Find Friend(s)
Chat
CHAT ROOMS
KPOP Lounge
KARD Chat
BTS Chat
JYP Chat
SM Chat
G-Friend Chat
YG Chat

Music Releases, Special Features, Original Features

[MV & Album Review] TWICE - 'Signal'

By eric_r_wirsing   Wednesday, May 17, 2017   51,930   5,240   32
twice

4

0

SHARES
  1. Google+


TWICE -- SIGNAL

Track List:


1. Signal
2. Three Times a Day
3. Only You    
4. Hold Me Tight   
5. Eye Eye Eyes
6. Someone Like Me



By now, you've probably heard about TWICE's comeback. It's hard not to hear about it, as video views keep piling up and their new JYP-penned song "Signal" hitting an all-kill. So, without further ado, here's what their new EP 'Signal' sounds like...




It kicks off with the J.Y. Park produced title track "Signal," which, quite frankly, is not as strong as their previous title songs. It lacks the energy of "Like Ooh Ahh" and the charm of "Knock Knock." It also sounds like several songs that were just mashed together, so the flow is really off. To make matters worse, the intro is really annoying. Once the song gets going it does get a bit better, but there are those awkward chanting parts which isn't musical and boring.




Now, "Three Times a Day" is a really nice slow jam. The girls sound equal parts fierce and sweet, and it's a magical combination on this tune. This tune is one that uses all the girls' vocal strengths and is interesting in its own way. I'm not sure I quite understand the dial tone at the end, but it's not terribly jarring. 



"Only You" is a more frantic affair, but doesn't take it too far. It starts out like that at the start but acquires a more comfortable pace as the song gets going. It's lively and catchy, bright and repetitive. The use of "Only" as a hook was a good choice, and it really gives the tune some punch. And a shouted "Only Love, Always Love" during the chorus just makes this track that much better.




"Hold Me Tight" has that trademark cute charm that I was looking for from TWICE. It's a pretty standard fare, but it seems like it's a song that was made for tons of aegyo, especially the ad-libs in between each line, and there are adorable raps that fit well with the tone to the track. It's all meant to make you jump around and put a smile on your face. It's not a great tune, but it is fun.



"Eye Eye Eyes" tries to capture that same charm that the previous track did, but doesn't quite get there. Or maybe more properly it would be that it goes a little overboard. There's a weird almost country-western beat in parts, along with some music box effects. The raps are more awkward and just sound like talking. The chorus is okay, but I'm not a fan of the main verses.





"Someone Like Me" is a good closer. It's a very quiet, unpretentious ballad. It's got guitar and claps, and a nice steady slow beat. The harmony in the chorus is just masterful. There's a nice "gather around the campfire" vibe to this one, and the chorus is beautiful and expansive. This particular track is a delight for my ears.

So overall, you have four good tracks and a couple that aren't so good. The real problem for me is the title track. It's a popular song, but not particularly pleasing to the ear. The same way Budweiser might be a terrible beer, but it's the most popular. And when you're promoting with it... I'm a fan, so I was looking forward to this comeback. In any case, it's not a bad EP, but it needs a little more to push it to "great" status.

MV REVIEW




Well, aside from the awkward song, the MV is kind of funny. An alien lands... a blue alien with a rather cartoonish cranium. The girls stick him in a classroom and try to get his attention. They fail. Badly. There's a twist ending, but I'm not going to ruin it for you.

Of course, the implications of shipping humans and aliens are outside the boundaries of this review.



So the girls of TWICE continue the supernatural bent, this time with aliens. There are some cute sequences such as a bunch of Dahyun clones running around in the background, and Mina trying to hypnotize the alien only to put herself to sleep. As much as I'm not a fan of the helpless girl tropes, I still found myself laughing.  

The dancing is a little lackluster. I don't feel that it was meant to be much, and we don't see a lot of it here anyway. What we do see is a little thin, and laced with aegyo. A fair amount of it. I could care less about aegyo either way, though when done really well it's fun.



The wardrobe was fairly cute. These girls have definitely grown up and JYP is apparently not shy about reminding you of that. That's likely one of the selling points of the video, and I can't say that I didn't enjoy watching them. There's a definite visual aspect to K-pop and they milk it well. I am glad that they didn't go over-the-top sexy.

