allkpop

first!!

she dances pretty good but i can barely hear her.

ehh lackk

When Sori sings it, it sounds a bit forced.

third!!!
Sori is OK,,,
I like the original better

she’s a good dancer…but the audio is so soft, i could barely hear her voice =\

gehhh i like the original better

I prefeeeeer hers better

I hate ivy

sori is a good dancer♥

she should sing more of her songs,
there pretty cool

no one can beat the original. i wish ivy would come back already.

dancing: good

props to her, this song is hard to sing live;
i think if she was to sing these type of songs, and not with what she debuted with,
i think she would get further in her carrer.

the song is annoying == but since the chreography seems tough to sing to at the same time, i think she performed good : )

i like the song. i liked it quite a lot when Ivy came out with it. i wonder if Ivy’s EVER going to make a comeback…

Hmm I actually think she did pretty good, I wasn’t expecting it. Though I wish the cameras and editing would just slow the hell down, I know they’re trying to make it more interesting but it’s just TOO MUCH *cut, shake, zoom in, zoom out, fade in, pan across, shake some more* all in a matter of seconds. My eyes hurt!

FAIL

so far good xD

It’s great that she doesn’t lip sync and all, but I was cringing through the second half of this. IVY has a pretty strong voice and SORI.. doesn’t. She shouldn’t have forced the vocals that she isn’t capable of.

She was a bit pitchy in a lot of parts o_o and it sounded strange.
I like the sweet image of her better
But if she improves her vocals that’d be great…

I lov this lady wish her the best!

I thought she ruined the song. She really needs to work on her Vocal skills. It’s too musical…if you get what I mean.

she was pretty good actually. which im surprised about. =)
but i really think Ivy is one of the best singers live while dancing without holding back.
so she is really hard to beat loll
but since Sori’s new, i will give her lots of propz ^^

thank goodness for ivy singing of this song to being played in the background and soris dancing because if she didnt have those 2 it would be fail it really seems like ivys singing was louder then soris though….but i like sori its just idk she is always missing something i dont know wat it is…....i wish ivy would make a come back like please show these lil girl groups(fan of these girl groups) wat sexy is…..it would be hot if hyori and ivy did a special stage together

The only person who I’ve heard do this song justice is Dana from CSJH The Grace

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=clOGtEHzq9U

Ivy is such a good singer

that was a really good performance, vocals are ok. she is missing charisma, something to draw you in.

i can barely haer her voice…but shes a really good dancer though
i still perfer ivy…she’s such a great singer

nice effort, especially for a newbie. gotta give her props, and it’s a hard song to sing live with all that dancing. though i still like ivy more :p

hmm i hope ivy comes back, even try to pass her scandal…

I don’t think her dancing is good.
It’s mediocre, just like her vocals
^ IMO.

i give her props for trying live, but that song sound hard to sing.
if she wants that extra 1%. show more skin damnit

did she even sing?? i barely hear her voice except at the reff part.. and it looked like she was just screaming not singing >.<
i prefer the original..

not feeling it…sry sori…sorry sorry…XD

it’s good, but heechul’s version is still good.. XD

Turn your volume up.  It’s the video’s quality itself that is shitty.  I can clearly hear her once I turned up the volume.

She’s definitely not Ivy.. something’s just lacking..
Maybe she should stick to her own style.. if she’s got one

I like her performance! At least she tried.
The song itself is hard to sing already.

It was a good effort. The dancing was good, but the vocals are lacking. I can barely hear her too. But its still a good try, Sonata of Temptation is a really hard song to sing, and she’s definitely no Ivy.

She’s no Ivy. She doesn’t have the backing to be one.

In truth, Ivy’s vocals are mediocre at best; a lot of good marketing has convinced a lot of morons to think her whiny, thin voice is has any worth (“strong vocals’) because it has some range, despite having no quality. If she wants to have that kind of star power machine behind her then, instead of doing Ivy’s song, she should be doing the Ivy’s team.

I prefer Ivy doing it!!

in my opinion she sings bad..but when you dance so much it is really hard to sing good

Dancing ok, but as others have said before, she’s not Ivy. I think this is one of those songs where only the original singer can truly sing it right. Temptation of Sonata is a unique song to sing, especially live.

Haha, she can’t sing.
And she definitely does not possess the fierceness that Ivy has

Her nose is AWESOME.
That’s one plastic surgeon I have to meet >,<

I like Sori but her tryin 2 sing Ivy’s song is really… I dont know how to say this but… it sucks! No offense but her vocals just sucks n doesnt match that song too well..

she’s really pretty. i hope she gets a better song to sing in the future.

she’s PRETTY. besides hyori can’t sing either
who says singers in asia have to be able to sing -____-
asia =/= america

ok i slightly object to my previous comment.
because the jonas brothers suck ass.

omg, this makes me miss ivy SOOOO MUCH!
nobody can be like her… just cause of that damn scandal

I DO think her performance is quite good… But she lacks sth as many others said…
And I think it might break down her career if she doesn’t correct it… I mean she won’t be able to face bands like Wonder Girls or SNSD or Kara, even After School and so on… I’m sure she would be as good as all those famous bands if she changed that little thing. Maybe she only has to ad some gestures but her choregraphy really LACKS SOMETHING… I don’t konw what but sth there is in other choregraphies and voices….