3253 Views

Do you think “East of Eden” will succeed?

27 CommentsSae in News | 25 Aug 2008 - 02:13 PM

Tags: poll, song seung hun, drama, east of eden

Image

Opinions are divided on whether the big-budget drama "East of Eden", starring the hot hot Song Seung-Hun, eye-candy worthy Dennis Oh and others (hahahaha), has what it takes to be the next Winter Sonata? (in terms of Hallyu power, anyway)

The extremely anticipated and hyped drama finally aired on the 25th, in celebration of MBC's 47th anniversary. Viewers are not shy about listing their complaints. After the broadcast, a special aired which contained an introduction of characters, footage of filming the cast in Hong Kong, making of the film, NG (bloopers) reels, views of the open set, etc., viewers spammed the message boards on the homepage. They complained that the special was more like a DVD special feature, and then they complained that there was no reason to air a special - netizens left comments like "I don't see why they needed to broadcast a special", "I wanted to see the actual drama, not a special", "The special was a waste of time", blah blah blah.

On the other end of the spectrum, they also left remarks like "It's like a big-budget movie, not a drama", "It looks like a fun drama will come out after a long time", "I feel like I've waited so long for this," etc. Jeez.

For those of you unfamiliar with the plot, basically, it's about a man (played by Song Seung Hun) who, as a teenager, witnesses his father being murdered. He swears to seek revenge on his father's killer... But in truth, his own younger brother, who grew up to become a prosecutor and promised to help his 'brother' seek revenge, was switched with his father's killer's son at birth. (Man, can Korean dramas stop this whole switched-at-birth thing?? It rarely even happens in real life!) OMG, they're not brothers!!! What will Song Seung-Hun the main character do when he finds out the brother that was beside him all these years was actually the son of his mortal enemy?

Honestly, I think this sounds way too typical, with a few 'twists'. 50 episodes are already 30 episodes too long. I can already imagine the dragged-out crying scenes, emotional outbursts and OF COURSE, the flashbacks. In a nutshell, there are skyrocketing expectations for this drama due to Song Seung-Hun its 'stellar' cast and the wasted $25 million that could've helped feed hungry children in North Korea big budget. Do you guys think East of Eden has what it takes to succeed and break Korea's succession of relatively boring and unsuccessful dramas?

Will East of Eden succeed?
 

Comments

25 Aug 2008 - 02:32 PM1. goldenGAZE

Website: None

 
goldenGAZE's avatar

WOOOW, i had to read that plot line about 10 times before i got it lol. I can see it doing well coz of Dennis Oh, but seriously the media needs to stop creating a hype because it will only make peoples expect more.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 02:41 PM2. hanah (Unregistered User? Sign Up!)

Website: None

 

with that much money going into it…better be worth it!

 

25 Aug 2008 - 03:18 PM3. loraborax3

Website: None

 
loraborax3's avatar

lol i’ve been waiting for a long time. any drama song seung hoon is in it will automatically be a hit. yea the storyline is so overrated and repeated but hey thats what makes it addicting.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 03:20 PM4. seobak (Unregistered User? Sign Up!)

Website: None

 

Your articles have great content, but I do wish you’d read over them and edit. They always seem to be full of grammatical and spelling errors. Sorry if this sounds criticizing, but without those little mistakes, your articles would be an awesome read. :]

And in response to the poll, if they present this cliche theme well, who knows what will happen?

 

25 Aug 2008 - 03:42 PM5. nikeg (Unregistered User? Sign Up!)

Website: None

 

I still dont know why Winter Sonata was so popular… its the SLOWEST damn love story ever even on kdrama standards. Im still gonna watch it regardless.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 03:46 PM6. Lana

Website: None

 

Nope.  All hype.  The storyline is too, ‘been there done that 100 times’.  The only thing that’s gonna prop this puppy up is the eye candy.  People swooning over how good looking they are, not the plot or the acting for that matter.

But then again, I’ve consistently noticed that Korea has low standards, because the ones they call ‘good actors’, with the exception of Song Kang-Ho, a lot of times I’m left scratching my head and saying,‘oh really?‘

 

25 Aug 2008 - 04:08 PM7. ohgeeze.

Website: None

 
ohgeeze.'s avatar

I don’t know. I hope it is. They used so much money and had such a good cast that if it sucked, it’d be suchhhh a waste.

Agreed with “nikeg”.
I watched one episode of Winter Sonata,
and maybe it was Bae Yongjoon or Choi Jiwoo’s hair cut,
but I’ve vowed to never watch the whole thing.

And yeah, I’d still watch this drama anyways.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 04:10 PM8. Lily

Website: None

 

lol.  Maybe it’ll do well in Japan and be popular, like Winter Sonata.  WS was never popular until it got popular in Japan.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 04:24 PM9. HPDANM

HPDANM's avatar

^that’s true…
I never really like Winter Sonata, I never see the hype in that drama but I could understand why Japanese ahjummas like it…I think Summer Scent was better not because of SSH, I didn’t even like SSH at first…and it’s SSH, it might become a bit draggy but I think it will be good…Just SSH being there, it’s more than enough…It felt like I haven’t seen him for years…I hope for it success! It has good and great actors in it…

 

25 Aug 2008 - 04:34 PM10. CK257

Website: None

 
CK257's avatar

Well I’m sorry but I don’t think it will succeed just because people are anticipating and expecting so much of it, hate it when they make you do it.

