Rules: - 3rd gen only. - Some groups not included because i don't know them well: Fromis, WJSN, Sonamoo, Laboum, etc. - Wheein not included. I'm too biased towards her so i won't include her. She easily could enter the top 10 tho. - There are some very well rounded groups in terms of stage pressence (Gfriend, Dreamcatcher, etc), however i'm focusing only on individual performance here. 1. Hwasa - Mamamoo Never dissapoints. She knows how to have fun on stage and look like she doesn't give a fuck. Praised by literally everyone, she's known as the fatal unnie for a reason. Spoiler 2. Soyeon - G Idle I'm gonna be really honest. I hated this girl when she appeared on PD101. Her voice was annoying and she was always trying too hard to be a badass. HOWEVER, now she won me. She is like a completely new person: talented, charismatic an A+ performer. She's got a bright future ahead. Same as Hwasa, she was born to be on a stage. Hopefully they can collab together sometime soon. Spoiler 3. Solar - Mamamoo She can be cute, sexy and a badass. Versatility at it's best. She always brings an honest and cheerful smile to the stage. Always having fun. Never disappoints. Spoiler 4. Seulgi - Red Velvet She knows how to handle a stage. Sometimes it feels like she carries the whole performance of RV. She's amazing, enchanting and talented. She could be even higher but i feel like sometimes she has a little bit of trouble with some cute concepts of her group. Spoiler 5. Yuqi - G Idle Although she doesn't really go with the girl crush concept she manages to bring a bright and cute vibe to G-idle. Also, with Alone she proved she can pull off a serious and dark concept too at perfection. Spoiler 6. Jihyo - Twice You always feel like she's having the time of her life on stage. Really, i don't know how she can always put a smile on her face (a genuine one) considering Twice barely have any time to breathe between schedules. Spoiler 7. Soojin - G Idle She is like a combination between Hwasa and 4minute's Jiyoon. She's sassy, badass and fits really well the concept of her group. ALSO: before someone calls me biased towards G-idle, i want to say i don't know anything about this girl and although the three girls i listed are amazing the rest lacks a lot on the stage pressence area, specially Shuhua and Miyeon. Spoiler 8. Sun J - Girlkind Amazing dancer, always giving her best smile even when the songs she has to perform are tragic. Hidden gem here. Spoiler Could't find any decent gif lol. But she's the one in the ugly blue thing. 9. Seungyeon - CLC Girl crush at it's best. Amazing performer and dancer. Cube please don't fuck it up with this girl and CLC. Spoiler 10. Lisa - Blackpink Hit or miss. Sometimes she gives the performance of her life and the next day she doesn't try too hard at all. She still have plenty of time to work on that. Anyway, when she's in a good mood she excels charisma on stage. Spoiler Please comment if you think i miss someone since obviously i'm not familiar with ALL 3rd gen groups.
Jennie doesn't really stand out for me on stage. However, it is true that she sometimes have her moments but she makes it too obvious when she doesn't really want to perform. About Sinb, she's good but imo she suits the girl crush concept much more and she doesn't get the chance to shine with Gfriend's cute concept.
List looks pretty good. Maybe a bit IDLE biased though. Need to see a lot more stages from them before having 3 of them in the top 10.
Hmm I think you ought to have added CLC's Yeeun to the list because she totally owns the stage.... also literally just put all of Mamamoo at the top lmao let's allow other girls to be on the top 10 too. I think even though Lisa's a hit or miss, she should be higher than that.... Although I do get that she mostly only owns the stage when she's in a good mood. Performing is close to her heart and I think that's why her performances are very much dependent on mood- she can't fake it. It's okay, but as an idol she'll eventually learn. SinB's good, but I doubt she's as good as the people on the list... and the problem with Jennie is that even though she's sexy af, has a great body and dances with elegance, her facial expressions never change. I think she feels like she HAS to go with a particular vibe for a song and that's understandable, but it can get boring, especially when you have someone as fun and lively like Lisa around
I thought about her but the recent promotions of Baam don't look really appealing. Maybe all the shit going on affected her but still, she's definitely an honorable mention.
Yeeun is really good, she's a runner up easily. However i think she mostly brights with girl crush concepts. I'm mostly basing my list on versatility among all the concepts done by each group. About Lisa, yeah, she's got an amazing charisma sometimes but when she's not in the mood she doesn't try too hard. Same we could say for Wheein, only difference is she doesn't really fake a smile. If Wheein is having a shitty day she doesn't really hides it. Lisa needs more experience on stage to control that.
agree with everything but what about Sana? i feel she has more stage presence rather than Jihyo Jihyo is more energetic and smiley (always the same happy face) whereas Sana’s has the ability to switch between concepts, her facial expressions are more versatile and overall she is better for me tbh her fancams are the most interesting to watch for
1. Hwasa 2. Soyeon 3. Nayeon - she literally shines on stage 4. Solar 5. Soojin 6. Lisa 7. Jungyeon 8. Joee 9. Jennie(i put her this low bc her stage presence depends on her mood lol) 10. Rose i’d like to mention Nancy and Yeonwoo~ all Momoland members have pretty great stage presence CLC members as well, they are really good! Elkie for example
