Welcome to our community
Discussion in 'K-POP' started by aaaanneee, Mar 20, 2017 at 12:38 AM.
P.S. Please vote objectively.
Seohyun's been in the industry for 10 years, Jihyo for 1year and 5 months . It isn't quite fair because Seohyun's had a lot of time to improve while Jihyo is just beginning her career.
Seohyun has better technique I guess but I like Jihyos voice better.
I read that Jihyo trained for something like 10-ish years though? Unless that information was false/mistranslated. Based on that, I'm not exactly sure where she's going to improve if she hasn't already.
IM A ONCE, yet I voted for Jihyo.
This type of competition doesnt make sense. One is a too much of a sunbae, while d other is only a rookie.
Jihyo actually sounds really good?? what I don't get is why, in Twice, her vocals don't shine like that. maybe it's the dancing that tires her out but (sorry not sorry) she's on a whole other level compared to the rest.
Okay. To make it fair, then I'll give you a video of Seohyun when she only debuted for almost 2 years.
Look up the comment above. I gave a video of Seohyun when she just debuted for almost 2 years at that time.
Seriously, Seo was better at debut than Jihyo is now, you do not get to start songs as often as she does for sm unless you can sing. There are plenty of clips out there, search, learn.
She went into jype for acting
Seohyun all the way!!
Wasn't she training to be an actress for the better part of those 10 years though?
This true but Jihyo has been training for 10 years also
La i wasn't gonna search for them but the good song ep, and the 1000 song show along with the radio lives Seo ftw. love the 4 of them singing INTW
im a ONCE but i vote seohyun. if tzuyu's live vocals are more stable than jihyo's there's a problem there.
Seohyun in her first year of debut could outsing all of Twice. Sorry but there really is no contest here.
Seouhyun, but not that far
Jihyo has a nice voice but Seohyun is better vocalist than jihyo imo
I don't think it's fair to say the dancing is the cause behind why her vocals don't shine. Other girl groups such as the one brought up here can dance and have harder choreos but still show off their vocals in an impressive manner. Technically speaking, JYP should give them songs that show off their vocal prowess more, the best way to test that would be in the second half of the year and if they use a different concept.
seohyun for me cause her voice is just... smoother to me