NEW USER? | FORGOT PASSWORD?
rss
 

Wonder Girls vs. Se7en vs. Utada, who will break through first?

431 Comments

johnnydorama in General | 16 May 2009 - 06:28 PM

 
Wonder Girls, Se7en and BoA

NYC's local news station NY1 has been running a promo for their upcoming Asian Heritage Week segment, in which they will air interviews with the Wonder Girls, Se7en and Utada!

I was able to briefly catch up with Lewis Dodley (Evening Anchor NY1) at Se7en's NYC Single Release Party at Circle Nightclub, where we discussed which Asian artist would break through first in the US Market. I won't reveal where we left off, but take our poll below, who do you think will break through first? Wonder Girls, BoA, Utada, Se7en, or Crown J?!?!








Which Asian artist do you think will break through first?

  
 

advertisement

Comments

down up

16 May 2009 - 06:31 PM

1. samuel (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

First and se7en

 
Kristy's avatar

I think BoA. SHe’s more of the states style.

 
Lexay's avatar

se7en all the way!

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 06:33 PM

5. Eden (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Utada. BoA has already failed. Utada is the only one getting radio play. Se7en is too busy partying to actual do anything. What was the point of being affiliated with allkpop?  As if the people here don’t already know he’s releasing in the US. Fail.

 
jeehyuni's avatar

hmm there’s only 3 comments here and mmore people just voted rather than leaving a comment as to why…
hmm it would have to be boa but thenn, doesn’t us like more upbeat dance-y songs….. so idk wonder girls?
don’t hate on me just cause i picked wonder girls. it’s just imo

 
no avatar

i think boa, because utada’s tried, but both are a close tie.
as much as i love wondergirls, i dunno, i’ll have to wait and see.
as for se7en, i have no idea.

 
juhaynee's avatar

i say either boa or se7en..def. not wondergirls and maybe utada.

 
Literati Tempo's avatar

So far I’ve heard the most from Utada here in the states. So I voted for her. It’s still early (for most of them), so it’s really anyone’s game right now.

 
k-addict11's avatar

Probably Utada.

 
tomoko's avatar

as much as i love them all (except crown j…) BoA is so far ahead of everyone else…

 
Meru's avatar

Utada. Even though she’s fluent, it’s gonna be tough for everybody.

 
tangy's avatar

as much as i adore Se7en


i think it’s gonna be Utada….next up BoA

WG and Crown J have got nothing on them

se7en’s in a weird place right now…....T___T
it’s like he’s pending

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 06:40 PM

14. yezer (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

CHARICE PEMPENGCO. LOL.
define asian music. i personally don’t get it.

 
humorFool's avatar

BoA all the way! :D

 
brendahh14's avatar

Utada or BoA.

 
Yumilovkpop's avatar

utada’s the only one i’ve been hearing on radio very often.


Utada’s songs also are actually really qualityied, as much as ai LOVEEE \boA, she doesn’t seem to be going anyuwhere much

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 06:44 PM

18. yontbont (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

probably boa i dont think wonder girls will be able to at all tho considering how well they speak engrish

 
Yumilovkpop's avatar

it’s funny how most of the comments are on utada, but the votes arent.

 
Raihn's avatar

I would have to say Utada. She composes her own music and lyrics and has gotten more recognition and air play here than any of the other artists. I think I heard se7en’s song on the radio ONCE out of how many months? And Boa’s song too “I did it for love”, how many times have I heard that being played on the radio, so far none.

I think out of all those artists, Utada will be the best bet to do well in the states. Of course, I’m hoping they all do REALLY well. But if one can come out the strongest than the others, then that’s okay too, atleast it’s one rather than none.

 
vicks's avatar

Utada her first lang. is english and she has the talent. writing her own songs and singing.

 
no avatar

i agreee, what the heck is boa doing all this time.. and se7en parties too much, well thats how you really promote songs down here in america : radios and shows. so se7en is actually doing well. and wondergirls have had concerts so they’re doing well too. and crown j… i duntknow.  utada is doing really well also. so its anyones game raspberry but i think ill root for se7en , he has that american feel.

