allkpop

there is no way in hell the korean version of boys over flowers was better. As expected korean version got most votes because of the horny fan girls who cant calm down. As always people always judge first by the looks and leave talent until last. Hipocrites.

As far as I know, the manga author does not authorize any remakes within 2 years of a production. If the story of this RETARDO (pardon my word) version is loosely based on -or- “inspired by” the original manga, then it explains “H4” instead of “F4”.

So many people here are just Korean biased. Honestly Taiwan looks the best, and had the more realistic story.

in my opinion they aren’t bad looking.and drama looks good to. i can see a lot of cute scenes! :D i don’t have intention to watch it cuz i watch just korean stuffs so… LOL well but Chinese Jan Di looks pretty better than Jan Di LOL

well..
the taiwanese was the first one that i saw, then japanese, but i prefer the korean..
coz the taiwanese was kinda long…the japanese a bit short..

No offense! But they don’t have the looks. Korean F4 have the best looks among all versions. Jap & Taiwain F4 are good too, but they look a bit old for the characters.

Chinese is better than Taiwanese that’s what I can say. But the KOREAN VERSION DOMINATES ALLL!!! I think Korean Actors has better acting skills than taiwanese & chinese but also Japnese actors too. But it’s just that Japanese actors lacks the skill of being dramatic and the way they act it’s hard to believe. KOREAN IS THE BEST!

edit: sorry that i said that about the taiwanese cast its just that i have really low self esteem and i just cant stand people who are way much better looking then me, please take pity on me..i am now going to cry in my room and ponder on why i dont have anybody who loves me..

^ in the taiwanese one, the setting starts in university not highschool….

Some of them are cute in the pics.
Better than that original picture.
And the girl looks better than the main characters in most of the other versions.
From the looks of the MV this version seems a lot different…
Maybe I’ll end up watching it.

Not bad.
I like the OST ^^ So nice~
and the GIRL is PRETTY ^_^

Lol I don’t understand why people are saying dumb shit about the Korean Version! Just deal with it, IT WAS THE BOMBB!!!! If you compare it to the other versions, it was more dramatic and the acting skills were very well done. So don’t brush your anger on their looks! Korean BBF ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

The girl is pretty though ^-^

xD H4.  The guys look pretty hot.  I hope it’s a good one.

the guys from the Japanese version were hottt, especially matsuda shota & shun oguri!

I SUCK!!!!!! YAY!!!!!

This drama has copyright violation written all over it. Didn’t the original author and her publisher stated that there can not be another Hana Yori Dango adaption until 2011?

Ok. I’m pretty excited. HYD story FTW!!
I hope they have better acting here than the Korean version though. I don’t like what they did Domyogi’s hair here! lol it’s not curly!

I like Japanese F4 the best because I think overall each person protrayed their roles the best like in the manga. For soujirou’s role I think Kimbum did the best job though. 

~another picture of them http://flytotheskylover.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/chinese_f4_20090204_*.jpg

o gosh ....
Korea witout a doubt…. the chinese teaser made me think DMZ was the violin guy ><
id have to say taiwan 2nd, how many more can they make?
im hearing india has one too >.>

i’m actually gonna watch dis (since i hav hunantv) even though im kind of sick of bof. the manga story was the most interesting and was great. all the dramas got boring towards the end. it took me forever to finish watching the korean version(i was stuck on ep 17 for 3 months XD), never finished the taiwanese vers, nd not interested in watching the jap ver. the taiwanese vers was the funniest, the korean was the best to look at, nd i heard the jap had the best actors. when i first heard about this remake on hunantv, i was like ewwww. r the serious? they want to live up to all their predecessors? but it seems interesting nd the girl is growing on me. but it woulda been much more interesting if hangeng was in it T.T

I couldn’t even finish watching BOF, even for Lee Min Ho’s hotness. It was just so bad. I’ve seen the Japanese and Taiwanese versions too. I saw the Taiwanese version first, so it has a special place in my heart. ^_^

I’ce seen all the versions of the “hana yori dango ” manga, so i have quyite a knowledge about it but i’m not a judgmentale person, i’ll wait till i see the chinese one to complete my point of view!
but i know taht each time a new version come we are somewhat happilly surprised so i’m waiting and we will see!

There are two guys who I consider hotties the two others are average. I actually think it looks pretty good. I think I’ll watch it.

Um the best has to be JAPAN - without a doubt.

