NEW USER? | FORGOT PASSWORD?
rss
 

[POLL] Battle of the Bands: Best Rookie Girl Group?

608 Comments

lawlietta in Special Features | 23 Sep 2009 - 02:48 AM

 
Battle of the Rookie Girl Groups!

That's right, we're playing Korea's Next Top Female Rookie Group, 2009 Edition! It can go unsaid, but I'll say it anyway - 2009 isn't even over yet and the kpop music scene has been absolutely filled to the brim with girl groups both new and old. These past few months, we've seen duos, trios, quartets, quintets and more bud onto the fertile soil of the Korean entertainment scene, and while some artists have seemingly flopped, others have bloomed.

The question is, which group takes away the crown for this year's best rookie group? Let's take a step back to reexamine this year's top five new female editions to the kpop scene...

After School


Members: Gahee (26), Jung-ah (26), Soyoung (23), Jooyeon (22), Bekah (20), UEE (21)

Bio:: After an influx of "innocent charm" girl groups in the past few years, After School hit Korea with a completely new image - dubbed the "Korean Pussycat Dolls", the original fivesome gave Korea a lesson on what sexy really was. Furthermore, the members have interesting backgrounds; for example, leader Gahee dated DBSK's Yoochun, and Jooyeon was a famous net ulzzang. In April, After School added another member, UEE, bringing the group count to six. Though they've been keeping group activities on the DL lately, you'll see these girls in MV features, big-time endorsements & various shows such as "We Got Married"!

Claims to Fame: Gahee & Juyeon performed with sunbae Son Dambi back in 08, Gahee was part of Korean-American girl group S Blush, UEE played a role in the hugely popular drama "Queen Seon Deuk"

Weaknesses: Despite gaining attention at the start of the year, After School seems to have been put on the backburner while member UEE takes the spotlight with solo activities. We hope this will change with their upcoming October minialbum!

Top Tracks: Ah! (MV | Live Debut), Diva (MV | Live)

( more... )

2NE1


Members: CL (18), Bom (25), Dara (24), Minzy (15)

Bio:: Aptly nicknamed the "fearsome foursome", 2NE1 garnered fans before the group even had a name. Rumors of a "female Big Bang" had been circulating for over a year, so when the new group was officially confirmed, netizens were on it immediately. Since then, YG Entertainment has been excellent in promoting 2NE1 - for example, making a big splash debuting in a CYON CF with big bro Big Bang pre-debut. After setting things on FIRE with their debut, 2NE1 started gaining even more momentum. Since then, the girls have been rolling up fans like pros.

Top Tracks: Lollipop (MV), Fire (MV | Live Debut), I Don't Care (MV | Live)

Claims to Fame: five kchart wins (including Mutizens for "FIRE" & "I Don't Care"), Best Newcomer's Award at Asia Song Festival 2009

Weaknesses: Hype can be a double-edged sword - 2NE1 has gotten heat for being overrated and a product of excessive marketing. Since the girls have gotten A-list deals from the beginning (ie.the aforementioned CYON CF & associating their name with Big Bang, customized earphones from Interscope Records), many consider this foursome to have taken a shortcut on their climb to fame. Furthermore, people are taking a second look at 2NE1's songs due to recent plagiarism controversies that have hit YG Entertainment.

Fan Forum: YG Ladies

( more... )

4minute


Members: Jihyun (19), Gayoon (19), Jiyoon (18), HyunA (17), Sohyun (15)

Bio:: Like with 2NE1, many eyes were on 4minute before they even debuted - a new group with the return of ex-Wonder Girl HyunA, who wouldn't be curious? Anyway, 4minute hit things off with "Hot Issue" and a "candy funky" concept, aka rainbow eyegasm fashion. Though their first song met mixed reviews due to the "spoiled princess" concept, 4minute redeemed themselves twofold with "Muzik", pinning themselves onto the girl group map as a formidable threat.

Top Tracks: Hot Issue (MV | Live Debut), Muzik (MV | Live)

Claims to Fame: HyunA was a previous member of the Wonder Girls & has been featured in AJ's "Dancing Shoes", Sohyun was part of group Orange & was a child actress, Gayoon was featured in Mario's "I'm Yours".

Weaknesses: With 4minute's autotuned pop beats, many are questioning these girls' vocal talents and versatility. Also, many criticize the overemphasis of HyunA and lack of attention given to other members, especially leader Jihyun.

