NEW USER? | FORGOT PASSWORD?
rss
 

Controversy over SNSD’s Album Cover

433 Comments

coolsmurf in Music | 22 Jun 2009 - 07:40 AM

 
Constroversy over SNSD's 2nd mini-album cover

Days before SNSD makes their comeback, their mini-album cover has come under fire from irate bloggers. Bloggers have claimed that in the album cover that was released today, the fighter plane was a direct replica of Japan's Zero-sen fighter planes which was operated by the Imperial Japanese Navy Air Service in World War 2.

Looking at the album cover, an image of a fighter plane does appear at SNSD's member, YoonA's waist, and just below the Korean flag on her military uniform. The bloggers have suggested that the image was Japan's Zero-sen fighter planes which had been used for kamaikaze attacks in the latter part of the war. They also said that the only difference was the lack of a Japanese national flag, everything else was the same.

Zero-sen fighter planes

Netizens commented, "As the nation's representative idol group, they have hurt the feelings of Koreans", "Not just the fighter plane, the marine uniforms that they are wearing reminds one of the Japanese imperialism period." Soshi fans defended their idols, "This is the fault of the album cover designer, SNSD has done no wrong."

A check with the public relations office of the Republic of Korean Air Force indicated that the fighter plane does look pretty similar with that of Japan's Zero-sen fighter plane although they fell short of confirming it. But they also expressed that the fighter plane definitely wasn't the ones used by United States or the United Nations Air Forces.

SM Entertainment expressed, "The album cover for SNSD had been designed based on the marine girl concept, there's no hidden meaning to it at all."

Constroversy over SNSD's 2nd mini-album cover

With South Korea still pretty much at loggerheads with Japan over World War 2, a different fighter plane could have been used instead.



  
 

advertisement

Comments

blaize_alight's avatar

o.o wow.. harsh much?

 
loosma's avatar

such constructive comments already haha

 
blaize_alight's avatar

@.3 loosma: lol.. i knowrite.. but news like this… wat can you say really smile

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:50 AM

7. chloe (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

I see where they’re coming from,but I think it’s just
reaching into it so much,like let’s stop disecting
everything and just enjoy the music~
but it’s not snsd’s fault unless they’re like wizzes at
photoshop now

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:51 AM

8. wowz (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

umm….....who ever designed it must be fired by now!^^

 
PeaChic's avatar

yeah it´s not snsd´s fault…
i dun really like the cover

 
xxskyzlimitxx's avatar

Omg..
Do people have no life these days..
I believe it was only a prop and not meant to have any other meaning….-__-

 
Rei_Asuka's avatar

lol.. wth… i’m sorry but they hurt the Koreans?? Dude the girls were just doing what the designers wanted and shizz. I agree with their fans when they say they rele didn’t do anything wrong. Gahh seriously… ppl these days.

 
no avatar

Seriously? Come on…......

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:52 AM

13. marie (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

it’s just a cover!!!

 
ukashka's avatar

agree with 7
putting too much thought into it just enjoy the music

 
xiiifiendfyreiiix's avatar

It looks more like a spaceship…. Marines and airplanes :S

 
Carmen's avatar

Oehh
it’s not snsd fault :S
hmm will they change the cover?

 
takaraS2taemin's avatar

lol ! so what . its not their fault. blam whoever made the cover or dont blame anyone at all. its just a plane ^^

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:53 AM

18. mandy (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

ROFLCAKESSS! all this for a japanese plane?!!! soon even them speaking in japanese could be the talk of the town for disrespecting koreans wtffff

 
xyiseul's avatar

dead ass? -_-

 
no avatar

wtf most planes look like that; those bloggers need to take a chill pill

 
lightofscorpio's avatar

LMFAO!!!!!!!! PHOTOSHOP FAIL!!!! YOU CAN STILL SEE THE RED SUN ON THE WING!!!! FUCKING OWNED!!!!!!

 
Tuly's avatar

What the hell o.o

 
ehsna_wonder_fan's avatar

I’ve heard the full song.. it’s nice. except that it’s not as catchy as “gee gee gee gee baby baby baby baby” and sounds like other songs.. but over all, I like that song. LOL. so random. SORRY!!

 
no avatar

no but nowadays, there are news on how posters and advertisments are becoming important representation of something
and even til today, korea is very sensitive about their relationship wit the harsh and difficult times of the past

 
Ms. A S ii A's avatar

WOW! Thars crazy…
I dont like the cover thaT MUCH
bUT DAMN
THAT sux right before their comebacke

 
no avatar

netizens attack again -_-


this is really quite ridiculous - i mean yea it looks like the plane, but i mean, don’t all planes look alike? i’m no plane expert, but it looks like any old plane to me o_o

 
Jstar's avatar

if they are wearing marine uniforms, why is there a plane?

