Face With That SNSD Nostalgia
    So Why Do You All Hate Good Things?
    [Rant] Did You Forget? Yes. No. Maybe.
     
  2. notfunnybtw

    notfunnybtw Rookie

    Joined:
    Sep 9, 2017
    Messages:
    934
    Likes Received:
    1,960
    Trophy Points:
    1,000
    Occupation:
    BTS, Park Jinyoung, Henry, Taemin & The Rose stan.
    Location:
    Québec aka the most heartwarming city in the world
    Vocals 10
    Rapping 7
    Dancing 7
    Songwriting 10
    Choreographing 5
    Instrument Skill 4
    Visuals 5
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 6
    Modeling/CF 2

    I love idols who self-compose their songs. I have so much respect for them. To me, their music sounds even more authentic. Vocals are very important as I CANNOT stand whiny voices. Personalities too, or I'll only stan them as artists and not as persons. Visuals are always nice, but it's really not a deal breaker. Same thing goes for rapping. I have a crush on dancers, so good dancing and choreographing is always very cool. I don't care about other things.
     
    #2 notfunnybtw, Apr 3, 2018
    Last edited: Apr 3, 2018
  3. kKaliko

    kKaliko Idol

    Joined:
    Nov 14, 2017
    Messages:
    6,618
    Likes Received:
    11,759
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Occupation:
    RM MONO PR TEAM
    Location:
    MON STUDIO
    Vocals 6
    Rapping 9
    Dancing 6
    Songwriting 10
    Choreographing 2
    Instrument Skill 4
    Visuals 2
    Personality/Charm 9
    Acting 2
    Variety/Hosting 0
    Modeling/CF 0
     
    KidLeader112 and emanresu like this.
  4. Adu

    Adu Ace Of Hearts

    Joined:
    Apr 11, 2017
    Messages:
    18,401
    Likes Received:
    51,854
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Vocals 10
    Rapping 6
    Dancing 8
    Songwriting 7
    Choreographing 3
    Instrument Skill 5
    Visuals 4
    Personality/Charm 9
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 3
    Modeling/CF 2
     
  5. Jessicaaaaaa

    Jessicaaaaaa Super Rookie

    Joined:
    May 24, 2016
    Messages:
    1,480
    Likes Received:
    3,648
    Trophy Points:
    900
    Occupation:
    Triggered Army™and Protector of SHINee
    Vocals 8
    Rapping 10
    Dancing 9
    Songwriting 8
    Choreographing 7
    Instrument Skill 9
    Visuals 3
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 9
    Variety/Hosting 6
    Modeling/CF 2
     
    KidLeader112 and emanresu like this.
  6. emanresu

    emanresu Icon

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Messages:
    22,859
    Likes Received:
    49,279
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Location:
    USA
    I was surprised your rapping wasn't a 10. I've seen you talk about rapping a lot so I thought for sure that'd be the 10.

    But now that I think about it you always seem to focus more on the lyrics than the delivery.
     
  7. soshilovelife

    Joined:
    Mar 7, 2016
    Messages:
    18,503
    Likes Received:
    40,541
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Vocals 10
    Rapping 8
    Dancing 10
    Songwriting 5
    Choreographing5
    Instrument Skill 5
    Visuals 5
    Personality/Charm 7
    Acting 5
    Variety/Hosting 5
    Modeling/CF 5
    (Other: Write In) I explained below

    That pic makes me crave cappuccino and cookies
     
    #7 soshilovelife, Apr 3, 2018
    Last edited: Apr 3, 2018
    KidLeader112 and emanresu like this.
  8. drakan

    drakan Trendsetter

    Joined:
    Feb 26, 2018
    Messages:
    4,332
    Likes Received:
    10,297
    Trophy Points:
    4,300
    Vocals 7
    Rapping 10
    Dancing 7
    Songwriting 0
    Choreographing 0
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 10
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 0
    Modeling/CF 0
     
    KidLeader112 and emanresu like this.
  9. Coelacanth

    Coelacanth Super Rookie

    Joined:
    Feb 2, 2018
    Messages:
    1,942
    Likes Received:
    5,242
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Hm... I always have trouble ranking things out of ten, so I guess I'll rank them from most to least important in my eyes?