I believe there is no need of making a poll for this because most people have most likely just watched the Korean version. So that doesn’t make this poll fair.

Hahah I agree with 101.

LOL! their domyouji sounded like hyungjoon, that cracked me up!

A CHINA VERSION!!!, i thought it was just a rumor or something!! and three dramas of the same storyline, i dont think i can take it
i honestly can’t choose which nation’s version is better…

LOL they look so so….......eeh yeeeah O.o no korean version FTW

The girl is actually pretty but the 4 boys is like…“WTF?” In the picture they do look better…but in the trailer…OMG. KOREA F4=FOREVER!

Wow, what is so great about the manga, that there has to be so many versions?
I say Meteor Garden was the least good-looking people for F4.
& it wasn’t the best version. Hana Yori Dango comes second.
Boys Before Flower, I think that one was the best. (;
Excellent casting, and they actually followed the manga storyline (as I heard).

I’m definitely going to watch the Chinese version.
I actually can not wait! I’m looking forward to it!

I like both the korean and japanese versions but i think the japanese version was the best. to be honest i only watched the korean one for the gaeul and yijung scenes lol ^-^
well anyways the japanese one the main characters had more chemistry and great acting. Never watched the taiwanese one but i heard that was good, the chinese one doesnt look that bad either.

they’re definitely better than the taiwanese version but not the best… the girl they chose for the main character is very pretty… the guys are pretty hot <3

... ANOTHER one?! ohman.. I wonder what this one’s going to be like. I hope it’s not a disappointment. I think I’ll check it out to compare them.

Japan version is the best so far ! Then Taiwan and Korean the last.
Can’t wait for the chinese version now lol.

H4 means probably means flower 4…in chinese since flower in chinese is ‘HUA’ lol

yuck…ones are uglier than others O_o…

lol blatantly everyone here’s gonna vote for the korean 1… but taiwanese 1 was basically like a classic

Wow definitely not hot….Hopefully they are good enough actors to pull this thing off…And I have to say that in all 4 of these, the actor who plays Jun-Pyo is ugly….I am still baffled by everyone’s obsession with Lee Minho…

he’s supposed to have curly hair!!—;

lol even tho Im Taiwanese but Korean def is the best ~ ^^

ARE YOU SERIOUS??! ANOTHER VERSION??

I don’t know what to say, my all time favorite was the first one I saw, the Taiwanese Version but this one does not look so bad is just that the guys in it are not that hot, they are too skinny and unattractive.  The song was not that bad it was kind of nice. Oh well, we will see how good or bad it is after the first episode.

Chinese Domyouji’s hair is so… fail.

i’ll pass

I can go on and on about Korean version is an epic fail ! But i’m not going to talk about it here -_-, If your’e talking about looks, Korean version of F4 pawns the rest. They have the best look. Because the settings is more current than the other, Korean version also win in the settings department. But plot and storyline, Japanese were the best. So, it’s a half half situation there. I choose Japanese because they have the perfect plot, storyline, settings, casting and music there. After reading/watching hana yori dango for 5 times (Taiwanese->Manga->Japanese->Anime->Korean).. I think I have enough of it :((  and PLUS.. Chinese’ Hanazawa Rui is not handsome/cool at all.. what’s up with the long hair !! blahhh..Okay i’ll stop ranting now..

I loved the Japanese and Korean one. Not so much the Taiwanese :/ I hope the Chinese one will be good!

OMG!! SERIOUSLY???!!! with out a doubt the KOREAN version was the best…but the ending sucked BIG TYM!!! tho….but it was the best out of all the versions…i’m actually curious as to how good the Chinese version to be…& if it can be at the level of all the previous ones….so many versions….now i want to see if Thailand will a Thai series too LOL…i would love to see that happen!!! LOL…

like aways the korean gets the most vote becasue of fangirls the korean version sucked ass i couldnt watch it after two episode it was horrible with mediocre actors and pretty boys that paid for there looks and a actress who should have tan. Japanese had great actors i liked it and the storyline was good. Tawainese had the best looking actors . I might watch chinese one as long as its better the korean one

well let’s just wait for other country’s version. i wonder if the philippines will remake this one.

korea’s best but i think china girl is the hottest xD

Oh they’re not bad at all… buh wtff is tha matter with these asians do they really have to duplicate this drama in every country… can’t they just put some fuckin subs? Huuuuuhhh

the japanese and thai actors look so ugly too eek!!!

In every version, i think the actors for “ji hoo” are the hottestt <3