Fan Forum: 4 Minutes

( more... )

T-ara


Members: Eun-jeong (20), Hyomin (20), Jiyeon (16), Boram (23), Q-ri (23), Soyeon (22)

Bio:: Because this group had major line-up changes and was in the wraps for three years, anticipation for T-ara had been building for a relatively long while. Though the group, which was initially a fivesome, released its first MV in April, it lost two members and came back with three new ones to debut yet again, this time on Radio Star. Since then, the girls have been hard at work promoting their hit "Lies" and appearing on various shows & shoots.

Top Tracks: Lies (MV | Live Debut)

Claims to Fame: Collaborations with SeeYa & Davichi with "Forever Love"; Eun-jeong has also starred in many FT Island MVs, including "Lovesick" & "Thunder + Only One Person"

Weaknesses: Cute & sweet concept? You're a few years late! Not to say that these girls aren't gorgeous, but we've seen their concept done many times over... I hope T-ara will bring something completely new to the table soon!

Fan Forum: Diadem

( more... )

f(x)


Members: Victoria (22), Amber (17), Luna (16), Sulli (15), Krystal (14)

Bio:: Unlike the other groups on this list, f(x) essentially dropped out of nowhere - yes, some photos and rumors had been circulating the net for a few months, but most dismissed such comments as mere speculation. Dubbed SM's next "international girl group", f(x) features two Korean members (Sulli, Luna), a Korean-American (Krystal), a Taiwanese-American (Amber) and a Chinese leader (Victoria). Though this group hasn't been around for very long, the fact that they've already risen above the girl group battle hubbub is a success in itself.

Top Tracks: LA cHA TA (MV | Live Debut)

Claims to Fame: Victoria was featured in a number of projects prior to her f(x) debut, ie SHINee's "Replay" & a CF with Rain; Krystal starred in SHINee's "Juliette"

Weaknesses: It's hard to pinpoint exactly what it is, but some kpop fans simply aren't interested in "LA cHA TA". Whether it's because of the lack of an electronic pop beat or the muted fashion concept, certain guys & gals just aren't feeling it. Better luck next concept/song, girls!

Fan Forum: Aff(x)tion

( more... )

...And this is just scratching the surface - there's also Brand New Day, Honeysh, Navid, Sunny Side, Pink Heart, Devil & Angel, 7Size, Twiny, HAM and many more... plus, we have yet to see Nine Muses, Secret & Lady Collection. To say that the music scene is alive and oversaturated is an understatement!

We still have a few months until award season comes around, but you be the judge – which rookie girl group do you want to see more of? We know this will turn into a popularity contest, so remember to keep talent & potential in mind. Now let the battle begin!


Which 2009 rookie girl group do you want to see the most?

  
 

advertisement

Comments

panamakira's avatar

wow suxs for after school and tara….i didn’t know the age difference in 2NE1 was so great….Dara 24? wow…..she’s older than me and she looks like she’s 19….

 
veeyenn's avatar

go go 2NE1 :]

 
no avatar

In b4 2NE1 fags

Oh look, I was too slow.

 
xmekix's avatar

2009’s best girl group? of course its 2NE1

 
no avatar

dang, f(x) already a competition for 2ne1, hm? I think those two groups are more capable of winning. Although I think 2ne1 deserves this one, for sure.

 
no avatar

of course 2NE1

 
-Aaron-'s avatar

<3 tw…tw…tw…2ne1! xD

 
Summer Time!'s avatar

The winner is pretty obvious already. These polls are pretty useless lol.

 
OnlyYou's avatar

2ne1!!
I love their songs ^^

 
no avatar

f(x) in second place they done nothing 4minute should be second.

 
mahmuda's avatar

wow 2NE1 are defiantly the best!!! i just love them!

 
no avatar

yeah 4minute should be in second place..

 
kimbumkillersmile's avatar

soo many girls!

 
WgSunbethy's avatar

100% 2NE1 All the WAy!!!!

 
no avatar

2ne1! Though i think they’re kinda overrated, but I like em FIERCE! Plus they’re YG Baby!

 
G-Dragon's avatar

Look at all the fan-GIRLS of 2NE1…

 
no avatar

we all know who’s gonna come out on top. i’m not the biggest 2ne1 fan but overall I have to give them my vote.

 
Chansung2NE2's avatar

1.2NE1 2.f(x) 3.4minute 4.After School 5.T-ara

 
WgSunbethy's avatar

Phil. Really Love 2Ne1 a LOT HWaiting DARA DAra Go go 2NE1<_<

 
drunkengaga's avatar

2ne1 is the game so their in for fame… of course 2ne1 wins… there’s nothing really great about these other girl groups.The TRENDS BEGAN with TWENTY ONE.. ;0

 
no avatar

2ne1~~i think 4minute should be second cuz i think their song are way better than f(x)~~and f(x) didn’t do much~~

 
Chenz's avatar

2NE1s got my vote for now

but f(x) is growinq on mee
im a sucker for SM artists (:

 
marikit's avatar

“..many consider this foursome to have taken a shortcut on their climb to fame.”

