Want to join in on the discussion? It's easy to sign up!

Welcome to our community

Jin should leave BTS

Discussion in 'K-POP' started by haylucky, Jul 7, 2017.

Tags:
  1. haylucky

    haylucky Leader

    Joined:
    Mar 7, 2016
    Messages:
    9,186
    Likes Received:
    14,349
    Trophy Points:
    0




    *・゜゚・*
    The mistreatment of Jin - a BigHit callout post
    A lot of people seem to think that BigHit could never do wrong and know what’s best for BTS. They think BigHit and BTS are a “family”. Well it’s time to wake up..! BigHit isn’t any better when compared to big companies like SM or YG for example. They’re just as problematic like K-Pop companies often tend to be. The perfect example of this is how they’ve been treating Jin these past 4 years.

    !! - a few of these facts are just borderline emotional abuse..
    okay, let’s get started:

    - Apparently Bang-PD walked around calling Jin fat???? wtf (this was 2013, before their debut and around the same time Jin went on a diet no one talks about where he only ate chicken breast for A YEAR.)

    [​IMG]
    - And guess what? Bang-PD isn’t the only one who has called Jin fat: even his manager did. Fortunately they fired him because he was mistreating Jungkook.

    - Jin majored in acting but in the House of ARMY, he got all the insignificant roles with basically zero dialogue. Yoongi even said Seokjin had texted him, shocked that he didn’t have any dialogue in the script. In the Making of-video he was clearly pissed: when the camera man said they’ll be filming Jin next he said “Oh, wow. Do I get to appear alone?” asdfghjkl. Jin was salty, but tried so hard to be positive. (he even avoided looking straight into the camera while they were interviewing him.. on the inside he was definitely feeling wronged.)

    - Let’s be honest. BigHit could easily push him in the OST direction or debut him as an actor if they wanted, but no.

    - Jin was once forced to perform even though he had hurt his neck in Kcon Paris. BigHit never made an official report about his condition… (it’s funny how they made a report about namjoon’s toe and suga’s ear but not this.)

    [​IMG]
    - Now let’s talk about his LINES. Remember Blood, Sweat and Tears where he had to share his few lines with Jimin? That was the most unnecessary thing ever. (later in the japanese ver. they made jin’s voice stand out more than jimin’s. lol I guess even BigShit felt a bit guilty??) I’ve seen people trying to defend this by saying that it’s okay because Jin was the ~Main Character~ in the MV. But honestly, where is the logic in that? BTS are a K-pop group! Their voices are the most important thing about them!

    [​IMG]
    - Jin is the only one who didn’t get a single line in any of the year end 2016 special stages (rainism: jungkook, as i told you: jimin, v, jungkook & class idea: namjoon, hoseok, jungkook… suga wasn’t there because of his ear injury.) He was just a backup dancer and nothing else.

    - Remember when people were hyping up Spring Day because apparently this was supposed to be the song where Jin would shine… even V said Jin would surprise us all and umm.. well he didn’t.

    - BigHit removed Jin from the thumbnail of Not Today MV because ????

    - Speaking of Not Today. Let’s talk about this fuck up…

    [​IMG]
    - *coughs* This was his only solo shot and it lasted about 2 seconds. Really. BTS filmed for almost 24 hours in cold weather and you’re telling me this is the only shot of Jin that was “good enough”. I don’t think so, because we saw the Behind the scenes-video and they were filming Jin quite a lot. They just didn’t use the clips.

    [​IMG]
    Originally posted by taejinmin

    - They keep telling Jin his voice is suited for ballads, but Butterfly was a ballad and he was once again the vocal who had the least amount of lines. (and some of them were not even lines like repeating “untrue” is.. not really a line)

    [​IMG]
    - … so basically the ballad comment was just some bs excuse, let’s be real no one fits only 1 type of music. Plus here are some Bangtan’s slower/not hiphop songs I think Jin’s voice could easily be fitted in but he still got the least amount of lines: Spring Day Studio Version, Miss Right, YNWA, Just One Day, Outro: Propose, House of Cards, Coffee…

    [​IMG]
    - Now the most recent fuck up is BTS’ cover of Seo Taiji’s song ‘Come Back Home’ and people are still debating whether Jin has ANY lines at all. The MV for the song was uploaded to CJENMMUSIC’sofficial youtube and their header was changed to a… group photo… of BTS… except Jin was nowhere to be seen. The fact that they forgot Jin is unbelievable and just plain disrespectful. No product should ever be released without approval and double check. None. And while we don’t know if BigHit had anything to do with the header, whose fault it is that even these other companies tend to forget Jin because they aren’t promoting him enough? This was not a simple mistake. It means that design and marketing teams from HUGE companies like CJEN don’t see him.