It's not a bad MV overall. It's not the best I've seen, but hardly the worst, and had some fun effects. And at least there was a slight plot to link the whole thing together. It's satisfying, if not particularly grandiose. And the twist ending is just the cherry on top.  

Score


MV Relevance...........7
MV Production..........8
MV Concept..............8

MV Score: 7.6


Album Production.....7
Album Concept.........7
Tracklisting...............7

Album Score: 7

OVERALL................7.3

SEE ALSO: TWICE go unnoticed in Times Square during "TT" cover performance

Get K-POP Merch @ allkpop The Shop


YOU MAY LIKE

GET AKP IN YOUR INBOX!

Tags:

  1. TWICE
  2. signal


Luna_latte93 Monday, May 22, 2017

I'm not even gonna be nice, but more honest and blunt, the whole album as a flop for me despite ironically hitting an all kill. most of the songs were kinda....empty for me. It doesn't give me the urge to listen to it again compared to their previous comebacks. If you guys like it, then good for you, but to me, it's just blah....

 0
 0Reply Report Share

FragleDagle Luna_latte93 Monday, May 22, 2017

"If you guys like it, then good for you" yet you dislike comments for people liking it, but don't reply directly. Pretty shallow if you ask me, but don't worry, I won't dislike your comment, because I can handle people having different opinions.

 0
 0Reply Report Share

AyanaShinozaki Saturday, May 20, 2017

"there are the awkward chanting parts which isn't musical and boring", "or maybe more properly" I respect everyone's personal opinion of the album, but wow the grammar is terrible in this review. Did Allkpop get an eight year old to write this, and do they not hire editors to proof read their articles.

 1
 0Reply Report Share

zfasya Friday, May 19, 2017

6.45/10

 0
 1Reply Report Share

SwiftFoot Thursday, May 18, 2017

In my first listen, I would've agreed that the beginning "rap/talking" part was annoying, but now it's grown on me. Plus is makes Jeongyeon's lines sound really nice after :DThe only other song I could tolerate was "Someone Like Me". Maybe I'm just too old, but generally for me, albums from JYPE are pretty boring overall, I feel like there's a lot of filler tracks, or tracks that just don't do it for me. (Although I loved 15&'s first album). The MV was really cute; I always like that their "love interest" is something weird XD

 0
 0Reply Report Share

enjiaxx Thursday, May 18, 2017

i would say signal may not be that appealing to many people but most of their side tracks in the album is pretty good

 2
 0Reply Report Share

YesIAm Thursday, May 18, 2017

My granma dying breath is more pleasing than this whole album

 3
 3Reply Report Share

onceinmylife Thursday, May 18, 2017

B tracks were amazing! I got "only" on repeat!

 1
 0Reply Report Share

queenbetchreturn Wednesday, May 17, 2017

0/10 the whole album

 6
 2Reply Report Share

AkaneHagaPlus Wednesday, May 17, 2017

i give them 5.8 tho, this guys in akpop is a nice guys

 1
 1Reply Report Share

Sandyuval AkaneHagaPlus Wednesday, May 17, 2017

That's always the same with you thrices. Just people with no education whatsoever. Learn how to write proper english. Geeeeez. Huge retard.

 2
 3Reply Report Share

SwiftFoot Sandyuval Thursday, May 18, 2017

Bruh, maybe you shouldn't tell people to "write proper english" when you're grammar is subpar. Also, you don't need to know english to have an opinion. You would think international kpop fans would have a little more understanding since, you know, we listen to music in another language and all.

 2
 0Reply Report Share

SoneElvis433 Wednesday, May 17, 2017

ugh. totally ignored this review of signal. I knew allkpop would hate on it LOL. I LOVED SIGNAL AND AM PROUD SOOO HAAAAAA <3 (where my ONCE ATTTT)

 2
 3Reply Report Share
Load More Comments

CONNECT WITH ALLKPOP

  1. Follow us on Instagram
  2. Subscribe on Youtube
  3. Follow us on Google+

BRAND PARTNERS

forever
forever
$18
kimi
kimi
$23
23
23
$23
15
15
$15

MORE STORIES