    Absolutely Essential

    (1) Personality
    -- A lot of idols (most idols, I'd say!) have great personalities and are fundamentally good people. And I don't need my idols to be flawless; making mistakes is a part of human nature. But I do need to believe that they're good at heart, and that they don't have some character flaw which will make them impossible to like. I find it hard to look past the bigoted comments certain idols have made, for example -- and impossible to look past things like domestic abuse, no matter how talented the perpetrator. Of course, genuinely kind and admirable idols are especially easy to like, and tend to win me over with their good personalities!

    (2) Rapping
    -- I don't mean, by this, that every idol has to be able to rap. But if rapping is an idol's primary position, I really do like them to be good at it. Great rappers win my heart every time; a huge proportion of my biases fall into that category! But weak rappers can turn me off of a song or even a group as a whole. I think rapping is a bit harder to "fake" than singing -- autotune and smaller numbers of lines can cover a subpar vocalist pretty easily, but the talent (or lack thereof) of a rapper is almost always clear.

    (3) Vocals
    -- It's totally fine for rappers not to have Kyuhyun-level vocals. But talent is pretty important to me when I'm following an idol or a group, and I do prefer it when singers are able to sing! Sometimes, great vocals alone are enough to win me over -- they're the reason I fell in love with both SHINee and Mamamoo!

    Important

    (4) Songwriting
    -- I like plenty of idols who don't write their own songs. But the ability of music to express emotions, and to transmit feelings from one person to another, is part of why I love it so much. I have a soft spot and a special admiration for idols who write their own lyrics, especially when those lyrics are as affecting as those of, say, Tablo (my UB.)

    (5) Dancing -- The least important of the "standard idol talents" in my book. Kpop has a strong visual component, to be sure, and I'm very impressed by good dancers. I don't mind, though, if an idol is less-strong in this department as long as they can sing or rap well. Music is consumed through the ears, after all; the performance side is the cherry on top! TOP isn't exactly known for being a dancing machine, and neither is Tablo, but their other skills make me love them anyway.

    Cool But Optional

    (6) Instrument Skill -- A totally optional talent, but it's a plus! I love idol bands just as much as traditional idol groups, and I wish they were more popular. I definitely respect a great drummer or guitar player. Musical talent is musical talent; instrument matters less than skill. That said, of course most idols don't play instruments at all, which doesn't bother me in the slightest.

    (7) Choreography -- Again, I do find dancing and all related fields slightly less important than the music itself -- so the production of choreography doesn't rank as highly as the writing of lyrics. It's totally great if idols can do this as well, of course. I've always admired Seventeen's choreography, which is largely created by the members themselves.

    (8) Variety -- I'm a fan of a good variety show, but not every idol is particularly charismatic and I accept that. Hell, there are some idols I love who shine in these kinds of situations (Heechul!) and others who are more awkward and don't do quite as well. But that's okay. I don't mind of an idol stammers his way through an interview as long as he can sing!

    Not Important

    (9) Acting; (10) Visuals; (11) Modeling/CF
    -- These are pretty much accessories to me, and I don't have any requirements on the looks/acting skills of idols who I follow. Some of my favorite rappers are almost homely, and hey, more power to them! If you can make a name in a visually-oriented industry without visuals, I think that's pretty cool and definitely worthy of respect. I appreciate attractive idols when I see them, but that definitely isn't as important to me as most other things.
     
  10. emanresu

    emanresu Icon

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Messages:
    22,859
    Likes Received:
    49,279
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Location:
    USA
    Nice list.

    I love your description at the end. Puts it all in context.

    :)
     
    notfunnybtw likes this.
  11. emanresu

    emanresu Icon

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Messages:
    22,859
    Likes Received:
    49,279
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Location:
    USA
    What instruments do the idols you stan play?
     
  12. seungriseyo

    Joined:
    Jul 8, 2016
    Messages:
    5,705
    Likes Received:
    13,699
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Vocals 8
    Rapping 8
    Dancing 0
    Songwriting 9
    Choreographing 0
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 7
    Personality/Charm 8
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 8
    Modeling/CF 7
    Other 0
     
    emanresu likes this.
  13. SquirtleYerimLuv

    SquirtleYerimLuv Public Figure

    Joined:
    May 11, 2017
    Messages:
    2,060
    Likes Received:
    5,596
    Trophy Points:
    2,000
    Vocals 6
    Rapping 0
    Dancing 6
    Songwriting 0
    Choreographing 0
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 6/7
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 8
    Modeling/CF 0
    (Other: Write In)
     
    emanresu likes this.
  14. emanresu

    emanresu Icon

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Messages:
    22,859
    Likes Received:
    49,279
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Location:
    USA
    What's your "Other"?