    [​IMG]
    - Awake: Jin’s first solo song he wrote and produced. He is talking about his own experience in this song. It’s a sad song. He’s saying that maybe he can’t fly as high as those petals (=other BTS members) but he’s still going to accept it and keep struggling. He wants to hold those 6 petals close and keep them safe so he’s going to make sacrifices. If this isn’t the most heartbreaking thing I don’t know what is…

    - Jin had actually wrote a few songs and lyrics for their songs before ‘Awake’ but they were all turned down by the producers. (the fact that he didn’t give up on writing music still amazes me..)

    - Despite all this there are some Antis who believe Jin is okay with his lack of lines and spotlight, because they think BTS handle the line distribution which is not the case. For example, Namjoon once even said that he was originally supposed to do Suga’s part in 21st Century Girls but Bighit changed it. It’s always the company who gets to decide things like this.

    He wants to sing. Jin has said multiple times he wants ARMY to hear more of his voice. Doesn’t this prove he wants more attention and isn’t happy with how things are right now? This is from the new concept book interview:

    Q: For the next album or promotions do you have any personal greed for bigger importance?
    Jin: Of course I do have those thoughts… but each member have their own color. If the song suits it, there’ll be more parts and if not, there’ll unavoidably be lesser.

    Q: Aren’t you anxious?
    Jin: Being anxious doesn’t solve anything. If I do my best at where I am, some day there’ll be a song that suits me.

    “Some day”, he said. But when is that day going to be? It’s been 4 years. Fire was a step in the right direction but then BST, Spring Day and Not Today came out.

    Like I said before, BigHit has convinced Jin that his “voice color” doesn’t fit BTS and has put the blame on him. Shouldn’t it be the company’s fault that they can’t make a song that fits all 7 members? There are K-pop groups with more than 7 members and they still have better line distribution? BigHit’s line distribution is obviously shit and they’re favoring only certain members.

    Of course they are favoring members like Jungkook, he has a better and more stable voice than Jin.” - maknae line solo stan

    [​IMG]
    While I do agree that Jungkook has a super stable, golden voice, so does Jin. It’s unfair when they give Jungkook 80% of the vocals in every song.

    Almost every song the vocal line from most lines to least lines looks like this:

    Jungkook - Jimin - V - Jin

    Why does it have to be like this every time? Why does BigHit hate variety and trying out new things? Would it be the end of the world if Jin and V got the most and the second most lines?

    It’s not Jungkook’s fault. Even he suffers when he has to sing all of these songs live.. BigHit puts so much pressure on him. Have you ever thought about how tiring it must be for him? When you have the most lines in every song and everyone expects you to always sing flawlessly? I’m sure even Jungkook has noticed that BigHit depends too much on him. In Spring Day they gave some of Jungkook’s lines to Jin in the live version which was one of their best decisions, but.. I still can’t stop wondering why Jin can’t have these lines in the studio version too? The version people are going to buy and listen?

    So.. why the heck is Jin still part of BTS? They don’t let him sing or dance in the front lines. He is supposed to be ~the visual~ but in their latest comeback he didn’t even get a lot of solo shots in their MVs. I’m scared that it’ll just keep getting worse. We all know there are some fake ARMYs who would definitely hype up a song even if Jin didn’t have any lines, even if the line distribution was the most unfair thing ever.