I think this is happening to f(x) as well. They don’t have a strong song and material as of now, and yet they are surpassing, say 4minute because people were saying that they were from SME. Anyway, I think it’s 2ne1 this year for me, followed by 4minute. I want After School to come back, and f(x) to have a better/stronger material. As for T-ara…I don’t know. This is just me, but I find HAM more exciting to watch than T-ara. Maybe they should come out with a better material as well?

 
CarlaYoochun's avatar

I didnt vote because I was torn between F(x)‘s Luna and 2NE1’s Bom! Both of them have amazing voices!Go f(2NE1)!!

 
bitchyfangirl's avatar

Torn between 2NE1 and f(x)

 
windstar!~'s avatar

2NE1’s got this in the bag(s)

 
SUPERvivien's avatar

F(X) is loveeeeeeeeeeeee <3
but 2NE1 is pretty damn awesome too though.

in the end i chose f(x) cos i thought 2NE1s gonna bag every newcomer award anyway xD

 
no avatar

haha 4minute became 1st

 
GrandmaXD's avatar

2NE1 is <3 until f(x) came along with AMBER <3
love 2NE1 all around, for their songs, looks and dance =D
love f(x) for AMBER LOL yeah.. lachata aint my favorite song
after school is so hot. dayum so sexy wink
4minute um their song musik is pretty good, i like jiyoon’s part but the rest… im just not a big fan?
t-ara is okay i guess.. they didn’t really capture my attention..
i watched HAM’s MV last night and they could’ve came up with a better title for their song.. tt dance sounds so childish..

 
Summer Time!'s avatar

@21 -> No…After School started the trend.

 
omgareusrs's avatar

f(x)!!!! I love Lachata (:

 
dainty_love's avatar

2ne1 wins.. why am i not surprised?

 
bebesandee04's avatar

2ne1!!!
YG fighting!!

 
Kentukey's avatar

2NE1 go go go Black Jack beat that

 
iheart's avatar

2ne1 NO DOUBT!
the title just flung to me and 2ne1 came to mind first

 
iDoraemon's avatar

All of you are obviously retarded.  None of the bands mentioned are the best rookie girl group of 2009.  Here’s why.


After School obviously has an identity crisis and can’t figure out if they want to be sexy or cute.


2NE1 has yet to come out with an original hit ballad song.


4minute is a poor girl’s 2NE1.


T-ara can’t even decide what name to stick with.  Tiara anyone?


f(x) isn’t even an all-girl band.  What?  That’s a chick?!


Obviously, the best rookie girl group of 2009 is…TwinY.


/end sarcastic rant

 
2double_J's avatar

although i’m not a fan of 2ne1 or any girl group in particular
but i’ve got to give this award to them
because in just 4 months after debut
they have achieved so much like having two hit songs, etc.
and also their live performances are far from being a rookie.

 
no avatar

After School easilly.

 
Kouyama's avatar

Err I like a bunch of these groups, some more than others.. but obviously had to vote for 2NE1.. like people have said, f(x) hasn’t done much..

 
xiah.junsu's avatar

i want to see some serious catfight going on between 4minute - 2ne1 & f(x) - t-ara. yes, LITERALLY catfight

 
kaorishae's avatar

2NE1 FTW!!! It’s pretty obvious! i ♥ 2ne1!!! CL>Dara>Bom>Minji (~^_^~)

 
amasakireyoko's avatar

F(x) all the way! XD To me their style might still be girlie and clique with other girl groups (especially SNSD) with their debut LaChaTa but the song slowly grows on you and the girls do have talent. They just need time to prove it to the world. Especially Amber and Luna. I believe they have MASSIVE potential. Just needs time. Krystal too, but I’m not too sure yet… to support her this early… anyways. For me, it’s F(x) all the way!!! X3

 
goldenGAZE's avatar

After School in the house~

Just need them to comeback!!!!

 
Forsaken's avatar

2NE1 without a doubt, accomplishments show.

 
no avatar

honestly… after school is the best… they are underrated and they are super talented… didnt gain fame from riding on the success of other bangs (aka big bang)... hopefully they will release new and stronger material and show the world their potential! AFTER SCHOOL!!! <3

 
ambot,..'s avatar

i’m not even a fan of any of them,..
but i can definitely tell who is going to pawn this.
just look at the result,..

 


Leave a Comment

To post a comment Sign In! New Here? Then Sign Up!

 

a 6Theory Media, LLC. Production

© 2007-2009 allkpop.com | Terms of Services | Privacy | Disclaimer