allkpop

wtf i dont understand either language but both songs sound 95% alike. yes that is how close to it.

wow, the songs are the same…O_o..

I thought the Jessica being mean and calling Seohyun names was hilarious. That is a weird tradition I’ve never heard of.

OMG!! I heard it and it is almost the same… O_O…. I was shocked..

woah…. this song is SUPER similar. :|

Pranks are funny and all but did Jessica really need to take it that far during a performance?

This group is sure popular. Every day new controversy. Controversy chases glamour people, if you don’t know. hahaha.. and how the heck they can dig a song from Uzbekistan? but it also proves the girls are the best. They pull of the song better.. (oh, sorry) perfectly.

Fighting girls~

oh oh this is only one song. Goshhhhhhhhhh poor Girl Generation, why? I love this song

“Sounds very similar”?! Is it understatement day at allkpop?

HAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAH… I want to see the faces of Sones on this one hahahahah

omg, poor snsd.. they dont deserved this… that uzbekistani singer is a stealer >.<
n that seo-sica incident… lol… i didnt noticed… netizens must be bored of their life… even that small incident become so big..duh, netizens - get a life…

Wow only the lyrics are different.. But whatever… SNSD rocks!

lol poor seohyun XD duh! many controversies about SNSD!!! urrrgh! these haters should get a life D:

Lol, oh please. Anybody who KNOWS SNSD knows that they are close as hell, and they would never do that to eachother, especially something like pushing the maknae. It’s pretty ridiculous to even think about, of course it’s just a joke.

And about the song, good to know that it’s the fault of the Uzbekistan company and not SM/SNSD.

Now people need to stop being so hateful toward these girls.

HAHA, pwn yu shitdaes.

omg that song is totally the same :OOO

This seriously cracked me up…

Lol, whether or not people are antis or fans, Netizens are just plain crazy.
:x

These girls never get a break ROFL…And to the SM Haters, SM owns the song so this Uzibekistani person and their company should be expecting a call soon, I betta they thought no one would notice since they are in some unknown country >.< but K-Netizens can find more things than the FBI.

The Dineyra version is an unapproved, unauthorized version.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1B_0vEfIu34&feature=channel_page

and btw the beginning sounds likke mirotic

Sica didnt do it during a live broadcast, it was during Mucor and we can clearly see that they are not holding their mics. It was either the rehearsal or that thing they do to get the audience cheers while the performance is broadcast on TV.

either way, these days netizens/antis are fire. A new attack everyday. lol

SNSD have ALWAYES been freakishly RUDE and UNFRIENDLY
so 2days post doesntreally surprise me coz SNSD r bitches

Either way, it’ll be clarified when SNSD go on radios to promote TMYW. Like how Tiffany and Yoona did it with their “scandal”. Rofl, you should post the email that was sent by a fan regarding this statement and the statement in reply from Dmusic themselves.

isnt this thing clear already eh?

oh my effin’ gawd.
it’s exactly the same! did they even get permit for this??
IT’S EXACTLY THE SAME for god’s sake!!

soooo disappointed.

“Considering how much netizens overreact to these kinds of things, however, it probably wasn’t the best idea to publicly carry out that prank during a live performance.” MORE like netizens need to spend their lives doing better things than looking at specifics of EVERY SIGNLE FRIGGEN DETAIL of the SNSD girls like wtf??? this whole thing is pissing me off. @47. WOW! how did u get that information? good riddens! problem solved people! Now let us all rejoice with cake! I’m glad that SM is guilt-freeee! (:

Universal Music says;

No, we own this song. Dsign are Universal writers. GG / SM were given this song exclusively to record and release.

The Uzbekistan release is an unauthorized,and unlawful version and not approved by us. GG/SM are at no fault at all. A press message will be sent out shortly.

Pelle Lidell
European A&R Executive
Universal Music Publishing Group
(sent via Blackberry wireless)

OMG NO WAY! SNSD’s is still better, without a doubt.

tch. whatever. haters should just keep to themselves. they need to stop digging crap about the girls and verify their materials as facts before they say sh*t. as for the song…well gl with that, i highly doubt that the girls will get in trouble. snsd fighting.

ok -_- i loss my interest to SM entertainment

WTF i knew that the song was femiliar to me but i could not figure it out but now i know egt dom jonge snsd moet egt en leven zoeken ga beter muziek leren maken ofso

I don’t know why,... but I think I love Dinerya’s version more than SNSD. Cause it has a latin & Indian feel in the song & I think the vocal are better than SNSD

Just an opinion>_<

Everytime like this.

wow its really the same…

SM’s song always has so many version in different language.
Last year, we saw another version of DBSK’s mirotic, and then SHINee’s song…. and than this??????

I think it’s because SM can’t produce their own song (Like YG or JYP…. no offense^_^),
In fact I don’t think they have their own great composer & music producer (Like Teddy, G-D & Kush from YG or JYP himself in JYP)

They always buy their song from foreign composer.
It’s just soooo wrong, because the composer still can sell their song to another singer in different country. That’s why they always had issue with plagiarism.

If they don’t want any plagiarism issue, please….... produce & compose their own song.
But they must find a great producer first >_<

Lol. I was born in Uzbekistan, Uz FTW! Haha :D Anyway, I don’t like either of the versions, thank you SNSD for bringing up Uzbekistan, haha. I bet more people know that it ‘exists’ now

thanks for clearing things up ^^

ah SAFE! tats all i care about *phew* i dont want another CLEAN Mirotic going on @___@

SIMILAR? THE SONG WAS EXACTLY THE SAME. omg. can snsd seriously not do anything original ._.

well, now i know im not a crazy netizen
Uzbekistan? wow….korean netizen are crazy
i cant even think that far
all i know the starting sounds a bit like JT and the chorus just like Why I like You
and thats what i assume
and keep to myself but still thinking of SM and his remake

sucks that song was leaked. SM ftw~
snsd fighting~!

crazy netizens. chill out. controversy is just another way of putting a certain group or person in the spotlight. in SNSD’s case, the more controversy there is the more exposure they get. they win as long as it’s pure speculation and nothing completely negative. I’d love to see the girls get more involved with the song writing team, though.

SM, im disappointed again they did the some thing with shinee song they copy form others what i have heard the song was exactly the same@ 27 dont blame the article man get a life if u dont know this isn’t the 1st time that SM did it copy form others i know that u r a fan but come on the article also said that the song was released a few months ago
the way i see it the SM is not putting much Effort to Make new music

juz wondering, i know korean guys swear using that word but do girls normally use it too?or do they have a “milder” word? am not korean so dunno how “bad” the word is..aww, maknae looks taken aback…careful tho, sica, 2pm members pulled this on junsu on his bday too, but they overdid it n he stormed off…hope it’s just a prank coz maknae + ice princess r my favs

IT IS EXACTLY THE SAME! oh no…

wow….
overreaction much?

To the ppl that keep thinking SM got the song after the Dineyra…hello read it again and again and again…SM got this song approve way before the Dineyra came out with the video…

Was this song really released prior SNSD’s ‘Tell Me Your Wish’? If so, were there no copyright deals?

OMG! both songs was alike! @@