    BigHit is completely wasting Jin’s potential. He could be so much more. His looks are so powerful SM tried to scout him, BigHit scouted him because of them.. Strangers wanted pictures with him predebut. He even trended on twitter because he looked so stunning when he stepped out of a car. Jin had no previous dance or singing experience before BTS and had to learn everything and try his best to keep up with the other members. Now Jin’s voice is super stable and beautiful. He can do high notes, his voice doesn’t only suit ballads, but other genres as well. Jin is extremely hardworking and a kind person. He can be the oldest hyung and the secret maknae. He loves BTS and ARMY. He blows kisses, makes lame jokes and never misses an opportunity to show his love. Remember his Heart Events? Let’s not forget that the clothes Jin wears to airports are usually fan gifts. A lot of them don’t match with each other, but he doesn’t seem to care because he just wants to show them off.

    Over the years he has come up with his own ways to make a name for himself (eatjin, dad jokes, worldwide handsome, hand kisses) even though it’s BigHit’s job to do so..

    Jin is just too nice.. He’s been patient with BigHit for 4 years and hardly ever complains. He has told us that he tends to hold all the emotions inside. That’s why ARMY needs to have his back. We need appreciate him and his efforts and make him feel happy to be part of BTS. In Bon Voyage 2, he calmly said: “The most important thing in my life is convincing myself that I’m happy. Being happy is making others smile.” Now… you know when you have to CONVINCE yourself to be happy there’s obviously something wrong.

    We don’t know what’s going on behind the scenes but we do know that Jin is the type of person to not show his negative emotions. Jin is mentally very strong, but has difficulties standing up for himself so we need to help him. If the next comeback he doesn’t have any lines again, PLEASE DON’T STAY QUIET ABOUT IT. Let BigHit know we are sick and disgusted of how they’re treating the oldest member. It’s OT7, right?

    [​IMG]
    Originally posted by bangtannoonas

    A reminder that Jin doesn’t need to be your bias for you to acknowledge the fact that he deserves a bigger role in BTS!
    While we wait for a comeback, there are things you can do for Jin. You can make tweets (people have been trying to trend #WeWantSeokjin for a while now), gifs and posts about him, listen to Jin’s solo and covers x / x, comment on his twitter posts (we all know they read them) and if he does a vlive you can support him by watching it and by showering him with hearts.

    Please make him a more popular member, so that BigHit can’t ignore him anymore. After all we are here to stan the 7 boys of BTS, not Bang-PD, Pdogg or BigHit.

    Thank you for reading!


    MORE YOU MIGHT

    See the rest of this Tumblr



    I don't think he should leave but things are messed up for him
    It must be hard for Jin stans out there
     
    #1 haylucky, Jul 7, 2017
    Last edited: Jul 7, 2017
  2. Flyingpetals

    Flyingpetals Leader

    Joined:
    Dec 30, 2016
    Messages:
    8,248
    Likes Received:
    28,530
    Trophy Points:
    8,200
    Occupation:
    Apple
    Location:
    Supermarket
    No he should not
    Jin said he finally found a way to make his parents proud and that is by being in BTS
    When he leaves what is he going to do?
    do those delulu fans actually think he has the vocal ability to keep himself afloat?
    Furthermore, even though he can get into acting his future is still very unsure
    Unless he can establish himself and grow on his own (which is unlikely) he STILL NEEDS BTS
     
  3. kamypop

    kamypop Trendsetter

    Joined:
    Jan 30, 2017
    Messages:
    5,480
    Likes Received:
    27,365
    Trophy Points:
    5,400
  4. IgotExosBangtan

    Joined:
    May 7, 2017
    Messages:
    5,815
    Likes Received:
    29,905
    Trophy Points:
    5,800
    Location:
    Minseok’s secret mansion
    Deadass wanna start a trend. #respectseokjin. He deserves more and should be respected. The other members and fans aren't the problem. It's the company that keeps fucking Jin over. BTS wouldn't be BTS with Jin, his talent, his corny ass dad jokes we all love and his windshield wiper laugh.
     
  5. haylucky

    haylucky Leader

    Joined:
    Mar 7, 2016
    Messages:
    9,186
    Likes Received:
    14,349
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Well I don't hibo he should leave but Jin could still be an actor if he's any good and we don't even know plus there's the fact since he's not pushed often the solo songs on the wings album were sold best with popular members Jimin Jungkook V Suga
     
  6. Vipmultifandom10

    Vipmultifandom10 Married to @RoAnon9935
    .

