Tag

  • Supreme Court overturns previous rulings in the plagiarism lawsuit against J.Y. Park and orders retrial

    August 13, 2015 @ 12:04 am

    J.Y. Park is finally catching a break in the ongoing plagiarism lawsuit filed against him. This issue has been going for several years now, and every time, the court had ruled against the producer, ordering him to pay composer Kim Shin Il for plagiarism.However, in the final appeal that J.Y. Park's side filed to fight the previous court decisions, the Supreme Court has sided with the producer. The Supreme Court found that a song from 2002 by an A

    Read More

    • 30
    • 20747
    • 4330
  • J.Y. Park loses his appeal on plagiarism case, fined $54,000 USD

    January 23, 2013 @ 4:46 pm

    J.Y. Park has lost his appeal against composer Kim Shin Il. Last year, J.Y. Park had lost the initial case claiming that he had plagiarized the 'Dream High' OST "Someday" from Kim Shin Il's "To My Man". After losing the case, he then appealed the ruling and their court date had been rescheduled to January. On January 23rd at 2:10 PM KST, the appeal case was held. In the original ruling from the lower court, J.Y. Park was stated to pay t

    Read More

    • 0
    • 95041
    • 46689
  • J.Y. Park and Kim Shin Il to continue their legal battle over plagiarism controversy in January

    December 13, 2012 @ 12:06 am

    J.Y. Park will be returning to court again next month to continue with his appeal against the original ruling of the plagiarism case. He had previously lost the case as the judge ruled that J.Y. Park's 'Dream High' OST, "Someday" had plagiarized Kim Shin Il's work, Ash's "To My Man", a song composed back in 2005. J.Y Park appealed the sentence, stating that the measures in question could be found in his previous works as well from before 2

    Read More

    • 0
    • 44887
    • 51589
  • J.Y. Park and Kim Shin Il attend appeals hearing for plagiarism controversy

    November 8, 2012 @ 12:32 am

    J.Y. Park appeared in court to attend the appeals trial following the initial ruling on the plagiarism case that took place earlier this year. On the afternoon of the 7th, he took part in the new appeals hearing to deny the plagiarism accusations of composer Kim Shin Il. As reported previously, Kim Shin Il claimed that "Someday" from the 'Dream High 1′ OST plagiarized Ash's "To My Man", a song he had composed in 2005. He filed a suit f

    Read More

    • 0
    • 39700
    • 53790
  • Court rules against J.Y. Park in plagiarism controversy case

    February 10, 2012 @ 7:22 am

    At the beginning of last year, a plagiarism controversy arose involving IU's "Someday" from the 'Dream High 1' OST. "Someday" was found to possess a very similar chorus line to Ash's "To My Man", and as a result, its composer (Kim Shin Il) decided to sue producer J.Y. Park in July of last year. The Seoul Central District Court has ruled on February 10th in favor of Kim Shin Il, acknowledging the likeness between the four measures in questi

    Read More

    • 0
    • 51529
    • 0
  • J.Y. Park sued over plagiarism controvers​y involving "Someday"

    July 12, 2011 @ 2:34 pm

    A few months back, there were some rumors going around that accused J.Y. Park of plagiarism. Netizens debated fiercely over whether his 'Dream High' OST track, "Someday", snatched a chorus from one of songwriter Kim Shin Il's works. According to the Seoul Central District Court, Kim Shin Il claimed that "They plagiarized "To My Man" from ASH's 2nd album." Since J.Y. Park was the songwriter and lyricist of "Someday", he is being sued for 11

    Read More

    • 0
    • 12
    • 0
  • Kim Shin Il to file a plagiarism lawsuit against Park Jin Young's "Some Day"

    January 31, 2011 @ 5:41 am

    The plagiarism debate between IU's "Some Day" (produced by Park Jin Young) and Ash's "To My Man" (produced by Kim Shin Il) has developed into a legal battle. On January 31st, a representative of Kim Shin Il's agency revealed to Star News, "After speculations of plagiarism between 'Someday' and 'To My Man' broke out, representatives of the agency held a two-day meeting on the 29th and 30th.  Kim Shin Il revealed that he will be filing a law

    Read More

    • 0
    • 5124
    • 0