NEW USER? | FORGOT PASSWORD?
rss
 

Hunan TV Remake of Boys Over Flowers Is A Fraud

127 Comments

coolsmurf in TV / Movies | 13 Feb 2009 - 01:00 AM

 
Image

It was revealed today that the chinese remake of Meteor Garden, an adaptation of the best-selling manga Boys Over Flowers by Yoko Kamio is most likely a fraud.

Japan publisher Shueisha, Inc. who holds the rights to the popular manga had inked an agreement with Group Eight beforehand stating that no adaptations of any kind can be made after them in the next 2 years. A Group Eight representative said today, "When we signed the contract with Shueisha, Inc., it was stated clearly that after our Korean adaptation, there will be no more drama adaptations of the manga within the next 2 years."

Although Boys Before Flowers originated from Japan, it was first made into a drama by Taiwan in 2001 with the resounding success bringing a sequel 2 years later. The Japanese drama adapation followed in 2005 with a sequel and a live-action movie in 2007 and 2008 respectively. All came away with resounding success. Boys Before Flowers is thus labelled by many to bring success to anyone associated with it.

Image
Two years later in 2009, the word that Korea will also be filming their own adaptation generated much interest within the nation and overseas. To protect the value of the manga and the Korean adaptation, Shueisha, Inc. had decided on withholding the rights to prevent others from filming an adaptation of the drama within the next 2 years.

But lately, there was news that Hunan TV together with Days Entertainment Company will be producing a chinese adaptation of Boys Before Flowers and has generated a lot of interest with all the casting, etc already finalised. Filming is expected to commence soon. Many fans are however very unhappy because of the drastic changes made to the story. But with the latest statement by Group Eight today, they are properly doing the right thing.

Image

Group Eight and Shueisha, Inc. expressed that they will be keeping a close watch on the China remake in case their copyright gets violated.



  
 

advertisement

Comments

Qoojunkie's avatar

LOL i thought the domyouji / jun pyo was F.T island’s lee hongki (<3) for a second. but he’s not. :d

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 01:36 AM

3. ho (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

taiwan F4 is the most handsome amongst
other F4

 
no avatar

ROFL..
I see..
good

 
dee-ana's avatar

ahhh….nvm. they not handsome at all wor. except for one. hahaha

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 01:37 AM

6. rice (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

hammer down on those chinese!

 
mia's avatar

I don’t think I’ll be watching this (if it actually happens), I don’t really care for the chinese remake. >_<

 
loosma's avatar

OOOOOOO copyright is serious serious business man


and technically if the story is changed, is it even boys over flowers anymore? or a derivative. hmmm

interesting, I’m very interested on how this happens.

 
Kelly Kim's avatar

the KOREAN F4 is the best
and i dont want to see the chinese remake
the guys look butt ugly

 
sueyunho's avatar

the korean 1 is the best i’ve seen so far! i wont bother watching the chinese one,taiwan 1 was good but China? no thank u!

 
no avatar

haha, thank goodness! that’s really good news!! :D

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 01:44 AM

12. Anna (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

YES. THANK YOU. <3
and thank you Shueisha, Inc! Very smart.
I hated the fact that other countries are trying to use the BOF’s buzz to promote their own, which I think it just a low tactic.

Plus, I’m sure there’ll be hell if other countries try to even tweak their storyline a bit to avoid copyright and call it their ‘own’. I’m sure netizens will be on watch.

 
no avatar

bottom right kneeling down looks like a serial killer

top right guy looks like a clown

 
Bomi's avatar

korean one is the BEST so far….i’m not so excited for this remake…even now since they’ll change the story a bit…and besides the boys in the korean version are way more sexy

 
sassy_girl's avatar

i like the korean f4 they r so hot wow screw 2 chinese f4*_*

 
no avatar

Wow….another remake..Chinese F4 are really cute though…

 
no avatar

wow the chinese remake people look weird and ugly…..and some of them look like their thiry~

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 02:05 AM

18. MusicLover (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

I like the korean version the last : there is something weird in it lol. Best looking F4 goes to Taïwan and best acting to Japan.
But I think a chinese version so soon isn’t good. I like the story but 2 adaptation in less than one year is still too much for me !

 
soupisgood's avatar

LOl i got so excited when i scrolled down and saw the 2nd picture 8D haha

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 02:08 AM

20. j (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

did any1 else notice that in general, all of hyd’s were released in a pattern of 2 yrs, respectively???

 
procrastinator's avatar

umm…..someone please tell these people that china doesn’t quite care about copyright laws. copyright cases are almost never prosecuted in china. they can sue all they want but the chinese government can care less.