I’d prefer a drama that surprises me and turns out to be great than a high promoted one that’s not even half of what I expected.

So basically it could be good but not as good as people are expecting it to be.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 04:49 PM11. TheProdigy

Website: None

 
TheProdigy's avatar

lol….its funny having a girl writer…I’m so used to Johnny ripping on every guy celebrity.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 05:02 PM12. friedkimchi

Website: None

 

obviously…there will be no relation to John Steinbeck’s novel, “East of Eden”...

 

25 Aug 2008 - 07:35 PM13. steviewonder06

Website: None

 
steviewonder06's avatar

I like this writer, she’s cool and writes the long ones. =D

I personally chose maybe since you can never know. It could become underrated(pshhhh), overrated(seems like it), or just right(like Winter Sonata, IMO). The story is so so since so many dramas have done it before.

and yea, Winter Sonata was pretty slow but i still liked it i guess but that’s the last really slow drama i watch XD I remember being addicted to it on AZN Television hahaha oh those days…lol.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 07:43 PM14. xoxLIZZIExox

Website: None

 
xoxLIZZIExox's avatar

the plot confusing..god dis is going to sooo long..i just it doesn’t get too like draggy and boring or whatever but ill still watch it

 

25 Aug 2008 - 09:37 PM15. Lana

Website: None

 

#12, when I first read the title a while back, I thought of John Steinbeck, as well.  Thank God they’re not doing it, because I’m certain that it’d be butchered beyond belief!

 

25 Aug 2008 - 09:54 PM16. tokyo_bunny_prodigy

Website: None

 

I think for it to really succeed I think the audience is going to have to look more towards the actors and not so much the storyline…

 

25 Aug 2008 - 10:11 PM17. Sae

Website: None

 
Sae's avatar

Haha, I really do appreciate the constructive criticism (and even the senseless criticism, cuz it’s funny).

SSH <3 Dennis Oh <3 But I dunno if I’d watch 50 episodes just for them. -_- I put Fail. Hehe.

 

25 Aug 2008 - 10:34 PM18. lovehate358

Website: None

 

i’ll watch the first epi. just for the sake of the eye candy..
the plot has FLOOOPPP written all over..
but the drama could become a hit.. maybe not in korea..

 

25 Aug 2008 - 10:39 PM19. okeydoke (Unregistered User? Sign Up!)

Website: None

 

WHAT?!
50 EPISODES?!

 

25 Aug 2008 - 10:40 PM20. kerochan

Website: None

 
kerochan's avatar

haven’t heard of it until now.
also, i don’t like the plot.
FAIL. good luck tho. ><

 

25 Aug 2008 - 11:12 PM21. kisstherain

Website: None

 

the plot doesn’t fail the drama… it’s the bad acting that fails a drama. i think this drama can bring up its own color and do well. [= i just can’t imagine lee yeon hee playing a character like that… O_o

 

26 Aug 2008 - 01:30 AM22. iluvmoi

Website: None

 

oh dear! no flashbacks PLEASE!

 

26 Aug 2008 - 02:13 AM23. crazyfrog

Website: None

 

man the plot sort of reminds me of… half the kdramas out there. lost me already!
anyway, this new writer is ok, maybe cut out some of the colloquial stuff. like “Jeez”. but otherwise good read. =)

 

26 Aug 2008 - 05:29 AM24. britmeech4eva

Website: None

 

why is it called east of eden anyways?
i MIGHt give it a try..
but if it becomes too draggy..
>_<

 

26 Aug 2008 - 06:24 AM25. Bluecat

Bluecat's avatar

Im definitely not gonna watch this since im not that much of a korean drama-addict anyway but I think it’ll do well. And your right about flash backs -___- it happens a lot in korean soaps, gets sooooo tiring and annoying :/
and i like your articles! keep ‘em coming 8D

 

26 Aug 2008 - 07:01 PM26. HPDANM

HPDANM's avatar

agree @kisstherain…though plot does a lot to keep the interest of the viewers, it doesn’t really weight as much. Sometimes, even though how great the plot is if the actors are bad, then it won’t get anywhere. It’s like a great composer + the worst singer…as long as there are good acting and such…For example Summer Scent, I don’t think the plot is that good, it’s predictable and kind of draggy in the middle. However, what I like about it is the sceneries, music, especially music, it has my favorite serenade in it. The flowers, plus it didn’t start in their childhood memories, it’s not too dramatic either. It’s cute from the start and then get melodramatic.
But for East Of Eden, I can tell it will be very dramatic, it starts from their childhood memories and such. But like what I said earlier SSH is enough for me to watch out for maybe 1-20 episodes, I just don’t know how it will go…

 

24 Sep 2008 - 12:01 AM27. East of Eden English Subtitle Episode 9 (Unregistered User? Sign Up!)

Website: None

 

Hey guys,

East of Eden English Subtitle Episode 9 has been completed
and Episode 10(row) has been uploaded. Check it out! smile

http://www.viikii.net/channels/goto/eastofeden

 



Leave a Comment!

Hey! You really should Sign In! | New Here? Then Register!

Name:

Email:


Verify that you're real! Enter the word below!



Remember my personal information


Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail? (make sure your e-mail is accurate!)


 

.