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2016
    Messages:
    6,160
    Likes Received:
    16,462
    Trophy Points:
    6,100
    Location:
    from multifandom land where there are no haters
    Well my honest opinion.
    I just think jongkook is overrated. (Like seriously i just hate how people and so called armys call jongkook and v good looking and call rapmon and jhopie ugly)
    Thats all. Okay bye.
     
  7. TzuyuGirl

    TzuyuGirl Public Figure

    Joined:
    May 9, 2017
    Messages:
    2,010
    Likes Received:
    2,249
    Trophy Points:
    0
    If he want too then I don't have problem with it , but I am sure he doesn't want too .
     
  8. Multifandom_hoe

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2016
    Messages:
    13,288
    Likes Received:
    44,607
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Occupation:
    Army cult leader
    Location:
    Army discord
    [​IMG]
     
  9. EGG

    EGG Idol

    Joined:
    Jun 24, 2017
    Messages:
    6,201
    Likes Received:
    48,464
    Trophy Points:
    6,200
    Occupation:
    12 year old music critic
    Location:
    somi's heart
    This injustice saddens me so much
    In BTS jin and V are my biases so stuff like this always hurts me
    JIN HAS IMPROVED MORE THAN ANYONE SINCE DEBUT
    He can now dance and his vocals are at the same level as Junkooks (in terms of tecnique at least). He is a subsub-vocal with tecnique as good as the main and better than the lead, and still he doesn't get lines?!?!?
    I get that jungkook gets lines because he is good at singing and dancing at the same time, but if it ruins your performances, WHY MAKE YOUR DANCES SO EXCESSIVE??!?!????!????
    Oh BTW, anyone remember awake, aka the best solo from wings, the lyrics show how diminished Jin's confidence is after being treated so poorly
    Honestly if this continues I want him to leave
    In fact I think the only reason he is staying is for his members, he doesn't want the team to split of, as they've stated that if one leaves they would disband
    His situation is really just sad, if it doesn't improve it might be better for BTS' sake if the disband sadly:'( .....
     
  10. TzuyuGirl

    TzuyuGirl Public Figure

    Joined:
    May 9, 2017
    Messages:
    2,010
    Likes Received:
    2,249
    Trophy Points:
    0
    His cheeks does look a little chubby here :sketchyk:
     
    haylucky likes this.
  11. shantafanta

    shantafanta Rookie

    Joined:
    Jul 19, 2016
    Messages:
    642
    Likes Received:
    976
    Trophy Points:
    0
    I hope Bighit will open their eyes.

    BTS is not Jungkook and then some.

    If leaving BTS is what is best for Jin, he should leave, as much as it hurts me to say so, because he really does deserve much more than what he has now. It's not even like he's the least popular, because he is consistently 3rd or 4th in the rankings, so I don't see a reason why Bighit is treating him like that.
     
  12. Multifandom_hoe

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2016
    Messages:
    13,288
    Likes Received:
    44,607
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Occupation:
    Army cult leader
    Location:
    Army discord
    Stop! just stop with your fake concern.
    Recently you were talking about BTS being a temporary group, how they would lose fans and some shit like that, now you pity Jin?
    Don't make me laugh.
     
  13. symlgs

    symlgs Trendsetter

    Joined:
    Oct 24, 2016
    Messages:
    4,168
    Likes Received:
    11,124
    Trophy Points:
    0
    TBH when I saw someone post this all on Instagram, I thought that they really tried to search deep. Some parts I understand that they get mad like him being removed on the thumbnail and not being part of the groups pic with "come back home", I was mad myself too. But the other things are exaggerated. Most CEOs will tell their artists that they gained weight and Bang PD probs did it to the other members too. Jackson of Got7 even said that JYP told him that he looked fat on screen so that he needed to lose weight, Jackson even said he was thankful for that. Nothing bad, he thinks about his image. The neck injury seemed to happen during the performance, I feel like I don't even need to explain how the lines get disturbed. BTS makes songs that doesn't suit his voice because it suits the others. Also Jin himself said he doesn't want to do acting anymore, he is fully focused on singing. He definitely shouldn't leave the group, what kind of BS is that.
     