 
Lady Tee's avatar

Good thing they copyrighted it…If more remakes come out, the story would lose it’s value! So happy Hollywood didn’t catch on!

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 02:25 AM

23. sdfsdfds (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

well that just shos how low life and shitty they are.. lol. PROCRASTINATOR.. jesus welcome to the 21st century china.. u gotta follow the natural common sense human law.

 
niceheenim's avatar

Good! smile) I don`t like China. ^_^

 
procrastinator's avatar

^23 hey i’m not complaining they let me watch movies online for free

 
Peachdoll's avatar

the jap and korean F4 is still the best.. I don’t think I’ll watch this one

 
Lady Tee's avatar

BTW Coolsmurf…Is there any recent news about the Korean version of Antique Bakery?

 
procrastinator's avatar

^you mean the movie? cause the movie came out last year.

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 02:48 AM

29. barbietch (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

cinko abizzzzzzzzzz… yuck!

 
procrastinator's avatar

the chinese soujiro looks retarted

 
no avatar

lol, but the chinese F4 are ugly. (:

 
schmaltz's avatar

i dont understand… i thought there was already a chinese remake?

 
procrastinator's avatar

@32 no that was the taiwanese version
this is the hunan tv version
and technically the taiwanese version was not a remake seeing as it was the first

 
no avatar

kim bum!
thats all i have to say.

 
no avatar

^^kyaaa.. kim bum my loveeee!! <333 lol
—-
ok good.
if they continue this after two years with the exact same cast, no one will be watching. ok maybe a few will but bleh :/
F4 is supposed to be hot, i think they forgot that during the casting. tsk tsk tsk

 
ShimHaneul's avatar

F4 should look violent+handsome at first.

I think their image is too fragile for F4??!!!!

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 03:48 AM

37. #1CUNT (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP?

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 03:49 AM

38. #1CUNT (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP? 

AND HOW IS THIS NEWS FOR KOREAN POP?

 
ndhaa's avatar

that’s what i like about allkpop, they don’t stick on korean pop too much, so i can get other news as well :D
and i think this news is pretty interesting..
well even if they would make a chinese version i wouldn’t watch it anyway raspberry

 
xiah.junsu's avatar

^ allkpop also reports about currently hot dramas, dumbass.

the taiwan version of domyoji tsukasa is hideous

 
xiah.junsu's avatar

not you, #39, but it’s for #38

 
Freyja's avatar

I’ll be happy as long as we don’t see a Hollywood version.

 
mia's avatar

@ 37 & 38
I think ONE SENTENCE of that question would’ve been good enough, don’t you think? Why are you even bitchin’??
I swear, sometimes I want to slap those people who take these blogs so f*ckin’ seriously…

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 04:22 AM

44. Soji (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

I also heard (most probably a rumor) that Philippines is also remaking it.
It would be interesting if China makes it, i can finally get down to watching Mainland.

 
no avatar

OMG ..
that’s all i want 2 say..
and..
please STOP REMAKE THIS STORY ,ok.^^

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 04:25 AM

46. Soji (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Another thing….I hope those guys are not playing F4! I saw some pretty good looking guys in the Welcome Beijing MV made for the Olympics.

 
cassie.blingout's avatar

Korean F4 iz the best so far..

 
down up

13 Feb 2009 - 04:56 AM

48. J4red (Unregistered User - Sign Up!)

 
no avatar

Wow! Someone in China violating a copyright?!!! Never that! I mean seriously that’s never happened before! No sarcasm..

 

Ok a LOT of sarcasm.

 
prettyboysareAWESOME's avatar

I really don’t give a fig about the China remake. There’s too many already. The Korean one is the last and has satisfied my HYD hunger.

 
lucky_kiss's avatar

I think after watching the Korean version I’ll not watch any other version cuz it’s the best 4 me..

 


Leave a Comment

To post a comment Sign In! New Here? Then Sign Up!

 

a 6Theory Media, LLC. Production

© 2007-2009 allkpop.com | Terms of Services | Privacy | Disclaimer