 
Tynice's avatar

stay positive. so i have to say its wg:)
ive listened to boa and utada’s album. i’m not really feeling them. though i like a few songs from boa’s.

 
ehsna_wonder_fan's avatar

I can’t pick. But definitely not BoA, not Utada, and not crown J. Se7en is a maybe and Wonder Girls is a “I just dunno”...
BoA and Utada have been TRYING FOR YEARS, but nothing is happening. So i don’t think anything is going to happen now. I don’t think US don’t like those types that much,cause if you’re going to go solo, you have to be like Rihanna to do that. Crown J is just not a type of US, se7en looks like he’s more into partying and Wonder Girls would be too corny for US [But I still wish them success and I still love them].

 
no avatar

im thinking boa or seven…

 
Soojung's avatar

the only reason i think boa is cos her songs are upbeat, but to me i don’t think it’s her style. ><

 
xVANY's avatar

BoA fo’ sho :]

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:00 PM

29. Lisa (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Utada all the way. Ive heard her songs on the radio already.
Her album is in stores right now.

 
Toomoko's avatar

I should say Utada (since she is a pioneer in this field ! ) BUT I voted BoA.
Seriously, I like Crown J but he’s more like a big joke aha~
And people heard more about Utada because she tried to be on us market for so long, that I can’t remember XD I still remember her “easy breezy” from 2004… And that was 5 years ago.
I wonder if Se7en could wait until 2013 to break through the us music industry aha ~~
Utada is such a brave girl XD

 
sushi's avatar

Utada or BoA, though Utada has more of an edge considering the airplay she’s getting. I wish them all success nevertheless, as I do like all of them (except for Crown J). Se7en though, seems to be going nowhere…

 
Icefiya's avatar

Hands down…BoA! ^^

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:04 PM

33. b to i to the g b to the a n g (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

most def. wonder girls - no questions asked
just wait ‘till they actually come out with their english album/song.
wow they’re really good, against singers who debuted like what 10 years before them? hahahahaha
all of them have released an english song and what happened? oh nothing
im pretty sure when wonder girls release one, you’ll see the wonder effect they had in korea come to america

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:06 PM

34. lovefiasco (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

wonder girls
they’re the most known in vancouver
all people with different ethnic background dances to tell me, so hot, nobody

 
numeroix's avatar

Most likely none of them.

Sorry :(

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:07 PM

36. frizzle (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Who the hell voted for Wonder Girls?  Are u f-ing kidding me? 
Boa’s ahead of everyone else in the poll right now. Her album isn’t that great and almost all of the songs are upbeat and techno-ish.  She’s had an okay amount of publicity too~. 

Utada’s album was pretty decent too and had a better variety of songs.  Utada can easily surpass Boa in this race with the right amount of publicity. 

Se7en needs better songs, and he needs to collaborate with the most popular artists right now (ie: Akon, NeYo, etc.)

Crown J is just…hmm.  He can rap and has some flow, but he needs to stop with his “A” gimmicks and crap.  He’s just going to be mocked and made fun of in the US. 

WonderGirls are blah.  Even though Boa still does have an accent and all, WonderGirls are a bit worse off with their Engrish (although Boa and Se7en both have some Engrish too).  And the idea of a girl group that’s poppy and crap just doesn’t appeal to the general American audience.  Sorry, but Cheetah Girls tried and failed, why would anyone think that WonderGirls would be able to make it to the US charts?

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:07 PM

37. raye (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

umm…. BOA already failed babies lol its over for her

i voted WG but i agree most likely it’ll be Utada. i’m hearing big things about her.

 
no avatar

I’d say either BoA or Utada. BoA because she’s more into this poppy style that America’s eating up right now but Utada is Japanese…and well, they have more ground here with anime and manga.

 
SkipBeat's avatar

utada, she’s already famous beecause of kingdom hearts and her song is getting crazy radio play. Next to her has to be se7en cause he’s hot, can sing, can dance, and he’s getting attention from the R&B and Hip-Hop community. Everyone else will sadly fail, mostly Crown J and wonder girls.

reason: Crown gay…i mean J is sucha wannabe that its not even funny. If americans can’t handle a white boy acting hood what makes you think they can handle an asian guy acting hood.

With wondergirls mhm kinda obvious they barely speak english and they lack in the dancing and singing department. The only way they could make it famous here with just a cute face would be if they sold their soul to disney, but i doubt they would go that road so um fail.

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:11 PM

40. ~ (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

UTADA

Shes amazing ^^

plus her singles were better then everybody elses.

Come back to me a brilliant song

 
ehsna_wonder_fan's avatar

Utada have to sing like Mariah Carey to be famous.
BoA have to be as sexy and beautiful as Rihanna to be famous.
Se7en is not even on the same level as Justin Timberlake
and Crown J is nothing.
Wonder Girls are unique BUT they are too young for US.