idont get it anymore…. >_<

tiffany…

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:57 AM

28. 000 (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

The Japanese war in Asia is still a pretty sensitive topic today.
In China, you can actually get arrested for talking good about the Japanese soldiers.
I guess it’s not too harsh for netizens to say that it is wrong for them to include Japanese air fighters on the album cover.
It is after all the object from which bombs were dropped onto tens of thousands of Chinese and Koreans.

 
no avatar

Whoah. Bloggers find meanings to everything they see eh. But I think the girls has nothing to do with it. I believe the designers made that cover without probably giving meaning to it.

 
noura's avatar

um,,  what?

 
no avatar

wtf how spaztic ova a album cover. it looks hot so who cares. it looks completely different. ii didnt even realise there was a plane there lol ><.  its not about the pic its about the music   :  )  why so serious?

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 07:59 AM

32. Chi (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Wow that’s lame xD Those people really need to get a life lol. As SM said, it’s not their intention to ‘offend Korea’ by putting a Japanese plane on an album cover, they probably just thought it looked cool, haha.. And yeah, SNSD aren’t responsible for the album art so to hate on them for it is really ridiculous. The netizens never fail to astound me with how petty and idiotic they can be. :x

 
Hiragiizawa's avatar

The netizens(blogger) really have nothing to do.. xD

 
soshifan's avatar

wahhh this is too much..
that is nothing to do with snsd…
they probably don’t even know wth with that plane…
just enjoy the music people…
do not need to go that far…

 
no avatar

no comment about japan etc. etc.
i better get my mouth shut, or i’ll start talking nonsense..

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:00 AM

36. sososorri (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

you guys are really insensitive. there are a lot of people in korea who are affected by the japanese. a lot of people’s grandparents and even parents had to go under harsh rule from the japanese and obviously there are still remnants of anger and revenge.  and dont give that “they should move on” crapp. unless you’ve experienced it yourselves, you know nothing. its the same as if some american celebrities were promoting Al-Qaeda.

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:00 AM

37. KSH (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

ridiculous. but hey, free press. they should be happy.

 
no avatar

lol if you were a korean (maybe some of you are) you’d understand it when it comes to Japan. EVERYTHINGs sensitive when it comes to japan. I know where these netizens are coming from but at the same time i do agree that it is the album designers fault.

Japan claims that Dokdo is theirs
Japan took over Korea and raped their women while shipping off some korean men into the Siberian Desert while stripping them down naked and using them as medical test subjects
Japan printed a modern history book stating the Phillipenes and Korea WANTED to be dictated by Japan
etc etc etc
koreans just hate anything japanese government related.

 
summersnow501's avatar

LOL..uhh..okaaaay?
not SNSD’s fault though.smile

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:00 AM

40. wtf? (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

what ever, like the SNSD members actually know about WWII fighter planes, in fact, most people probably didn’t even know about this until some jack ass had to point it out, and it looks like an honest mistake that they tried to make out of a toy airplane, and what the heck? the marine outfits look like Japanese imperialism days? they never said anything bad about the outfits before the airplane thing, plus the outfits freaking has the korean flag on it, they are representing

 
cocopop's avatar

it wasn’t their fault. its just a plane

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:02 AM

42. ilovejelly (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

wtf ..  but still snsd’s still jjang ..

 
KOREAN♥DUDESS's avatar

WELL there is a history of Japanese and Korean conflict and not only with Koreans but with A LOT of Asia.
i agree with comment 28
the Japanese did some cruel things and people in asia still remember that.
remember people are saying this for a reason. try and understand instead of saying wth and stuff….

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:03 AM

44. wasabi21 (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

wtf!! it is just a fucking plane!! no big deal…

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:03 AM

45. so shame (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Honestly, I always thought the covers were bad. Why put Yuri and Yoona only? Everyone deserves a spot, I don’t dislike anyone, but it’s unfair that only them get the spotlight. And the airplane is another thing. *sigh*, I like them, but they don’t stop disappointing people… even if it’s not their fault directly, the fault goes to them for being the main image. That’s why artists should try to have a better education, so that they can be part of the background in their stuff.

 
yumiyu's avatar

That’s right what SM Entertainment said! no hidden meaning!

 
no avatar

who gives a fuck

 
down up

22 Jun 2009 - 08:03 AM

48. snsdjjang (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

lol whatever.
I love SNSD so so much that I dont care about any trash talk about them.

snsd fighting!

 
love 'em's avatar

well,it has nothing to do with SNSD and their song is stll great…. i love the song!

 
sho0rty's avatar

it’s just a plane though? O_O why do they have to be so detailed about it’s design, and besides, it should be the design team’s fault raspberry

 


Leave a Comment

To post a comment Sign In! New Here? Then Sign Up!

 

a 6Theory Media, LLC. Production

© 2007-2009 allkpop.com | Terms of Services | Privacy | Disclaimer