  14. Flyingpetals

    Flyingpetals Leader

    Joined:
    Dec 30, 2016
    Messages:
    8,248
    Likes Received:
    28,530
    Trophy Points:
    8,200
    Occupation:
    Apple
    Location:
    Supermarket
    He could still be an actor yes but he hasnt shown Korea what he can do
    so if he leaves now and gets into acting
    the only people that would support him are the ones wanting him to leave

    I personally think he should stay until he can actually have something to fall back on
    he is learning how to write, play instruments and produce music in BTS
    even with the line distribution thing
    He is still growing as artist
    I dont see any reason why he should just jump ship

    If I were in his shoes I wouldnt.
    I'd milk as much as I can in a group thats garnering immense popularity, learn everything that I can and then when I'm established, leave and do what ive always wanted to do.

    As much as I love him
    I think it's stupid if he leaves
    and I think it's stupid that fans are asking him to leave
    They tend to not see the whole picture
    Decisions as drastic as that need to be deeply thought about
     
  15. whateverwonwoo

    whateverwonwoo Super Rookie

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2016
    Messages:
    1,556
    Likes Received:
    2,826
    Trophy Points:
    1,500
    i don't think he should leave bts, but the company needs to start treating him right. just look at how popular he is for his looks alone? if they pushed him forward, he could bring so much more to the group, but bighit won't bc they don't see that. i'm surprised taehyung gets as much screentime/line distribution as he does, in my honest opinion the two of them are on the same level so surely you would use both of them to your advantage? idk, the amount of lines jungkook and jimin get are ridiculous, bighit needs to stop flaunting them but they won't and honestly, who knows why? like how hard is it to get jin and acting role if they can get taehyung one????? i'm not even a fan and i can see everything that is wrong
     
  16. Multifandom_hoe

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2016
    Messages:
    13,288
    Likes Received:
    44,607
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Occupation:
    Army cult leader
    Location:
    Army discord
    Its not that deep guys lol. And for all the people with the fake concern, y'all can disperse now. Thank you.:rolleyes:
     
  17. Couponski

    Couponski Married to @Abeamus
    .

    Joined:
    Apr 15, 2016
    Messages:
    8,200
    Likes Received:
    17,297
    Trophy Points:
    0
    I feel bad for him, but I don't want him to leave.
    BigHit needs to change something, the line distribution is every time the same, it gets really boring.
    When they say that Jin's voice doesn't fit BTS , they should produce a song which fits his voice, then give him more lines, let him shine even when it's just for one song and Jungkook and Jimin could sing less in this song.

    They shouldn't just experimenting with their music but also with the line distribution.
     
    sarang_heyooo and haylucky like this.
  18. LegendaryTsunade

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2016
    Messages:
    7,868
    Likes Received:
    26,864
    Trophy Points:
    7,800
    Occupation:
    Stanning the same group forever
    Location:
    TaehyungLand
    Are you forgetting that this is mostly about business and they're doing their job? Seeing BTS literally on top rn, I'm sure BigHit know what they're doing. After all - they've been behind BTS' success all this time.
    It's true and it kinda hurts me too, to see that Jin isn't participating in everything as much as I would like - but I'm sure they'll pave a path for him once BTS tries to cool down from all the group promoting. They will all get a chance but if they believe that this is how it's supposed to be patterned then who are we to say anything? Just support your fave and shut up.
     
  19. haylucky

    haylucky Leader

    Joined:
    Mar 7, 2016
    Messages:
    9,186
    Likes Received:
    14,349
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Oh come one you were not mad about the come back home poster especially since Jin is a visual and also knowing how Jin takes offense to this stuff as in idk why that isn't that deep
     
    Multifandom_hoe likes this.
  20. Multifandom_hoe

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2016
    Messages:
    13,288
    Likes Received:
    44,607
    Trophy Points:
    10,000
    Occupation:
    Army cult leader
    Location:
    Army discord
    Most of the people saying shit don't give a single fuck about BTS.
     

Share This Page