Personally, I love WG but I’d say that NO ONE can break US charts yet.

Only RAIN can do that. Cause he already have.
Rain is different. I think no one can be next to him.

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:12 PM

42. Angela (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

i see a lot of people think Boa will make it but from the interviews and performances that I see of her it seems like she’s very bored and tire….not enthusiastic or excited for her US debut…seems more like she’s being force to do it…plus boa looks older than 23 years old..lol..i thought she was older than Se7en…

well i voted for Se7en…he’s doing a fine job

 
sLaVe's avatar

HELL yeah, BoA winnin that shit.

Se7en and Utada, you know I love you. But Se7en, I haven’t seen much going on with you so I can’t say much. And Utada, sigh, I honestly feel like you’re just dicking around with the way your second album was done. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE the songs but the arrangement… just the way everything was done ABOUT the album was disappointing.
And Wonder Girls, I love you. But I love you in Korea.

-sLaVe

 
stuff~'s avatar

Wonder Girls will succeed first of coarse :x

 
MOARStrawberry's avatar

Logically, Utada has the best chance out of all of them already.  MySpace promotion, real radio play, iTunes free video of the week - she just needs to get a little bit more of a push behind her, and repackage the album to catch more eyes.  Also, perform on Ellen.  She’d be MORE than welcome there.

After that, I think the Wonder Girls have the most potential.  Music history repeats itself, and we are due for another Spice Girls-style invasion; these are the girls who can make it happen.  They have a type of sound many in America don’t realize they’ve been dying to hear.  Any of my friends who don’t know kpop, who I’ve shown them, love them.  They’ve got appeal in all areas, and with the right PROMOTION, outside of just sites frequented by Asians, it WILL work.  They need to be shoved down this country’s collective throat like NSYNC was back in their day, and everything will go swimmingly.

BoA, as much as I love her, didn’t do something right.  The album wasn’t all-her…more Autotune than belting; more sex anthems than originality.  Don’t get me wrong, the girl has insane talent and potential, but the people pulling her strings didn’t take the right approach.  I can guarantee you that if she debuted over here with an English version of Eien, no crazy Autotune stunts, she’d be majorly famous here.  Maybe second time will be a charm.  BoA fighting, still.

Se7en needs a stronger thing than “Girls” to get him by.  And less JT comparisons.

Crown J is just a douchebag.  We already have 3 6 Mafia, we don’t need another one.

 
no avatar

I’m rooting for Utada, shes my favorite artist becuase she really has talent (not that the others dont), but boA hasnt really done much. At most people have been saing look out for her, but about 5 months later there hasnt been much progress. Se7en is just floating around out there. I don’t think the US is ready for the Wonder Girls, their image wont really fit in here. I dont know what to say about Crown J. Utada has the biggest chance. In the US she affliated with a big record label, she has the talent, she’s fluent in the language, and she is getting some recognition

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:15 PM

47. goofy (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Anyone who votes for BoA or remotely thinks of her transitioning into the US to be a big hit, is probably missing some screws in her their heads. Out of all of these candidates, it’s quite obvious regardless of how you guys are voting in the polls, that Utada has the best chance. Before any of these Asians make it here, you’ll sure as hell see an Asian American making it big first. Out of all of them she has the most talent. And it’s not even about air play, the general audience recognizes her more than they would BoA, especially since BoA on concentrates on Cali…big deal all you’re gaining is more “asian” fans and not appealing to the masses.

 
down up

16 May 2009 - 07:15 PM

48. animrac (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

UTADA HIKARU…....vow!!!

 
Shattered_Regrets's avatar

I think Utada might have a a good chance this time, but I think BoA might make it first. She seems to have the good promotions and everything so…idk. Only time will tell.

As for Utada getting radio play, does anyone know if she’s been getting radio play in Chicago? Cuz I’ve given up on American radio XDD

 
MOARStrawberry's avatar

I also have to say…WG better get the “Nobody” single out in good, full English by this summer, because if there’s no Rihanna/Lady GaGa/Pink/Britney/Xtina fuckery going around (which, if you look closely, there actually won’t be by post-June…sans GaGa) they’ll be in the perfect climate.  I hope “Nobody” does great, and comes out really soon.

 


Leave a Comment

To post a comment Sign In! New Here? Then Sign Up!

 

a 6Theory Media, LLC. Production

© 2007-2009 allkpop.com | Terms of Services | Privacy | Disclaimer