    You were supposed to write it in!

    :teeheek:

    I know that pic made me crave coffee as well. I had to go make a cup. I'm drinking it right now.

    :)
     
    soshilovelife likes this.
  15. lunachick415

    lunachick415 Rookie

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2016
    Messages:
    512
    Likes Received:
    843
    Trophy Points:
    500
    Vocals: 10/ 10
    Rapping: 5/10
    Dancing: 8/ 10
    Songwriting: 2/10
    Choreographing: 9/10
    Instrument Skill: 8/10
    Visuals: 5/10
    Personality/Charm: 10/10
    Acting: 0/10 (I don't watch dramas, lol. Nothing against them; they're just not appealing to me)
    Variety/Hosting: 0/10
    Modeling/CF: 5/10
    (Other: Write In):

    Honestly, what I love most about idols is when they seem natural, when they're naturally good singers, naturally good dancers, or naturally charming. When it looks like they're not TRYING to win you over, but are genuinely talented and charismatic just the way they are, it's always nice to see, especially in the Kpop world where everything is so scripted and forced to be picture perfect.
     
    emanresu likes this.
  16. whateverwonwoo

    whateverwonwoo Super Rookie

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2016
    Messages:
    1,563
    Likes Received:
    2,847
    Trophy Points:
    1,500
    Vocals 8
    Rapping 7 (it has to be bearable if i'm going to listen to them)
    Dancing 8
    Songwriting 5
    Choreographing 5 (idk if you meant the group choreographing for themselves or the actual choreography so I went for choreographing)
    Instrument Skill 5
    Visuals 2
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 8
    Modeling/CF 0
     
    emanresu likes this.
  17. Ling

    Ling The other 91%

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2016
    Messages:
    5,720
    Likes Received:
    16,284
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Vocals 8
    Rapping 4
    Dancing 8
    Songwriting 2
    Choreographing 6
    Instrument Skill 5
    Visuals 7
    Personality/Charm 10
    Acting 2
    Variety/Hosting 8
    Modeling/CF 2
     
    emanresu likes this.
  18. IQYZS

    IQYZS Married to @igloo
    .

    Joined:
    Feb 20, 2018
    Messages:
    3,303
    Likes Received:
    8,895
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Vocals 9
    Rapping 0
    Dancing 7
    Songwriting 0
    Choreographing 0
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 6
    Personality/Charm 8
    Acting 1
    Variety/Hosting 5
    Modeling/CF 0

    I really couldn't care less if an idol write songs and compose. I respect the idols who can, but it doesn't really change their music to me. Instrumental skills don't matter unless they're in a k-band. Personality and charm are important as idols. If you can't rap, that's fine and if you can, that's great. Visuals are important, but not nearly as important as vocals and dancing to me.
     
    emanresu and soshilovelife like this.
  19. katahtattat

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2016
    Messages:
    10,167
    Likes Received:
    10,367
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    if i am talking about individual idols it's probably something close to this

    Vocals 5
    Rapping 5
    Dancing 5
    Songwriting 6
    Choreographing 6
    Instrument Skill 0
    Visuals 7 though i don't have a particular visual type
    Personality/Charm 10 this is another one that i don't have a specific type. it all just depends if it catches my interest.
    Acting 0
    Variety/Hosting 5
    Modeling/CF 0

    under "other" i am including hobbies\interests, which i will give a 9 When an idol shares an interest with me, it's almost impossible for me not to be at least a little hooked.

    if the subject is idol acts then the artistic side of things is what's important to me
     
  20. soshilovelife

    Joined:
    Mar 7, 2016
    Messages:
    18,503
    Likes Received:
    40,541
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Oh shoot really?

    Ok

    Other: I'm still processing Oh my girl's new song lyrics. Sad jokes apart. I like to be surprised, that's why I wrote 5 in most of the categories that are indirectly related to performing. I don't really care if they are involved in it but if they do I'm glad for them. It's not like they are compulsory for me to like them. Thats why I gave a higher score to performance skills. I will change the score for personality but I fail to see it as a charm thus my mediocre score for it.

    My other will be the ability to reinvent themselves or to remain relevant in a competitive market.

    I think I filled that template lazily, let me fix it :p
     
    emanresu likes this.

Share This Page